Playstation Move vs Xbox Natal

Well E3 is less then 2 weeks away which mens huge presentations on both Move and Natal. So who do you think will win?

Personaly I think Move will win, I don't care if it is a rip off of the wii remote as long as long as it is better I don't care. And from what we have already seen with the Move being 1 to 1 with a reaction time of 22 miliseconds and operating in 3D space it seems like it is 10 times better then the wii remote. Also the Natal appeals to only a small part of the xbox fanbase since it is impossible to play fps games, unlike the Move which showed both mature games like Socom 4 and casuel games like little big planet. Also something else to think about is price, with the economy still not 100%, price is a big factor. So with Natal being rumored to cost 149.99 and a PS Move bundle which as PS Eye,PS Move, and a game for less then $100.

1. You need more than one Move controller if you want to play with more than one person
2. Natal supports like 4 people (no controlllerz!!11)
3. Casuals will look at Move and say "I already have a Wii".
4. How many casuals remember the PS Eye when seing Natal?

as I said back when this was in Legacy :P

I think natal is the safest of the two so theres a higher chance of it succeeding, but I am currently more interested in what Natal has to offer as some of the tech demo's theyve shown have really piqued my interest.

1. You need more than one Move controller if you want to play with more than one person
2. Natal supports like 4 people (no controlllerz!!11)
3. Casuals will look at Move and say "I already have a Wii".
4. How many casuals remember the PS Eye when seing Natal?

Modern_Unit

1. Name me 5 Xbox 360 games that would be perfect for Natal!

2. The only thing that Natal can do in FPS is teabag!

3. This is so much fun http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hT1BHz7Ck1o

I still need to see more of Natal to build a proper opinion on it. With Playstation Move having a lot of similarities to Wii motion controls, we already know the technology will work... For Natal, I'm still just a bit skeptical about whether or not it will work as good as some of the tech demos make it out to be.Nerd_Man

[QUOTE="Modern_Unit"]

1. You need more than one Move controller if you want to play with more than one person
2. Natal supports like 4 people (no controlllerz!!11)
3. Casuals will look at Move and say "I already have a Wii".
4. How many casuals remember the PS Eye when seing Natal?

mrmcygan

1. Name me 5 Xbox 360 games that would be perfect for Natal!

2. The only thing that Natal can do in FPS is teabag!

3. This is so much fun http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hT1BHz7Ck1o

Although Natal sounds like a pretty cool idea, bear in mind that it will most probably have a lot of glitches and won't function very smoothly. It won't always be able to perfectly recognise body parts + movement like in all the demos and adverts. That, and I can't really imagine any serious games being made for this. Shooters won't work, RPG's won't work, the only real kind of game that this will allow is first person sports games. Not very much variety.

As for Move, again I like the concept, PS3 + motion controls sounds very appealing. The only thing bugging me is those glowing ball things on the controllers. It was really not necessary and makes the controller look like a child's toy. Move has a lot of potential, I can see a lot of games working with this. But again until it's released there's no telling whether it will run smoothly.

Although Natal sounds like a pretty cool idea, bear in mind that it will most probably have a lot of glitches and won't function very smoothly. It won't always be able to perfectly recognise body parts + movement like in all the demos and adverts. That, and I can't really imagine any serious games being made for this. Shooters won't work, RPG's won't work, the only real kind of game that this will allow is first person sports games. Not very much variety.

As for Move, again I like the concept, PS3 + motion controls sounds very appealing. The only thing bugging me is those glowing ball things on the controllers. It was really not necessary and makes the controller look like a child's toy. Move has a lot of potential, I can see a lot of games working with this. But again until it's released there's no telling whether it will run smoothly.

Falconthefirst

I just don't see how Natal can do "hardcore" games without an Analog stick to move around, I feel like Move will be more versatile so my vote is with Move.

However once natal comes with a treadmill to sense movement, my life will end and I will never leave my house

Lemmings seem to be losing any hope of core/hardcore games support from Microsoft so Natal and casual gaming is suddenly looking pretty hawt. For the rest of us Move.

i wont lie a m alittle exited for both. im want move for game like house of dead and for wii like game. also i want move for using it ta navigate thro menus without a remote and for its voice recognition features and im alittle excited to see how responsive it is in game.