Overrated, Underrated and Just Right rated Games.

For Me:

Overrated: New Super Mario Bro's, Metal Gear Solid 4, Grand Theft Auto IV (Great but doesn't feel like a GTA), Call of Duty Modern Warfare 3
Just Right: Uncharted 2 Among Theives, Battlefield Bad Company 2, Red Dead Redemption, Burnout Paradise
Underrated: The Sabotuer, Tomb Raider Underworld, Uncharted Drakes Fortune, Need for Speed Shift

Overrated: Everything

Just right: Nothing

Underrated: What does that mean?

Overrated:Anything I don't like obviously.

Just right:No such thing.I will always complain about scores.

Underrated:Scores I can't deal with because I had fun with the game and that person didn't.

it is so subjective:

games you dont like or cannot get into:Overrated

games you really like:Underrated or just right.

so for me overrated are Ico and Shadow of Collosus with their broken controls.

Underrated: - Psychonauts(funniest game ever,funnier than Paper Mario 2 and Mario and Luigi RPGs) with genious level design.Also Beyond Good and Evil,the best Zelda inspired game ever.

All of them have too many.

Every game released in 2011 was overrated

Overrated: Everything I don't like
Underrated: Everything I like
Just Right: Nothing

It's coming....:twisted:

I feel like there is no such thing as overrated or underrated anymore.

If a game didn't sell great and isn't seen a lot, hipsters will ALWAYS talk about it. Demon's Souls and Bastion get talked about constantly despite being relatively indie, and that's great since they were good, but they can't be called underrated (since they are talked about constantly), nor overrated (since they didn't sell amazingly or get butt ton of coverage).

Same goes for a game like GTA or CoD, but the opposite (tons of love from mainstream press, tons of hate from forum hipsters).

Overrated: RDR, Bioshock, Amnesia the Dark Descent, GTAIV.

Underrated: Knights in the Nightmare, Just Cause 2, Radiant Historia, Solatorobo: red the Hunter, Majora's Mask.

Just Right: Chrono Trigger, final fantasy IV, Wind waker, SMB3.

These are all random games off the top of my head.

overrated: Skyrim, love it but definitely no GOTG

underrated: Skyward Sword, at least on Gamespot