ps3 owners, honestly rate KZ2 and U2

A User Review thread in SW?

-------

I have all the machines, but I don't know why U2 and KZ2 are being targeted.

I haven't fully given UNCHARTED 2 the FULL RIDE.

However, I am a pretty good KILLZONE 2 EXPERT. I would give KZ2 a 9/10, I agreed with most Sites/Magazines/Gamespot. I am leaning towards a 9.4-9.5 for KZ2, but overtime, it's about a 9.1. :)

UNCHARTED 2 seems godly as well, but I haven't had as much time as I had with KZ2, so I can get back to you in a month.:P

i would give KZ2 a 9

havent played U2 yet

Funnily enough, 9.0 and 9.5 respectively :P

Haven't played either of them. o_o

Funnily enough, 9.0 and 9.5 respectively :P

lundy86_4

U2 I give a 9.5 and haven't played KZ2.

I've played Killzone and I'd rate it 8.5-9. The real problem with it for me is that it had no lasting appeal. It got boring pretty quick.

Haven't played uncharted yet.

You can rate them anyway you like, and dont post if you havent played both, kind of makes it pointless. Thanks.blue-blood

Ooops posted at some time, sorry.

Send me the games so I can rate them.. But by the demos (and Uncharted 2s online demo):

Killzone 2: 2/10

Uncharted 2: 6/10

If I had to use Gamespots scoring system.

9.0 for Killzone 2 (would really be like an 8.8)

9.5 for Uncharted 2 (would really be like a 9.7)

[QUOTE="blue-blood"]You can rate them anyway you like, and dont post if you havent played both, kind of makes it pointless. Thanks.drufeous

Ooops posted at some time, sorry.

Send me the games so I can rate them.. But by the demos (and Uncharted 2s online demo):

Killzone 2: 2/10

Uncharted 2: 6/10

Yandere

No offence but you seem to play so many of those japanese sim/role playing games (which imo think are the most boring games in the world), do you actually play any other types of games/like them?

Killzone 2 gets a 7/10 from me. It was a good game, looks nice and all, but the hype and the sucky controls killed it for me. I haven't finished Uncharted 2 yet (about four, maybe five hours in) and so far it's a solid 8/10.

[QUOTE="Yandere"]

Send me the games so I can rate them.. But by the demos (and Uncharted 2s online demo):

Killzone 2: 2/10

Uncharted 2: 6/10

Eggimannd

No offence but you seem to play so many of those japanese sim/role playing games, do you actually play any other types of games/like them?

Yes, but I hate shooters.. On the other hand though Uncharted 2 was an enjoyable online experience so I rated it above a average score (5).

I enjoyed Uncharted 2 enough to get to level 50 in a week also. :w

Killzone 2 is a solid 9.0 for me. Haven't gotten U2 yet and won't for a while :(.

same scores they got here. 9.0 for KZ2 and 9.5 for uncharted 2. IDK what it is but something is keeping me from giving Uncharted 2 a 10.

[QUOTE="Eggimannd"]

[QUOTE="Yandere"]

Send me the games so I can rate them.. But by the demos (and Uncharted 2s online demo):

Killzone 2: 2/10

Uncharted 2: 6/10

Yandere

No offence but you seem to play so many of those japanese sim/role playing games, do you actually play any other types of games/like them?

Yes, but I hate shooters.. On the other hand though Uncharted 2 was an enjoyable online experience so I rated it above a average score (5).

I enjoyed Uncharted 2 enough to get to level 50 in a week also. :w

So I'm guessing the 6 was because you haven't played enough of the single player or you just didn't enjoy it? Because personally I'm liking the sp much more than the online.

Killzone 2: 7

Uncharted 2: 10

[QUOTE="Yandere"]

[QUOTE="Eggimannd"]

No offence but you seem to play so many of those japanese sim/role playing games, do you actually play any other types of games/like them?

Eggimannd

Yes, but I hate shooters.. On the other hand though Uncharted 2 was an enjoyable online experience so I rated it above a average score (5).

I enjoyed Uncharted 2 enough to get to level 50 in a week also. :w

So I'm guessing the 6 was because you haven't played enough of the single player or you just didn't enjoy it? Because personally I'm liking the sp much more than the online.

It was only the demo version of the online, so I would rate it less then the full product.

I'll be nice to KZ2 and give it an 8 since I did'nt give it as much of a chance as I should have.

As for U2, I'm only halfways but so far it's a 9.5.

Both games get a 10 from me. They are some of the best games that I have ever played. HONESTLY.

Haven't played U2 yet, but I gave KZ2 a 9.5.

KZ2? 9.0 great game.

I haven't gotten around to U2 yet.

Haven't played Uncharted yet, but 8 for K2. I'm not too big a fan of FPS's, but it was alright.

I have not played KZ2, my room mate has it so I intend to, but UC2 I can honestly give a 9.5. It misses out on perfection because its not original a few minor issues here and there easily outweighed by what is done right, but overall it is one of the most polished games I have seen. Naughty Dog really put effort into their work and it shows. If you want to see the full review it is in my signature.

KZ2 2/10 Just kidding I didnt play it but I hate FPS games so probably it wont get more than that if I play it :P

Uncharted 2 8.5/10 I dont like shooting games but uncharted was very fun and got a nice story.

Haven't played UC2 to death yet, but would give KZ2 a 9.3-9.4.

Killzone 2 - 9

Uncharted 2 - 9.7

How do you unhonestly rate games?

I'll give Killzone 2 a 8.5 max. The graphics are the selling point of this game and that's most of the hype. The game play is average most of the time only a few times did it get exciting. Multiplayer is kind of fun sometimes but there aren't that many exciting modes to play.

I haven't played Uncharted 2 yet so I can't rate that game. I hope I get it in a few months, I hear it's a great game. :)

KZ2-8.8

U2-9.3

9.5 outta 10 for Uncharted 2. Good multiplayer and one of the best single player games in history IMO.

8.0 / 10 for Killzone 2. I really didn't see what the big deal was. I didn't like the MP and SP was good but not great.

I'll give Killzone 2 a 8.5 max. The graphics are the selling point of this game and that's most of the hype. The game play is average most of the times only a few times did it get exciting. Multiplayer is kind of fun sometimes but there aren't that many exciting modes to play.

I haven't played Uncharted 2 yet so I can't rate that game.

KZ2 9/10

U2 haven't played it yet/10

KZ2 9.4 most intense, realistic and difficult shooter i've played in a really long time. its stunning to look at.

U2 not finished it yet but so far looks like a perfect 10

9.5 outta 10 for Uncharted 2. Good multiplayer and one of the best single player games in history IMO.

8.0 / 10 for Killzone 2. I really didn't see what the big deal was. I didn't like the MP and SP was good but not great.

SpideR_CentS

Killzone 2 - 8.0 Uncharted 2 - 9.0DonPerian

I never understood why some people call it just "good". What made Killzone 2 so great was not the amount of quantity of the game, but quality. And KZ2 is the most exiting fps that I have ever played due to its realistic weighty controls, and also the intense Warzone in it. It gets a 10/10 from me.