POTY-LittleBigPlanet v.s. Banjo

Which one do you think will win?

My vote goes to LBP.

LBP easily for me, but Banjo looks to be really fun too.Chutebox

Same.

NEW CONTENDER:

I actually think this looks really fnu, hopefully it'll be another sleeper hit for Wii =p

Out of those two though, I say LBP. Banjo doesn't interest me much, I never played the previous Banjos so the change in tone doesn't bother me, it just doesn't look that fun. LBP looks good just for the editing tools, making your own platforming levels =win.

Banjo, it's a bit more than a glorified map creator. CreepyBacon

I think neither games will be monster hits.

I'm I the only one who doesn't think LBP will live up to the hype? Does the general public really want to spend time creating their own levels? Don't the characters look a bit floaty in the video?

Banjo may sell more just because there are more 360 owners.

Banjo 1,2 & 3 = Win :DSecretPolice

Have they said when BK is going to be on XBLA?

But i think Banjo 3 will be more of a true platformer, despite what a lot of people have been saying when they saw pics (bu, bu, teh cars!?!?! :cry: ), whereas LBP will barely qualify. That doesn't mean Banjo 3 will be the better game, or vice versa, however.

I think neither games will be monster hits.

I'm I the only one who doesn't think LBP will live up to the hype? Does the general public really want to spend time creating their own levels? Don't the characters look a bit floaty in the video?

Banjo may sell more just because there are more 360 owners.

wackoss

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]Banjo 1,2 & 3 = Win :DTheRealMC01

Have they said when BK is going to be on XBLA?

But i think Banjo 3 will be more of a true platformer, despite what a lot of people have been saying when they saw pics (bu, bu, teh cars!?!?! :cry: ), whereas LBP will barely qualify. That doesn't mean Banjo 3 will be the better game, or vice versa, however.

Little Big Planet easily. I would actually just get a PS3 for that game.

Sincerely i'm going to have to go with LBP, looks more inovative than banjo :D Al3x_n90

What makes it innovative? Creating your own level =/= innovative. There's plenty of games out there that have similar features (the biggest one being Garry's Mod) that do just as much, if not more. TBH, i think Banjo 3 is more innovative than LBP. How many games allow you to platform using vehicles?

Not only that, but innovation isn't always a good thing. I'm not saying it's not, but people like you act as if it's the only thing that makes a game good. And that's about the only thing i ever hear when people talk about LBP.

If you still think LBP is innovative, then tell me how it's a good thing in this case.

THIS:

OR THIS:

I have to say LBP, depends how good Banjo really turns out, its just that LBP is so new, and different, that I want it to win so that more games like it are made.

I'm sure both will be really good though..

You see this is difficult. I don't know how fun the 40 levels coming with LBP is going to be fun. The beauty of LBP is the level designs that can be created and its community.

Banjo is limited in level design, but creative in actual agemplay. The beauty is in how creative you can be with the vehicles. Banjo is limited by its level design, but that is expected because it is a 3D platformer7 You really can't compare the 2.

I believe Banjo will with out a doubt be better than the 40 levels given in the game, but LBP is going to be the winner here because of the amount of replay value that can behad in making your own design.

both look to be really fun

i'll be getting both, but i voted for LBP because it's likely to have a lot more variety

You see this is difficult. I don't know how fun the 40 levels coming with LBP is going to be fun. The beauty of LBP is the level designs that can be created and its community.

Banjo is limited in level design, but creative in actual agemplay. The beauty is in how creative you can be with the vehicles. Banjo is limited by its level design, but that is expected because it is a 3D platformer7 You really can't compare the 2.

I believe Banjo will with out a doubt be better than the 40 levels given in the game, but LBP is going to be the winner here because of the amount of replay value that can behad in making your own design.

too_much_eslim

LittleBigPlanet may very well make me buy a PS3.famicommander

lol 9 years old?

Banjo is awesome, therefore Banjo.EuroMafia

This.

Little Big Plant is no slouch either, however.

[QUOTE="too_much_eslim"]

You see this is difficult. I don't know how fun the 40 levels coming with LBP is going to be fun. The beauty of LBP is the level designs that can be created and its community.

Banjo is limited in level design, but creative in actual agemplay. The beauty is in how creative you can be with the vehicles. Banjo is limited by its level design, but that is expected because it is a 3D platformer7 You really can't compare the 2.

I believe Banjo will with out a doubt be better than the 40 levels given in the game, but LBP is going to be the winner here because of the amount of replay value that can behad in making your own design.

wolverine4262

In Banjo if the level design is great then the fun factor comes in how creative the person can be in building his vehicle. I believe just testing out vehicles is going to be amazingly fun.

LBP has coop and Banjo has multiplayer gametypes. I still give the edge to LBP because if you don't like the levels given to you,. you can make levels or hope levels come out that are fun for you. Banjo has to have fun level design or the game will fail. If Rare delivers on that part then Banjo will definately be up there with GOTY contenders this year. This also means LBP will definately be a GOTY contender too.

littlebigplanet

it's not even close IMO

NEW CONTENDER:

*Picture be here*

I actually think this looks really fnu, hopefully it'll be another sleeper hit for Wii =p

Out of those two though, I say LBP. Banjo doesn't interest me much, I never played the previous Banjos so the change in tone doesn't bother me, it just doesn't look that fun. LBP looks good just for the editing tools, making your own platforming levels =win.

bobbetybob

The blob is a puzzle game, according to gametrailers :P

edit: and LBP is an Action-Adventure game according to them as well.

LBP. I've never been more excited about a videogame in my entire life, and I've been gaming for the last 15 years.

Which one do you think will win?

My vote goes to LBP.

SolidCrimson

NEW CONTENDER:

de Blob

I actually think this looks really fnu, hopefully it'll be another sleeper hit for Wii =p

Out of those two though, I say LBP. Banjo doesn't interest me much, I never played the previous Banjos so the change in tone doesn't bother me, it just doesn't look that fun. LBP looks good just for the editing tools, making your own platforming levels =win.

bobbetybob

Not saying that means it wont be good, just not geting my hopes up really.

LBP. I've never been more excited about a videogame in my entire life, and I've been gaming for the last 15 years.

TheLordHimself

Seconded. The very same years too I believe.

I think the people bashing LBP calling it a glorified map editor pretty much don't have a creative bone in their body.