Portal 1 owns Portal 2...Yeah its true, Lets face it guys...:(

Nope. And your pro's for Portal 2 includes Wheatley (worst character), but NOT cave Johnson? Yeah you have no idea what you are talking about ;).

Nope. And your pro's for Portal 2 includes Wheatley (worst character), but NOT cave Johnson? Yeah you have no idea what you are talking about ;).

NaveedLife

Portal 1 has NOTHING over Portal 2, let's face it guys

Everything that made the first one fantastic was built upon, and Portal 2 has to be the best sequel I have ever played. Bashing Portal 2 for the lack of Cake? Come on... :roll:

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

Nope. And your pro's for Portal 2 includes Wheatley (worst character), but NOT cave Johnson? Yeah you have no idea what you are talking about ;).

millerlight89

Really? He was annoying most the time. It just got old fast to me. Glados was good and Cave was amazing.

[QUOTE="millerlight89"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

Nope. And your pro's for Portal 2 includes Wheatley (worst character), but NOT cave Johnson? Yeah you have no idea what you are talking about ;).

NaveedLife

Really? He was annoying most the time. It just got old fast to me. Glados was good and Cave was amazing.

Cave Johnson rocks! He's gonna burn everyone's houses...with LEMONS!

Portal 2 is better.

Also funnier.It had JK Simmons.Portal 1 didn't have JK,so Portal 1 loses automatically.

I think Portal 1 is ridiculously overated. Brilliant idea but wasn't much of a game albeit still really fun. Portal 2 expanded on the idea and is totally amazing.

I don't think it pwns it, but i think Portal 1 was better overall. I think the writing was funnier and more witty in Portal 1. In Portal 2 GLaDOS didn't behave robotically enough like she did in Portal 1. Whether it was a design choice to do that or not I don't really care because she wasn't as good. Wheatley had some funny moments but overall the terrible voice acting just distracted me. It didn't sound like "oh this is a character in a game." It sounded more like "Oh, this is some guy in a studio recording his voice off of a poorly written script." As you can see by my signature and avatar I love Valve games. All of them. But the writing and voice acting just wasn't up to what I would expect from Valve (with the exception of Cave Johnson, I loved his character). Other than that I liked it. I think the story was good and I love the puzzles and it was a decent length (took me 14 hours to beat both single and multi player).

I'll voice my opinion:

--Portal 1--

Pros:

-Great, Clever Puzzles

-Very good writing and subtle humor

-Memorable credits song

Cons:

-Way too short

--Portal 2--

Pros:

-Even better puzzles with plenty of new puzzle elements that cause genuine head-scratching moments

-Writing is just as good as the first game, and the humor is more direct

-Wheatly and Cave are hilarious new characters, and GLaDOS remains as fantastic as the first game

-Co-op mode extends the replay value and challenge

-Graphics are artistically pleasant

-Brilliant Voice acting

Cons:

-Nothing ( I honestly can't think of anything)

"1. TOOOO LOONG (the game dragged for the sake of making it longer and became tedious)"

Are you mad? The game is short, both of them are too short!Inconsistancy

"1. TOOOO LOONG (the game dragged for the sake of making it longer and became tedious)"

Are you mad? The game is short, both of them are too short!Inconsistancy

I think Portal 1 is ridiculously overated. Brilliant idea but wasn't much of a game albeit still really fun. Portal 2 expanded on the idea and is totally amazing.

tryagainlater

Spaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaace

I like long games but Portal 2 just dragged and dragged for the sake of adding more hours to the game. Is got old and very repetitive and I couldn't wait to finish it. Portal 1 was the great lenght. I was sad that I finished the game I wanted more...Supah_FLY

[QUOTE="Inconsistancy"]"1. TOOOO LOONG (the game dragged for the sake of making it longer and became tedious)"

Are you mad? The game is short, both of them are too short!Supah_FLY

"1. TOOOO LOONG (the game dragged for the sake of making it longer and became tedious)"

Are you mad? The game is short, both of them are too short!Inconsistancy

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"]I like long games but Portal 2 just dragged and dragged for the sake of adding more hours to the game. Is got old and very repetitive and I couldn't wait to finish it. Portal 1 was the great lenght. I was sad that I finished the game I wanted more...Inconsistancy

I like both, portal 1 was too short, as it would have been better to be double it's length. Portal 2 could have had some extra test chambers and challenges for those chambers, but otherwise Portal 2 was vastly superior. Graphically, music, humour, voice acting, storyline, new elements (goo) were all improved or added over portal 1.

My only gripe is that p2 lacked test chamber challenges (like least steps, least portals, quickest time)... otherwise it was perfect. Oh that and that the xbox version didnt get user made levels... booo.

Portal 2 made Portal 1 look like Superman 64, not like thats a bad thing, Portal is good, buy Portal 2 is miles better

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"][QUOTE="Inconsistancy"] [QUOTE="Inconsistancy"]"1. TOOOO LOONG (the game dragged for the sake of making it longer and became tedious)"

Are you mad? The game is short, both of them are too short!millerlight89

[QUOTE="millerlight89"]

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"] I like long games but Portal 2 just dragged and dragged for the sake of adding more hours to the game. Is got old and very repetitive and I couldn't wait to finish it. Portal 1 was the great lenght. I was sad that I finished the game I wanted more...Supah_FLY

you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youTH1Sx1SxSPARTA

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"] Portal 2 - Cons: 7. Annonying puzzles, needing luck or a walkthough to solve. onebeelo

I never used a walkthrough and do not remember needing luck :P.

[QUOTE="TH1Sx1SxSPARTA"]you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youSupah_FLY

Portal 1 is a great game, but Portal 2 is an instant classic.

[QUOTE="TH1Sx1SxSPARTA"]you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youSupah_FLY

And guess what? There were ZERO luck based puzzles in Portal 2.

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"][QUOTE="TH1Sx1SxSPARTA"]you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youmillerlight89

[QUOTE="millerlight89"]

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"] Luck based puzzles aren't my sort of thing...the level design was poorly done...unless your IQ is 999 your gonna be spending alot of the time just randomly shooting portals and hoping for the best.Supah_FLY

Again, there were not ANY luck based puzzles. Did we even play the same game? :?

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"][QUOTE="TH1Sx1SxSPARTA"]you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youTH1Sx1SxSPARTA

I have a friend that has used strategy guides to get through every Zelda game since OoT came out. If the game isn't a straight forward shooter or action game then he is usually lost.... but he managed to get through both Portal games on his own with no help at all. I don't know how the TC could be having so much trouble lol.

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"][QUOTE="TH1Sx1SxSPARTA"]you should prob go to the doctor and get your head check and make sure ur not clinicall insane lol i kid but ncomeone, you say the first portal is a perfect length? lol its like an hour and a half, maybe 2 hours. Portal 2 is actually the lenght i game needs to be at a minmum. i would have loved it to be longer. lol did you use walkthroughs for portal 2? that completely defeats the purpose of playing the game. that satisfaction you get from solving a puzzle in portal 2 is rare to find in games these days. i just think you dont know how to play games. i pity youonebeelo

[QUOTE="millerlight89"]

[QUOTE="Supah_FLY"] Luck based puzzles aren't my sort of thing...the level design was poorly done...unless your IQ is 999 your gonna be spending alot of the time just randomly shooting portals and hoping for the best.Supah_FLY

[QUOTE="onebeelo"][QUOTE="Supah_FLY"] Luck based puzzles aren't my sort of thing...the level design was poorly done...unless your IQ is 999 your gonna be spending alot of the time just randomly shooting portals and hoping for the best.Supah_FLY

Not liking a game and posting inaccurate garbage about a game are two different things though. I think Valve is one of the most over rated devs around, but I also think you're wrong about Portal 2.

I have the strangest feeling TC hasn't actually played Portal 2 and is just making this thread to annoy everyone who actually did.

not a valve fanboy, didnt think the games were that amazing which is my opinion. but its a fact that the puzzles wernt hard. you used youtube for HALF THE GAME?!?! what age are you? seriously i bet you are under 13. well i hope you are because if not your one dumb teenager

not a valve fanboy, didnt think the games were that amazing which is my opinion. but its a fact that the puzzles wernt hard. you used youtube for HALF THE GAME?!?! what age are you? seriously i bet you are under 13. well i hope you are because if not your one dumb teenager