My 360/ps3 prehype scores/guesses

I think when it's all said and done at least in the next year... I wonder how many I will be right on.

ps3-

Uncharted 2-9.5

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8.5/9

Ratchet-9

GT5-10

White Knight Chronicles-8.5/9

Demon's Souls-8.5

MAG-8.5/9

Mod Nation Racers-8.5

360

Forza 3-9.5

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-8.5/9

Halo ODST-9

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5/9

Crackdown 2-8

Balled of Gay Tony/Lost and Damned Compilation-8.5.

The trend continues imo. The 360 has a wide selection. The ps3 has some really good stuff. But they both do ultimately.

360

Forza 3-9.5

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-8.5/9

Halo ODST-9

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5/9

Crackdown 2-8

The trend continues imo. The 360 has the wider selection. The ps3 has some really good stuff. But they both do ultimately.

Walker34

I agree with everything except the Halo ones. It's too early to hype Halo reach, and ODST might be full price-- that'll pretty much make it impossible to score a 9.

Uncharted 2, God of War III, Mass effect 2 and Alan wake I could probably all say 9/9.5 but i'll leave it as is for now. It's pretty much the difference of GOW and Uncharted getting 9.3's and 9.4's and MAss Effect 2 and Alan Wake getting 9.2's and 9.1's.. Everything else i'm not changing. Halo ODST will get a 9 to me. Even. If Infamous got a 9. Halo ODST is comparable. Splinter Cell is the equivilant of an 8.7 etc..

just a cuz, heres my scores:

Gran Turismo 5 - 9
God of War III - 9.5
Uncharted 2 - 9
Heavy Rain - 8.5
MAG - 8.5
White Knight Chronicles - 8.5
Demon's Souls - 8.5
R&C A Crack in Time - 9
Singstar: Pop Edition - who cares
Motorstorm: Arctic Edge -8.5/9

ModNation Racers - 8/8.5
Halo 3: ODST - 8.5/9
Forza 3 - 9/9.5

Modern Warfare 2 - 9

Assasians Creed 2 - 8.5/9

i counted out titles that i thought were too early to be put in

Oh I forgot MAG and Mod Nation Racers.. Just added. I also added Balled of Gay Tony for 360 to even things out. I didn't know tehre was a new motorstorm coming. I thought it was just ps2 and psp?

The trend continues imo. The 360 has a wide selection.

Walker34

hows the trend looking now that i evened things up

i mean you put halo reach 4Q 2010 most likely 2011

and tba crackdown?

just a few tweaksto even it out

ps3-

Uncharted 2-9

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8.5

Ratchet-8.5

GT5-9.5

White Knight Chronicles-8

MAG-9

Demon's souls- 7.5/8

ModNation Racers - 8

FFXIV-9(Since you added Halo Reach both tba 2010)

The Last Guardian-9(Since you added crackdown 2 both tba)

360

Forza 3-9

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-9

Halo ODST-8

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5

Crackdown - 8

both have great games... but now that its not stacked unevenly by data you can see the real trend "and i low balled some"

not hating on the 360 but your list was a joke

Eh, I'll give it a whack.

ps3-

Uncharted 2-8.5, maybe 9.0 (based on previous Uncharted scores)

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8

Ratchet-8 (Gamespot panned the first one. I don't see the second doing any better)

GT5-9

White Knight Chronicles-7.5

MAG-8

Mod Nation Racers-9

360

Forza 3-9

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9.5

Spinter Cell Conviction-8

Halo ODST-8

Left4dead2-8

I think when it's all said and done at least in the next year... I wonder how many I will be right on.

ps3-

Uncharted 2-9.5

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8.5/9

Ratchet-9

GT5-10

White Knight Chronicles-8.5/9

Demon's Souls-8.5

MAG-8.5/9

Mod Nation Racers-8.5

360

Forza 3-9.5

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-8.5/9

Halo ODST-9

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5/9

Crackdown 2-8

Balled of Gay Tony/Lost and Damned Compilation-8.5.

The trend continues imo. The 360 has a wide selection. The ps3 has some really good stuff. But they both do ultimately.

Walker34

your list is a joke right

Halo reach

crackdown

and dl content

who you trying to fool yourself?

thereareso many great multiplat games this year I say its a tie:roll:

[QUOTE="Walker34"]

I think when it's all said and done at least in the next year... I wonder how many I will be right on.

ps3-

Uncharted 2-9.5

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8.5/9

Ratchet-9

GT5-10

White Knight Chronicles-8.5/9

Demon's Souls-8.5

MAG-8.5/9

Mod Nation Racers-8.5

360

Forza 3-9.5

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-8.5/9

Halo ODST-9

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5/9

Crackdown 2-8

Balled of Gay Tony/Lost and Damned Compilation-8.5.

The trend continues imo. The 360 has a wide selection. The ps3 has some really good stuff. But they both do ultimately.

Fetus5

your list is a joke right

Halo reach

crackdown

and dl content

who you trying to fool yourself?

thereareso many great multiplat games this year I say its a tie:roll:

[QUOTE="Fetus5"]

[QUOTE="Walker34"]

I think when it's all said and done at least in the next year... I wonder how many I will be right on.

ps3-

Uncharted 2-9.5

God of War III-9.5

Heavy Rain-8.5/9

Ratchet-9

GT5-10

White Knight Chronicles-8.5/9

Demon's Souls-8.5

MAG-8.5/9

Mod Nation Racers-8.5

360

Forza 3-9.5

Mass Effect 2-9

Alan Wake-9

Spinter Cell Conviction-8.5/9

Halo ODST-9

Halo Reach-9

Left4dead2-8.5/9

Crackdown 2-8

Balled of Gay Tony/Lost and Damned Compilation-8.5.

The trend continues imo. The 360 has a wide selection. The ps3 has some really good stuff. But they both do ultimately.

kentaro22

your list is a joke right

Halo reach

crackdown

and dl content

who you trying to fool yourself?

thereareso many great multiplat games this year I say its a tie:roll:

not saying his scores are off or on just pointing out the extra TBA games he added to extend his list

[QUOTE="kentaro22"][QUOTE="Fetus5"]

your list is a joke right

Halo reach

crackdown

and dl content

who you trying to fool yourself?

thereareso many great multiplat games this year I say its a tie:roll:

Fetus5

not saying his scores are off or on just pointing out the extra TBA games he added to extend his list

I thought it was fair. So adding demon's souls and mod nation racers and gtaiv's compilation pack isn't fair? Why not? it can be said the other way around as well. I had none of those orignally but someone complaiend and said demon's souls and mod nation racers. i completely forgot mag. That should have been there and i just forgot it. Demon's souls and mod nation racers are questionable at best. So is gta's compilation pack.

[QUOTE="Fetus5"]

[QUOTE="kentaro22"] Well I believe his guesses are better all of them but Alan Wake wich I believe will be an 8.0 or 8.5.Walker34

not saying his scores are off or on just pointing out the extra TBA games he added to extend his list

I thought it was fair. So adding demon's souls and mod nation racers and gtaiv's compilation pack isn't fair? Why not? it can be said the other way around as well. I had none of those orignally but someone complaiend and said demon's souls and mod nation racers. i completely forgot mag. That should have been there and i just forgot it. Demon's souls and mod nation racers are questionable at best. So is gta's compilation pack.

yeah thats all fair but why is halo reach and crackdown on 360?

crackdown tba

halo reach tba 2010 ... maybe 2011 even

i was saying if you gunna have those add

FF 14 tba 2010 and

The Last Guardian tba

get what im saying now?