PS3 vs. 360: Better Game Library

Who do you think, based on games that HAVE BEEN RELEASED, has the best gaming library. Again, this is mostly a "who has the best exclusives" qwuestion, but i'll leave the topic open-ended. who has the best games between the oft-compared PS3 and 360

Here is a list if you need a little reminding (forgive me if i leave out YOUR favorite)

Microsoft XBOX 360

1. Gears of War 1 & 2
2. Halo 3
3. Mass Effect
4. Fable 2
5. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

Sony Playstation 3

1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
2. Killzone 2
3. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
4. Resistance 1 & 2
5. Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

Best games? 360. Best exclusives? Ps3. That's my take on it.angelkimne

That's how I see it as well.

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]Best games? 360. Best exclusives? Ps3. That's my take on it.bez2083

That's how I see it as well.

For now, agreed.

Gears 1 and Mass Effect arent exclusive :o

Gears 1 and Mass Effect arent exclusive :o

Uptown

[QUOTE="Uptown"]

Gears 1 and Mass Effect arent exclusive :o

tmacscores91

I'm shocked you put down Fable 2 Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts.
You do realize they're not even shooty?

[QUOTE="tmacscores91"][QUOTE="Uptown"]

Gears 1 and Mass Effect arent exclusive :o

Animal-Mother

[QUOTE="bez2083"]

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]Best games? 360. Best exclusives? Ps3. That's my take on it.50u1r34v3r

That's how I see it as well.

For now, agreed.

I'll sign that too.

Who do you think, based on games that HAVE BEEN RELEASED, has the best gaming library. Again, this is mostly a "who has the best exclusives" qwuestion, but i'll leave the topic open-ended. who has the best games between the oft-compared PS3 and 360

Here is a list if you need a little reminding (forgive me if i leave out YOUR favorite)

Microsoft XBOX 360

1. Gears of War 1 & 2
2. Halo 3
3. Mass Effect
4. Fable 2
5. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

Sony Playstation 3

1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
2. Killzone 2
3. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
4. Resistance 1 & 2
5. Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

tmacscores91

Here is my list

My top 30 games so far this generation, 12 are 360 only and only one is PS3 exclusive

1. Fable 2 (360)
2. Lost Odyssey (360)
3. Mass Effect (PC/360)
4. Fallout 3 (PC/PS3/360)
5. Two Worlds (PC/360)
6. Oblivion (PC/PS3/360)
7. Last Remnant (PC/PS3/360)
8. Tales of Vesperia (360)
9. Viva Pinata 2 (360)
10. Kameo (360)
11. Eternal Sonata (PS3/360)
12. Enchated Arms (PS3/360)
13. Infinite Undiscovery (360)
14. Too Human (360)
15. Ninja Gaiden 2 (360)
16. Assassins Creed (PC/PS3/360)
17. Overlord (PC/PS3/360)
18. Blue Dragon (360)
19. Prince of Persia (PC/PS3/360)
20. Lord of the Rings The Battle for Middle Earth 2 (PC/360)

21. Naruto Broken Bond (360)
22. Folklore (PS3)
23. Banjo 3 (360)
24. Bioshock (PC/PS3/360)
25. Dead Space (PC/PS3/360)
26. Dark Messiah Of Might And Magic Elements (PC/360)
27. Viking Battle For Asgard (PC/PS3/360)
28. Zelda TP (Wii)
29. Gears 2 (360)
30. Lost Planet (PS3/360)

Here is my top 30 most anticipated titles in 2009, the top 20 are my personal AAA-AAAA titles, those are some of my most wanted games ever, and will be bought day one

1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)
2. Mass Effect 2 (360/PC later)
3. Two Worlds Temptation (360/PC)
4. Fallout 3 expansion (360/PC)
5. Divinity 2: Ego Dragonis (360/PC)
6. Venetica (360/PC)
7. Alan Wake (360/PC)
8. Kingdom Under Fire 2: Dominion (360/PC)
9. Risen (360/PC)
10. Final Fantasy 13 (360/PS3)
11. Star Ocean 4 (360)
12. Witcher white wolf (360/PS3)
13. Gothic 4 (360/PC/PS3)
14. Dragon Age (360/PC/PS3)
15. Overlord 2 (360/PC/PS3)
16. Resident Evil 5 (360/PC/PS3)
17. Final Fantasy 13vs (PS3, if it comes in 2009)
18. Dungeon Hero (360/PC)
19. Majesty 2 (360/PC)
20. Dawn of Fantasy (360/PC)

The rest 10 in my top 30 most anticipated, are mostly games that may turn out good and even AAAA and are the genre i love (RPG's and WRPG's especially), we do not have much info on a few, but the promise of another amazing huge WRPG is more appealing to me than say another shooter like Gears

21. Age of Pirates: Captain Blood (360/PC)
22. Precursors (360/PC)
23. Black Legion (360)
24. Xavaint Studios RPG (360)
25. Magna Carta 2 (360)
26. Theseis (360/PC)
27. Deus Ex 3 (360/PC/PS3)
28. Demon Soul (PS3)
29. Lord of Shadows (360/PS3)
30. Aliens RPG (360/PC/PS3)

Pics and videos of the above titles

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26715971

Besides 2 PS3 titles, one of which (FF13vs) will probably not make it in 2009, the rest are all on 360, 6 of them are only on 360 too

Here is my most gameplay hours so far this generation

Xbox 360
.
Fable 2 - 120 hours
Lost Odyssey - 90+ hours
Mass Effect - 80+ hours
Tales of Vesperia - 40+ hours
Infinite Undicovery - 30+ hours
Too Human - 40+ hours
Banjo 3 - 40+ hours
Viva Pinata 2 - 30+ hours
Fallout 3 - 100+ hours
Oblivion - 100+ hours
Enchanted Arms - 30+ hours
Eternal Sonata - 30+ hours
Blue Dragon - 40+ hours
Ninja Gaiden 2 - 25+ hours
Last Remnant - 60+ hours

.

PS3
.
Folklore - 15 hours

So, xbox 360 lineup by a million miles for me and my personal preferences

[QUOTE="tmacscores91"]

Who do you think, based on games that HAVE BEEN RELEASED, has the best gaming library. Again, this is mostly a "who has the best exclusives" qwuestion, but i'll leave the topic open-ended. who has the best games between the oft-compared PS3 and 360

Here is a list if you need a little reminding (forgive me if i leave out YOUR favorite)

Microsoft XBOX 360

1. Gears of War 1 & 2
2. Halo 3
3. Mass Effect
4. Fable 2
5. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts

Sony Playstation 3

1. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
2. Killzone 2
3. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
4. Resistance 1 & 2
5. Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

obamanian

Here is my list

My top 30 games so far this generation, 12 are 360 only and only one is PS3 exclusive

1. Fable 2 (360)
2. Lost Odyssey (360)
3. Mass Effect (PC/360)
4. Fallout 3 (PC/PS3/360)
5. Two Worlds (PC/360)
6. Oblivion (PC/PS3/360)
7. Last Remnant (PC/PS3/360)
8. Tales of Vesperia (360)
9. Viva Pinata 2 (360)
10. Kameo (360)
11. Eternal Sonata (PS3/360)
12. Enchated Arms (PS3/360)
13. Infinite Undiscovery (360)
14. Too Human (360)
15. Ninja Gaiden 2 (360)
16. Assassins Creed (PC/PS3/360)
17. Overlord (PC/PS3/360)
18. Blue Dragon (360)
19. Prince of Persia (PC/PS3/360)
20. Lord of the Rings The Battle for Middle Earth 2 (PC/360)

21. Naruto Broken Bond (360)
22. Folklore (PS3)
23. Banjo 3 (360)
24. Bioshock (PC/PS3/360)
25. Dead Space (PC/PS3/360)
26. Dark Messiah Of Might And Magic Elements (PC/360)
27. Viking Battle For Asgard (PC/PS3/360)
28. Zelda TP (Wii)
29. Gears 2 (360)
30. Lost Planet (PS3/360)

Here is my top 30 most anticipated titles in 2009, the top 20 are my personal AAA-AAAA titles, those are some of my most wanted games ever, and will be bought day one

1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)
2. Mass Effect 2 (360/PC later)
3. Two Worlds Temptation (360/PC)
4. Fallout 3 expansion (360/PC)
5. Divinity 2: Ego Dragonis (360/PC)
6. Venetica (360/PC)
7. Alan Wake (360/PC)
8. Kingdom Under Fire 2: Dominion (360/PC)
9. Risen (360/PC)
10. Final Fantasy 13 (360/PS3)
11. Star Ocean 4 (360)
12. Witcher white wolf (360/PS3)
13. Gothic 4 (360/PC/PS3)
14. Dragon Age (360/PC/PS3)
15. Overlord 2 (360/PC/PS3)
16. Resident Evil 5 (360/PC/PS3)
17. Final Fantasy 13vs (PS3, if it comes in 2009)
18. Dungeon Hero (360/PC)
19. Majesty 2 (360/PC)
20. Dawn of Fantasy (360/PC)

The rest 10 in my top 30 most anticipated, are mostly games that may turn out good and even AAAA and are the genre i love (RPG's and WRPG's especially), we do not have much info on a few, but the promise of another amazing huge WRPG is more appealing to me than say another shooter like Gears

21. Age of Pirates: Captain Blood (360/PC)
22. Precursors (360/PC)
23. Black Legion (360)
24. Xavaint Studios RPG (360)
25. Magna Carta 2 (360)
26. Theseis (360/PC)
27. Deus Ex 3 (360/PC/PS3)
28. Demon Soul (PS3)
29. Lord of Shadows (360/PS3)
30. Aliens RPG (360/PC/PS3)

Pics and videos of the above titles

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26715971

Besides 2 PS3 titles, one of which (FF13vs) will probably not make it in 2009, the rest are all on 360, 6 of them are only on 360 too

Here is my most gameplay hours so far this generation

Xbox 360
.
Fable 2 - 120 hours
Lost Odyssey - 90+ hours
Mass Effect - 80+ hours
Tales of Vesperia - 40+ hours
Infinite Undicovery - 30+ hours
Too Human - 40+ hours
Banjo 3 - 40+ hours
Viva Pinata 2 - 30+ hours
Fallout 3 - 100+ hours
Oblivion - 100+ hours
Enchanted Arms - 30+ hours
Eternal Sonata - 30+ hours
Blue Dragon - 40+ hours
Ninja Gaiden 2 - 25+ hours
Last Remnant - 60+ hours

.

PS3
.
Folklore - 15 hours

So, xbox 360 lineup by a million miles for me and my personal preferences

1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)obamanian

[QUOTE="obamanian"]1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)angelkimne

If you're reall trying to make an impartial decision about the better game library, you need to list more games. What about all the exclusive RPGS on xbox 360 like lost oddyssey, star ocean 4, blue dragon, tales of vesparia, last remnant and also infinite indiscovery or PS3 exclusive rpg White Knight Chronicles?

Change your title to "if you only consider the 5 or so games I decided to list, which is the better library."

360 almost has two times the amount of AAAEs, and more than two times the amount of AAEs, and so on, when compared to the PS3, and when you take into account that it also recieves PC multiplat games, and offers far more variety in its library over the PS3 it should be easy to see that it is currently leading over the PS3.

360 almost has two times the amount of AAAEs, and more than two times the amount of AAEs, and so on, when compared to the PS3, and when you take into account that it also recieves PC multiplat games, and offers far more variety in its library over the PS3 it should be easy to see that it is currently leading over the PS3.

opex07

[QUOTE="opex07"]

360 almost has two times the amount of AAAEs, and more than two times the amount of AAEs, and so on, when compared to the PS3, and when you take into account that it also recieves PC multiplat games, and offers far more variety in its library over the PS3 it should be easy to see that it is currently leading over the PS3.

Animal-Mother

Were does it say exclusive in the title?, I'm pretty sure it says 360 vs ps3 library therefore if it's not on ps3 it counts towards library

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"]

[QUOTE="opex07"]

360 almost has two times the amount of AAAEs, and more than two times the amount of AAEs, and so on, when compared to the PS3, and when you take into account that it also recieves PC multiplat games, and offers far more variety in its library over the PS3 it should be easy to see that it is currently leading over the PS3.

Erik_Lensherr

Were does it say exclusive in the title?, I'm pretty sure it says 360 vs ps3 library therefore if it's not on ps3 it counts towards library

[QUOTE="Erik_Lensherr"]

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] 360 has two times the amount AA PS3 has? I think you mean two more. It has 5 PS3 has 3, as for AAE's their coming slowly but surely and with a sig like that you cant be wrong you also fail to mention how the 360 is missing a AAAAE

Animal-Mother

Were does it say exclusive in the title?, I'm pretty sure it says 360 vs ps3 library therefore if it's not on ps3 it counts towards library

I believe he said gears 1 and Mass effect thanks you, And what the hell does being able to play it on your pc have to do with 360 vs ps3 library? I don't see pc mentioned anywhere in the title.

360 has two times the amount AA PS3 has? I think you mean two more. It has 5 PS3 has 3, as for AAE's their coming slowly but surely and with a sig like that you cant be wrong you also fail to mention how the 360 is missing a AAAAE

Animal-Mother

I'm not sure if your talking about AAE games in your first two sentences or AAAE, but if your talking about AAAE, yes the 360 has 5, while the PS3 has 3. I had forgotten to take into account that Killzone had just scored AAAE so I had previously said the 360 has more than two and had to edit it quickly into almost two, which is true since it is only 1 game away from two times the amount. Im good at spining numbers:P

I'm also not sure what you are trying to say about my sig.

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"]

[QUOTE="Erik_Lensherr"]

Were does it say exclusive in the title?, I'm pretty sure it says 360 vs ps3 library therefore if it's not on ps3 it counts towards library

Erik_Lensherr

I believe he said gears 1 and Mass effect thanks you, And what the hell does being able to play it on your pc have to do with 360 s ps3 library? I don't see pc mentioned anywhere in the title.

Comes down to what the gamer prefers imo. There are some games I like on PS3 and vice versa for the X360.

Why does the OP mention only exclusives? and no if I can still put it in my PC and play it I might not get the same graphic expierience but I Still get the same gameplay and story

Animal-Mother

The TC said its mostly about exclusives but he wants the thread to be open-ended, in his op. Also being able to play the game on your PC doesn't take away from the fact that you cant play it on a PS3.

[QUOTE="Erik_Lensherr"]

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] Why does the OP mention only exclusives? and no if I can still put it in my PC and play it I might not get the same graphic expierience but I Still get the same gameplay and story

Animal-Mother

I believe he said gears 1 and Mass effect thanks you, And what the hell does being able to play it on your pc have to do with 360 s ps3 library? I don't see pc mentioned anywhere in the title.

What part don't u understand this is not ps3+pc vs 360 , so really thats all that counts. Do you think games can't be included that aren't on ps3 because YOU have a computer to play them on :roll: get real do these games not exist because you can play them on your computer?, when you go to purchase them at walmart do they say sorry these are on pc also and we can't sell them to you?. they are part of the 360 library you cannot play them on ps3, they do exist

They both have very good games out. Anybody that says different is smoking something illegal.

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="Erik_Lensherr"]

I believe he said gears 1 and Mass effect thanks you, And what the hell does being able to play it on your pc have to do with 360 s ps3 library? I don't see pc mentioned anywhere in the title.

Erik_Lensherr

What part don't u understand this is not ps3+pc vs 360 , so really thats all that counts. Do you think games can't be included that aren't on ps3 because YOU have a computer to play them on :roll: get real do these games not exist because you can play them on your computer?, when you go to purchase them at walmart do they say sorry these are on pc also and we can't sell them to you?. they are part of the 360 library you cannot play them on ps3, they do exist

ps3 for me, but thats just my opinion

[QUOTE="Erik_Lensherr"]

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] Yeah did you read any of the other posts where We mention Gears 1 And ME are not exclusive. And the pc discussion came from your "if it's not on ps3 it counts towards library" so Yeah I can play L4D on a 360, but yeah I can also play it on a PC as well, and No I dont have some super PC if I get the same core gameplay expierience thats all that countsAnimal-Mother

What part don't u understand this is not ps3+pc vs 360 , so really thats all that counts. Do you think games can't be included that aren't on ps3 because YOU have a computer to play them on :roll: get real do these games not exist because you can play them on your computer?, when you go to purchase them at walmart do they say sorry these are on pc also and we can't sell them to you?. they are part of the 360 library you cannot play them on ps3, they do exist

How much easier can it get thread says "PS3 vs. 360: Better Game Library" is gears 1 playable on 360?, is mass effect playable on 360?, is L4D playable on 360?. Yah just assume everyone has a pc to play them on, ever think a majority of people that have a console don't play games on pc? Well you should because that is the case. No matter how hard you want to believe they don't count they do. Some people really like to think games are not part of a library when they are on the console is ridiculous.

Here the 360 and the PS3 exclusives list rated here on gamespot. I also excluded all the PC/360 games (that ones would make the ownage even bigger)! Well, thats not even a contest of which has the better lineup but considering here in system wars most are cows im not surprised with the poll.

XBOX 360

AAAE - 5

Gears of War 2
Halo 3
Forza 2
PDZ
GRAW

AAE - 15

DOA4
PGR3
Kameo
Banjo Kazooie
Fable 2
Viva Pinata
Viva Pinata 2
ToV
Ace Combat 6
PGR4
Dead Rising
Saints Row
MotoGP 06
Scene it
Ninja Gaiden 2

AE - 9

Race Pro
Chromehounds
Crackdown
Amped 3
Namco Museum
Lost Odyssey
Scene it?
Naruto
Naruto The Broken Bond

PS3

AAAAE - 1

Metal Gear Solid 4

AAAE - 3

LittleBigPlanet
Resistance 2
Killzone 2

AAE - 6

Resistance
Valkyria Chronicles
Warhawk
Motorstorm PR
Uncharted
Heavenly Sword

AE - 11

Motorstorm
Naruto
Disgaea 3
Buzz!
SingStar
Gran Turismo Prologue
Hot Shots Golf
Ratchet and Clank
The Eye of Judgement
SingStar V3
Folklore

LOL @ cows on this forum

The 360 library is twice as big for a start

with more AAA's

more AA's

and more A titles.

In what way could the ps3 library be in the slightest better?

[QUOTE="obamanian"]1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)angelkimne

I read about it in a blog, it is supposed to have some amazing art, and influences from Zelda WW and old adventures and RPG's, with focus on dialog, story, emotion, characters etc

Also i read it has influences from anime like mononoke, thing is it has no name or publisher yet, but is pretty far in development

I can't find the blog though, i found it through a post in some forum, and now i can't find that post sadly

I guess more will be revealed soon aobut it though anyway

LOL @ cows on this forum

The 360 library is twice as big for a start

with more AAA's

more AA's

and more A titles.

In what way could the ps3 library be in the slightest better?

scottiescott238

IMO, the 360 library is better. More RPGS.

LOL @ cows on this forum

The 360 library is twice as big for a start

with more AAA's

more AA's

and more A titles.

In what way could the ps3 library be in the slightest better?

scottiescott238

Yah but half those games are just an illusion and aren't really there because I have a computer :roll:

[QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="obamanian"]1. New XBLA 2D RPG to bring back the old feeling/atmosphere/adventuring/art in RPG gaming (360 XBLA)Animal-Mother

I do not like bad 3D visuals, because they lack the detail and feeling you can get with 2D visuals

In 2D of course you have no limitations, so there you have it, if you go 3D, better have detail like a 2D game, if not looks plain and boring, the 2D can look stunning with any system though, especially the HD systems like 360 and PS3

The 2D is what made FF7 for example look so amazing back then, they used it even in FF10 and these areas still rival the best of 3D visuals

You know what, if i make a poll saying , which console do you own, then it will be mostly ps3.

becasue this place is full of cows, and any poll is going to end up in thier favour

You know what, if i make a poll saying , which console do you own, then it will be mostly ps3.

becasue this place is full of cows, and any poll is going to end up in thier favour

scottiescott238

You know what, if i make a poll saying , which console do you own, then it will be mostly ps3.

becasue this place is full of cows, and any poll is going to end up in thier favour

scottiescott238

Wrong again most cows would vote 360 , think about it , as for better library the numbers speak for themselves 360 by far.

Gears 1 and Mass Effect arent exclusive :o

Uptown