Playing GTA IV doesn't compare to playing Zelda: OOT for the first time 10 ago

Not sure about MGS IV (Since I don't own it) but GTA IV scored at 10 here and at IGN. Playing GTA IV for the 1st time does not compare to playing Zelda: OOT for the 1st time 10 years ago. In fact it doesn't compare to GTA III. If anything GTA III is way more deserving of a 10 than GTA IV.

When I first played Zelda: OOT that game blew me away. GTA IV is fun but not 10 worthy IMO.

Who else agrees with me

I was underwhlmed when I played OoT the first time, GTAIV was much more satysfying, altough I did have lesser expectations about itAdrianWerner

I agree with that. I actually like MM better than OoT. WW is still my favorite 3D Zelda, though.

Oot was the first 3d installation of zelda, gtaiv was not the first 3d installation of gta. I think this comparison is moot, now gta3 vs Oot, thats entirely different. Oot was a great game, tp just didnt have the same awesome feel to it because its still pretty similar to Oot, same with gtaIV its not entirely brandy new. So im voting for gta only because my gta3 experience was far far far better then Oot ever gave me. I had so much fun with Oot, but gta3 consumed 3 months of my life before it started seeing the outside world again.savagetwinkie

[QUOTE="savagetwinkie"]Oot was the first 3d installation of zelda, gtaiv was not the first 3d installation of gta. I think this comparison is moot, now gta3 vs Oot, thats entirely different. Oot was a great game, tp just didnt have the same awesome feel to it because its still pretty similar to Oot, same with gtaIV its not entirely brandy new. So im voting for gta only because my gta3 experience was far far far better then Oot ever gave me. I had so much fun with Oot, but gta3 consumed 3 months of my life before it started seeing the outside world again.chansaet

I don't know. I didn't really like GTA4 too much, but all games from when we were younger look better. It's just the nostalgia talking most likely.

Playing Twilight princess for the first time doesn't compare to the first time with OoT either, yet Twilight princess is the better game. You can't compare this type of stuff anymore. Playing Gears of War 2 doesn't compare to playing Pitfall for the first time on the atari 2600 20 years ago. That doesn't mean Pitfall is a better game.gamer620

I don't know. I didn't really like GTA4 too much, but all games from when we were younger look better. It's just the nostalgia talking most likely.

LittleHands134

[QUOTE="AdrianWerner"]I was underwhlmed when I played OoT the first time, GTAIV was much more satysfying, altough I did have lesser expectations about itBioShockOwnz

I agree with that. I actually like MM better than OoT. WW is still my favorite 3D Zelda, though.

Zelda OoT deserve the score.EuroMafia

[QUOTE="gamer620"]Playing Twilight princess for the first time doesn't compare to the first time with OoT either, yet Twilight princess is the better game. You can't compare this type of stuff anymore. Playing Gears of War 2 doesn't compare to playing Pitfall for the first time on the atari 2600 20 years ago. That doesn't mean Pitfall is a better game.chansaet

Nothing compares to getting my Super Nintendo bundle with Super Mario World. That game... oh my gawd!BioShockOwnz

I was underwhlmed when I played OoT the first time, GTAIV was much more satysfying, altough I did have lesser expectations about itAdrianWerner

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]Nothing compares to getting my Super Nintendo bundle with Super Mario World. That game... oh my gawd!Rahnyc4

just like nothing compares to playing SMB on the NES for the first time. or to some people that are older, playing games on the 2600, 7800 Atari, or just before my time, the colecovision :).

gaming experiences are relative to when you were born imo, OOT i LOVED, but it pales in comparison to the first time I saw mario bros being played.

[QUOTE="AdrianWerner"]I was underwhlmed when I played OoT the first time, GTAIV was much more satysfying, altough I did have lesser expectations about itRahnyc4

It got much better later on, but I never truly understood why some people go crazy over it, it felt very limited, linear and simple. Altough each element was designed very nicely I guess.

Playing Twilight princess for the first time doesn't compare to the first time with OoT either, yet Twilight princess is the better game. You can't compare this type of stuff anymore. Playing Gears of War 2 doesn't compare to playing Pitfall for the first time on the atari 2600 20 years ago. That doesn't mean Pitfall is a better game.gamer620

[QUOTE="gamer620"]Playing Twilight princess for the first time doesn't compare to the first time with OoT either, yet Twilight princess is the better game. You can't compare this type of stuff anymore. Playing Gears of War 2 doesn't compare to playing Pitfall for the first time on the atari 2600 20 years ago. That doesn't mean Pitfall is a better game.GinoNYC

Seriously, GTAIV was severely overrated. Both MGS4 and Zelda OoT had the feeling of every moment in both games would stay within your mind for as long as you live. GTAIV was just repetition an annoying European crying out for the American dream(No offence), and too much realism which didn't belong in any GTA game.

I gave my GTAIV copy to my friend. It was boring and was a 9.0 game max.

While I agree, the fact that GTA4 is a sequel and we have all experiance a 3D GTA, probably many times over makes it hard to prefer the experiance of playing GTA4 over the first experiance of playing Zelda: OOT since it was the first 3D Zelda and something we hadn't experienced before. St_muscat