PGR4 vs GT5! Who wins?!?! (56k)

GT5

PGR4

i didnt even need to look at the pics, GT5 got this onedef_mode

me too ha... ha...

Sales? GT5

In graphics? GT5, but PGR4 looks dam good.

In how fun they are? GT

But....if the sandwhich was either turkey, or a monte' cristo, I would have picked it.

look some fanboys just voted for Forza while its clearly GT5 got the best looking one, AND they didnt even bother to post, to dodge ownage?def_mode

:| Forza huh?

[QUOTE="def_mode"]look some fanboys just voted for Forza while its clearly GT5 got the best looking one, AND they didnt even bother to post, to dodge ownage?gigantuouse

:| Forza huh?

or PGR...I get confuse of the 2 for some reason, i always think Forza and PGR are the same. my bad

[QUOTE="gigantuouse"]

[QUOTE="def_mode"]look some fanboys just voted for Forza while its clearly GT5 got the best looking one, AND they didnt even bother to post, to dodge ownage?def_mode

:| Forza huh?

or PGR...I get confuse of the 2 for some reason, i always think Forza and PGR are the same. my bad

:shock: wow dignity in SW?!? The end must be near.

From those screen, I'm goign to go with PGR4 just because of hte water effect, but i think things will change later on

EDIT: WHOOPS. OSrry everyone. I mean't to say PGR 4, but i hit hte wrong key.

From those screen, I'm goign to go with PGR 3 just because of hte water effect, but i think things will change later on.

Cedmln

Yes, you are going with PGR 3, and PGR 4 is going to look even better then PGR 3. :)

PGR4 sucks, because PGR3 sucked, its just so boring. I dont like GT series either but damn PGR is worst than GT. They both look like next gen games both look good.ff7isnumbaone

:cry:But BUt Motorcycles :cry:

From those screen, I'm goign to go with PGR 3 just because of hte water effect, but i think things will change later on.

Cedmln

PGR4 looks way better.

Xbox 360 is the King of Racing Games.:)

Enviornments: PGR4. Car Models: GT5.Pro_wrestler

I can agree with that, especially since there really hasnt been much shown in regards to GTs enviorments.

The Lemmings seem to be in denial.

GT5 is superior. No contest.

Sry, im going with PGR4.MrGrimFandango

Dont be sorry, just explain.

[QUOTE="MrGrimFandango"]Sry, im going with PGR4.gigantuouse

Dont be sorry, just explain.

Well since neither are in game, there is really no point, but to compare with just those screens...GT's cars look like toys, they are about as far from looking like the real thing as Forza 2 was, but kind of in the opposite sense. In my opinion PGR3 still has the cars and environments done better than both Forza 2 and GT5, but GT5 isnt complete so its hard to say until we start seeing some more screens.

Some of it has to do with the time that the developers have been developing, Bizarre have already released a game, neither Poly or Turn did when they made / have made their games, respectively. Bizarre can just hardcore tune and tweak their first engine and add stuff, they dont have to take as much time to do it.

You guys have to understand that having extera feature like car painting or weather have implications on the car models (their graphics).

I think Forza 2 would have looked better if it didn't have the paint feature. Would you rather have better graphics or the pain feature?

You guys have to understand that having extera feature like car painting or weather have implications on the car models (their graphics).

I think Forza 2 would have looked better if it didn't have the paint feature. Would you rather have better graphics or the pain feature?

emawk

GT5's models look too dull and Forza 2's models were too reflective, I dont think thats a graphical capability problem. Maybe the dullness one is but not glossy coating.

[QUOTE="gigantuouse"]

[QUOTE="MrGrimFandango"]Sry, im going with PGR4.MrGrimFandango

Dont be sorry, just explain.

Well since neither are in game, there is really no point, but to compare with just those screens...GT's cars look like toys, they are about as far from looking like the real thing as Forza 2 was, but kind of in the opposite sense. In my opinion PGR3 still has the cars and environments done better than both Forza 2 and GT5, but GT5 isnt complete so its hard to say until we start seeing some more screens.

Some of it has to do with the time that the developers have been developing, Bizarre have already released a game, neither Poly or Turn did when they made / have made their games, respectively. Bizarre can just hardcore tune and tweak their first engine and add stuff, they dont have to take as much time to do it.

Well for the most part, the games will not have any cuts in polygons or textures, effects ect.Just because the game isnt in a third person pov, doenst mean that it isnt an accurate dipiction ofwhat the gamewill look like. Poly did do one game, the GTHD download. So they have atleast a little expierience with the hardware. you couldsay that they canjusttweak that engine, it looked amazing. turn 10 on the other hand,gah, there really isnt a reason for the game to look so poor i dont think.

i didnt even need to look at the pics, GT5 got this onedef_mode

Me too but and I was certain that PGR4 pwned GT5.

I vote PGR4- why I hear you ask?

1. PGR4 is displaying weather effects

2. PGR4 is playable- GT5 is a trailer (remember KZ2 E3 2005 anyone? they can make the graphics look as good as they want them to in a trailer)

GT5 HD Image(Best on The Net)

Sry, im going with PGR4.MrGrimFandango

PGR4 >>> GT5

[QUOTE="emawk"]

You guys have to understand that having extera feature like car painting or weather have implications on the car models (their graphics).

I think Forza 2 would have looked better if it didn't have the paint feature. Would you rather have better graphics or the pain feature?

MrGrimFandango

GT5's models look too dull and Forza 2's models were too reflective, I dont think thats a graphical capability problem. Maybe the dullness one is but not glossy coating.

I think the fact that players are allowed to customize their car designs, with a wide assortment of colors an patterns, are the reasons why the cars were too glossy.

I think the developers themselves knew the cars were too glossy for a game that was too glossy. If they didn't, then they were (are) artistically challenged.

pgr has better effects... better car models....better levels.... hmmmm....

gt has avery realistic look tho...

WellanywayPGR4 looks better technicaly and artistically...Blind Cows are in denial.

I voted for sandwhich. Heres why. First of off those PGR4 images are from in game. The GT5 images do look better but if you ask me not a single one of those are in game images. I bet sony's using the smoke and mirrors technique. If the GT5 does look like that I will eat my cell phone.

Sorry everyone. I mean't to say PGR 4, but i typed 3 by accident. Anway. My hopes go to GT 5 anyway.

Also. THeres isn't half the buzz going on about PGR 4 as there is for GT 5.

GT5 looks amazing,to be fair though GT4(HD) and 3 looked amazing in replays,i hope it looks that great in game this time.

The PGR games are always fun and look good so i'll be getting both.

I'm assuming everyone is just looking at the cars.

Becasue I'm looking at the environments and, I'm sorry, but GT5's look like dump.

PGR4's look like they're lit with Global Illumination..... just beautiful.

I'm assuming everyone is just looking at the cars.

Becasue I'm looking at the environments and, I'm sorry, but GT5's look like dump.

PGR4's look like they're lit with Global Illumination..... just beautiful.

Chloroformality

I wouldnt really call these environments dump...

[QUOTE="Chloroformality"]

I'm assuming everyone is just looking at the cars.

Becasue I'm looking at the environments and, I'm sorry, but GT5's look like dump.

PGR4's look like they're lit with Global Illumination..... just beautiful.

asdasd

I wouldnt really call these environments dump...

I'm a lookin' at that picture and, me sorry, but I do.

Poor lems they always get the inferior... inferior graphics and inferior hardware, well actually defective hardware also.

Oh by the way this what PGR4 looks like... Total Garbage, Water effects hide is ugliness... Trully poor lems.