POLL: Which would most likely cause SW to implode? (Uncharted 2 related)

So System Wars, what say you?

I'd rather see it get a 10 than flop, but a flop would cause more chaos.

If Uncharted got below a 9 I think these boards would go up in flames

well 1 would cause massive cow heart attacks with houses being burned in the streets... the other would send lemmings into fits of emo rage and they will destroy the internet. either way tears will be shed, and LULZ will be had.

If Uncharted got below a 9 I think these boards would go up in flames

BPoole96

yes pretty much this. now thats interesting now i want U2 to flop. (im joking) :P

Which would cause SW to IMPLODE? Uncharted 2 getting exceeding hype and getting a 10/10 or U2 Flopping and getting an 8/10?

Probably the 10/10 scenario.

Cows already got plenty of AAA's this year from Sony. The PS3 fans could afford Uncharted 2's floppage due to :

AAA MLB09:The Show,

AAAE Killzone 2,

AAAE Infamous,

AAAE Demon's Souls,

and whatever Ratchet:Crack in Time ends up scoring.

I'd go as far and say, anything less than a 9.5 would cause this place to go nuts:twisted:

I dont see that game getting below a 10 because some of the earlyreviews suggest that the game is pretty much perfect.That xplay guy said it was the best single player experience he had ever had and that the multiplayer was awesome.If it gets a 9 or below people will be mad.

Flopping, as it scoring high would be more expected then it scoring low -- though it matters how low the 'flop' is.

the game is almost perfect,its the best game many critics have seen ,why shouldnt it deserve a 10?innovation?mgsiv and gta hd says hi....

seriusly u2 is the game of the year and instead of being angry for it getting 10s go rent a ps3 and play the game,from what i have seen and read its the best game this gen and deserves a 10.

Cows have hyped this up to 9.5 level, so anything less is going to be considered a phlop.

Cows have hyped this up to 9.5 level, so anything less is going to be considered a phlop.

Jacumov

The UNCHARTED 2 HYPE is recorded at AAA. :roll:

That means a 9 or 9.5, lol :lol:.

----------

Also, welcome to the GS-SW forums, new user! You already have 150+ posts, so keep on keepin' on! :)

Game is going to be great, it's a guarantee.

Cows have hyped this up to 9.5 level, so anything less is going to be considered a phlop.

Jacumov

10/10 would be boring. Now a flop would be awesome!! Imagine the mass exodus and the flaming and the hate topics....one can only dream :P

I can see this game scoring 10, but a flop would make for some really REALLY explosive posts/topics me thinks.

Either way, the SW Mods will need to be out in full-force in the week or so after this game is reviewed here!

Um...the 10? That seems obvious.

Maybe a 7.5 would be approaching the same level of insanity, but a second PS3 AAAAE would trump everything.

Best case scenario is an 8.5 (for those of us who aren't cows and thus would see the humor in the situation), but I doubt that will happen

If U2 flopped it would be the Scribblenauts case all over again. Nothing more than a flash in a pan. Heck, the first Uncharted was a flop. If it scored 10/10, however,the PS3 purists wouldnever let it down that they have 2AAAAEs while Xbox 360 has none. And it won't matter that a 10 for this game will mean less than a 9.5 for SMG either, or that SMG will stillmaintain a higher gamerankings average. Why? Because 'only GS scores count you n00bs'.

If U2 flopped it would be the Scribblenauts case all over again. Nothing more than a flash in a pan.iLiveBy2words

If U2 flopped it would be the Scribblenauts case all over again. Nothing more than a flash in a pan. Heck, the first Uncharted was a flop. If it scored 10/10, however,the PS3 purists wouldnever let it down that they have 2AAAAEs while Xbox 360 has none. And it won't matter that a 10 for this game will mean less than a 9.5 for SMG either, or that SMG will stillmaintain a higher gamerankings average. Why? Because 'only GS scores count you n00bs'.

iLiveBy2words

Uncharted 2 flopping would be FAR, FAR worse than U1 and R&C case combined.

can't imagine uncharted failing... Xbox fans would cry of joy lol

The chances of Uncharted 2 scoring a 10 is more likely to happen than flopping, so yeah flopping would be more likely to cause a uproar here in the forum.

Which would cause SW to IMPLODE? Uncharted 2 getting exceeding hype and getting a 10/10 or U2 Flopping and getting an 8/10?

Probably the 10/10 scenario.

Cows already got plenty of AAA's this year from Sony. The PS3 fans could afford Uncharted 2's floppage due to :

AAA MLB09:The Show,

AAAE Killzone 2,

AAAE Infamous,

AAAE Demon's Souls,

and whatever Ratchet:Crack in Time ends up scoring.

SolidTy

I honestly do not want to see what this board would be like if Uncharted 2 were to flop. It would be like the TP incident only on a much larger scale. I pray that this game gets at least a 9 not only for the sake of more people wanting to buy it, but because of the irreversible damage it would cause if it doesnt.

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Which would cause SW to IMPLODE? Uncharted 2 getting exceeding hype and getting a 10/10 or U2 Flopping and getting an 8/10?

Probably the 10/10 scenario.

Cows already got plenty of AAA's this year from Sony. The PS3 fans could afford Uncharted 2's floppage due to :

AAA MLB09:The Show,

AAAE Killzone 2,

AAAE Infamous,

AAAE Demon's Souls,

and whatever Ratchet:Crack in Time ends up scoring.

tok1879

I'm not saying it would be a dissappointment, but the scenerio you laid out happened with Ratchet and Uncharted 1. Both those games have a Metacritic score of 89-90.

Still, I see it beinig bad either way, I just know that PS fans have a leg to stand on if U2 somehow flops from it's AAA hype.

Obviously, no real gamer wants to see that happen, I'm just laying it out how it plays in my mind.:P

uncharted2 will not get anything under aaa i repeat uncharted2 will not get anything under aaa