Name 1 game on each console rated too high and 1 rated too low here at gamespot

RULES!! You have to name 2 games for each current system. One rated too high, one rated too low.

PS3 - Too high - Assassins Creed

Too Low - R&C should have been at least 8.0

360 - Too High - PDZ - I hated this game. 7.0 from me

Too Low - Mass Effect - One of the best RPGs I have ever played.

Wii - Too High - RE4 Wii Edition - Enough Already!

Too Low - Super Mario 64 - 8.0? This game is classic.

PS3 - Uncharted Should have ben atl;east an 8.5

360- Blue Dragon should have been atleast 8.0

Wii- MP3 should have been AAA.

Ps3- None were rated to high.

360- Halo 3 was rated far to high should have been 9.0

Wii- None.

Wii- Too high: Zack and Wiki. Too low: Twilight Princess

PS3- Too high: Assassin's Creed Too low: Motorstorm

360- Too high: Mass Effect Too low: Mutant Storm Empire

PS3 and 360 too high Assians creed

360 To low N/A

PS3 to low Rachet

WII To high Mario galaxy

WII To low Zelda

Ps3 - Too High - Call Of Doodies 4 - Short single player, too focused on MP.

Ps3 - Too Low - Folklore deserved AAA status, one of the best games I've ever played.

Xbox 360 - Too High - Halo 3 - Like many sports titles, they just phoned this one in.

Xbox 360 - Too Low - Mass Effect - Should have been GOTY 2007

Wii - Too High - Excite Truck - no modes makes me a sad panda

Wii - Too Low - Trauma Center: Second Opinion - Skipped over, but a damn good game, and my gf swears by the series.

Ps3 High: none lol, Low: Uncharted

360 High: Halo...i didnt like it as much as i thought i would, Low: Bioshock shoulda been a 10 :)

PS3 High - Dunno

PS3 Low - R and C

360 High -Forza 2

360 Low - Dunno

Wii High - Wario ware

Wii Low - SSX Blur

360 too high: Halo 3. The improvements Halo 3 has over Halo 2 are far too small to get a 9.5.
360 too low: Skate. It got a 7.5 but its worth at least an 8.5 in my book.

PS3 too high: Oblivion. One of the most overrated games this gen. It should've gotten an 8.5. Perhaps a 9.0.
PS3 too low: Ratchet and Clank. Should've gotten an 8.5.

Wii too high: The Sims 2: Castaway. I played this at a friends house for a while and I thought it was extremely boring. It should've gotten 7.0 in my opinion.
Wii too low: Fire Emblem. 6.0 is way too low. An 8.0 would be far more appropriate. Another game that comes to mind is MP3, which should've gotten at least a 9.0.

EDIT: Woot, 3000 posts.

PS3: low - Uncharted or Ratchet i cannot decide. high - I'd like to say Assassin's creed based on everything else i've seen, bu ti have to play it first before i can say this fairly. Conan shouldn't be a 7.0, 7.0 games are still good! Heavenly sword is another one i question, but again i have to play it! Oblivion, i can say for sure! :)

360: low - Crackdown. high - Halo 3 or Assassin's creed. Halo was great, but not nearly 9.5 worthy.. but then again, assassin's creed i'm not sure if its even 8.0 worthy.* Oh, and Oblivion

Wii: low - most VC games, Fire Emblem, Battalion Wars 2, harry potter, Metroid Prime 3, and especially Twilight Princess. high - Monkeyball.. this game is not terrible, but i don't quite agree that it's a AA worthy game.

*just to clarify, like i said in the ps3 section i haven't played it so cannot fairly judge it.. hence why i'm not putting it over halo 3.

360 - too high Halo 3

too low Crackdown

PS3 - too high Heavenly Sword

too low Ratchet

Wii - too high WarioWare

too low Battalion Wars 2, and yeah Metroid Prime 3 should have been AAA atleast.

It's all just opinions but ok

PS3 Too High - Resistance Fall of Man

PS3 Too Low - Ratchet & Clank Tools of Destuction

Xbox 360 Too High - Perfect Dark Zero

Xbox 360 Too Low - Mass Effect

Wii Too High - Warioware: Smooth Moves

Wii Too Low - Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

PS3 Over-rated RFOM

Under: R&C

360 over; PDZ & Halo 3

Under; The Defence Force Game watcha call it

wii: Overrated the machine

Under; The Refund bit on the recipt that says 'refund this gimmick'

dont have a PS3, and havent had a Wii long enough to make any judgements

360

Too high: Halo 3

Too low: Mass Effect

PS-triple

too low: Ratchet and Clank

too high: Resistance: FOM

X360

too low: Dead Rising

too high: Halo 3

Wii

too low: Legend of Zelda: TP

too high: Warioware: SM

360 High: Halo 3, I guess

360 Low: Crackdown

PS3 High: [Insert Lair joke here]

PS3 Low: Ratchet & Clank

Wii High: Warioware

Wii Low: Fire Emblem

Wii:

Too High- Warioware
Too Low- Fire Emblem Radiant Dawn

360:

Too High- PDZ
Too Low- ???

PS3:

Too High- ???
Too Low- ???

*???= Haven't played any games who's scores I don't generally agree with.

PS3:

Too High - Assassin's Creed. (I have it and its not that great.)

Too Low - Ratchet and Clank: Tools of Destruction. (I think its the best Ratchet & Clank game so far!)

360:

Too High - Halo 3 (I played it and I think it's WAY overrated.)

Too Low - Mass Effect (Omg this is a really good RPG that nobody should miss.)

XBox 360 too high Halo 3 should have been a 9.0. too low Mass Effect should have been a 9.0

PS3 Assasins Creed 9.0 It's worth an 8.0 and too low probably Uncharted should have been higher rated

Wii Rated too high Wario Ware Smooth Moves not as good as Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess or Metroid Prime 3. Too low I would say Metroid Prime 3 should be AAA.

360 rated to high- Pd0 should of gotten a 6 that game was total garbage

Rated to low- Crackdown loved that game wish they would make a sequel

Wii rated to high- Warioware a 9.0 ? REALLLLLLLLLY ? I beat that game in an hour :lol:

Rated to low- Metroid prime 3- Game is one of the best of this generation so far

Ps3- Rated to high- None most of them deserved the AA scores they got

Rated to low- Lair :P

RULES!! You have to name 2 games for each current system. One rated too high, one rated too low.

PS3 - Too high - Assassins Creed

Too Low - R&C should have been at least 8.0

360 - Too High - PDZ - I hated this game. 7.0 from me

Too Low - Mass Effect - One of the best RPGs I have ever played.

Wii - Too High - RE4 Wii Edition - Enough Already!

Too Low - Super Mario 64 - 8.0? This game is classic.

SpideR_CentS

PS3 - Too high - Agreed, Assassin's Creed.

PS3 - Too low - Agreed, R&C

360 - Too high - Halo 3. No game that delivers a 6 hour campaign should get 9.5.

360 - Too low - Wow, this is a hard one. Most are too high. "Too low," I would say, probably Crackdown. I had a ton of fun in this game, and IMO it deserved at least 8.5.

Wii - Too high - WarioWare. Are you kidding me? I like it, but it's not AAA.

Wii - Too low - Zack & Wiki. Should've been 9.0.

I like this... one of the least fanboyish forums ive seen in a while here at SW.

360 high - halo 3, low - idk (mostly play the hyped games only)

PS3 high - assassin's creed, low - uncharted

Wii high - Warioware, low - MP3

360:

Too High: Assassin's Creed

Too Low: Virtua Fighter 5

PS3:

Too High: Assassin's Creed

Too Low: Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction

Wii:

Too High: No More Heroes

Too Low: ???

Wii: low-Zelda TP

Ps3: low-R&C high-Resistance

360: high-Halo 3

XBOX360

Too High: Halo 3 (Much too high...)

Too Low: Mass Effect (Great game, minor flaws don't deter me at all..)

PS3:

Too High: Call of Duty 4 (Doesn't deserve it, IMO)

Too Low: Ratchet and Clank Future (Pretty good game, should've gotten a 8 at least.)

Wii:

Too High: Hmm... I think most of the Wii games that scored highly deserve it...

Too Low: Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

PS3

Too high: Resistance: FOM

Too low: R&C

360

Too high: Perfect Dark Zero

Too low: PGR3

Wii

Too high: WarioWare

Too low: Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games

I only own a wii

Too high - Warioware, doubt it would be as good MP3 or Zelda: TP

Too low - Zelda: TP, MP3. Zelda deserves at least a 9.3 and so does MP3.

PS3- Too high - AC

-Too low - R&C

Wii- Too high- Wario Ware

-Too low- TP

360-Too high- AC

Too low- Mass Effect

360 - Too overrated; Mass effect
too low; eternal sonata

PS3 - Too low; uncharted drake

Wii - too high; more galaxy
too low: no more heroes

PS3: too high-Assassins Creed

PS3: too low-Ratchet and Clank

360: too high-Gears of War/PDZ

360: too low-Dead Rising

Wii: too high-SMG

Wii: too low-...RE4?

XBOX360:

Too High: Halo 3

Too Low: Mass Effect

PS3:

Too High: AC

Too Low: Ratchet and Clank Tools OF Destruction (This should of definitely got a 9)

Wii:

Too High: WarioWare Smooth Move

Too Low: MP3

The PS3: Uncharted (too low) Assassin's Creed (too high)

The 360: Crackdown (too low) PDZ (too high)

The Wii: Warioware (too high) ......Zelda (too low)

360

Too High:GRAW2

Too Low:Viva pinata

Wii

Too high:Medal of honor heroes 2

Too low:MP3