PS3 vs 360 vs Wii vs PC!! The battle of greatest exclusives!!

For now we enter the 4th year in gaming this generation, we all know that all the consoles (including PC) have their greatest exclusives.

So, the question is : Which is the greatest exclusive game this generation?

For that, I pick Gears of War (X360), Metal Gear Solid 4 (PS3), Super Mario Galaxy (Wii) and Crysis (PC). Each of them are the greatest exclusive from their console using Gamespot Score.

Fight 1: The Graphic

This fight Crysis easily won by huge gap, that's because Crysis is the only game that using PC power almost maximum! Just look at that, even though it's released in 2007. until now (2009) no game defeat Crysis!! Crysis is easily have the best graphic until now!! (Killzone 2 second)

Fight 2: The Storyline

For this fight, the winner is easily Metal Gear Solid 4 by very far huge gap. That's because if we compare it to another.... c'mon man! Gears of War story is so BOORRIINGG!! Super Mario Galaxy? No comment? Crysis? Standard. MGS 4 is by far have the best storyline until now!! (BioShock second)

Fight 3: The Gameplay

A very tough battle, because all of them have very solid gameplay, but because we can't have a tie, I pick Metal Gear Solid 4 for the best gameplay. Because it itroduces many new variety from the last game!! If we see Gears of War 2, we will say: "WTF? This is just rip-off from Gears of War 1!! Let's call it Gears of War 1.5!" Althought Grand Thef Auto 4 and Call of Duty 4 have better gameplay than MGS 4, for this fight the winner is Metal Gear Solid 4.

Fight 4: Sound

Err.....I think I don't need to explain this. Metal Gear Solid 4 is the clear winner, because of the voice acting and soundstrack are much better when we compare it to the rest. I know, Persona 4 has better soundtrack than MGS 4, but in voice acting no game can match it.

Fight 5: Main Character (Marcus Fenix vs. Mario vs. Old Snake vs. Nomad)

Old Snake is the winner, that's not only because of his personality, but also when I touched the game, I feel entirely that I was Old Snake!! When Snake screams, when Snake fight, when Snake dies, I felt that it was my actual self that did all that. Ok, I know Mario since I was just a child, but I judge it only from Super Mario Galaxy!! And, because of that, I picked Old Snake for the best character.

Fight 6: Fun Factor

For this, Super Mario Galaxy is the clear winner, I don't even need to say anything. Just play it and you'll soon understand

Fight 7: Gamespot Score

Metal Gear Solid 4 (10) is the winner, followed by Gears of War (9.6), Super Mario Galxy and Crysis (both 9.5). Heck, everybody! It's the perfect 10!!

Fight 8: Award

Gears of War won Gamespot Game of the Year Award 2006, Super Mario Galaxy won Gamespot and IGN Game of the Year Award 2007, Metal Gear Solid 4 won Gamespot Game of the Year Award 2008, Crysis won nothing. So, Super Mario Galaxy is the winner.

Fight 9: Metacritic Score

Once again, Super Mario Galaxy is the winner. Super Mario Galaxy scored 97 in metacritic, MGS 4 and Gears of War both 94, and Crysis 91

Fight 10: My Opinion

For me, all of the are masterpiece, but if I have to pick one, I pick Metal Gear Solid 4, because it's ****c.

So, the score is:

1. Metal Gear Solid 4 (won 6)

2. Super Mario Galaxy (won 3)

3. Crysis (won 1)

4. Gears of War (won 0)

There it is, the greatest exclusive game this generation is METAL GEAR SOLID 4!! Congratulations, PS3 owner, you have not only greatest exclusive game this generation, but also the greatest game by far this generation!!

The winner:

The greatest game by far this generation...

I haven't played Crysis, but I seriously doubt I'd like it more than MGS4.

I loved MGS4 the first 2 times I beat it, but I can't seem to care to play it again. Crysis I beat once and I could careless about it. SMGalaxy I played for 3 hours before I sold it. Gears of War I beat the first day and I never played it again. The moral of this story is that these games have the least re-playability factor compared to last gen, but thats just my opinion.

Wait ... Gears isn't exclusive???

opinions vs critics score thats basicly what your thread is about :P

except the graphics part, crysis is really the winner there.

so mario galaxy wins acording to critics

but mgs4 wins acording to your opinion

Wait I would stay halo 3 instead of Gears, its stayed loyal to xbox, and is probably the most iconic game for xbox, Why?

MGS4 seems about right!, great games all of them

Fight 1: The Graphic

Crysis, naturally. Despipte critics saying MGS :roll: and even CoD4 in some cases... because they are retarded.

Fight 2: The Storyline

MGS4 - naturally, since its the majority of the so called "game".

Fight 3: The Gameplay

... You said MGS4 just because it added new features? and Crysis didnt? at least that was 90% playing, not 5 hours gameplay and 9 hours cutscenes.

Fight 4: Sound

MGS4 agreed.

Fight 5: Main Character (Marcus Fenix vs. Mario vs. Old Snake vs. Nomad)

Agreed, old snake.

Fight 6: Fun Factor

Goes between Crysis and Gears of War, tbh though these 4 games were far from the most "fun" of this gen. this list is flawed.

Fight 7: Gamespot Score

Zzzz pointless.

Fight 8: Award

Pointless Zzzzz

Fight 9: Metacritic Score

Again pointless.

Fight 10: My Opinion

Agreed, MGS4, but this list is shocking tbh.

The greatest game by far this generation... LMAO no.

ihsanqueen

I would of done something like this more like:

PC: WoW:Wrath of the Lich King

Wii: Smash Bros Brawl

360: Halo 3

PS3: MGS4

Your award system is flawed aswell, you added in the strenghts of MGS4 (Characters ect) yet you missed out, online play, competitive factors, sales, most played ect... you know ... THE ACTUAL GAME SIDE OF GAMES!. god MGS4 makes me sick in these discussions, just coz its the biggest array of cutscenes around it seems to be immune to its actual flaws. mayaswell made a CGI movie.

I think PC gamers value Stalker more than Crysis.

I think PC gamers value Stalker more than Crysis.

Baranga

I value Crysis more then Stalker. I never understood that radio active wall that you die when you go through so I've never made it pass 40 minutes in the game without dying :(

[QUOTE="Baranga"]

I think PC gamers value Stalker more than Crysis.

bigblunt537

I value Crysis more then Stalker. I never understood that radio active wall that you die when you go through so I've never made it pass 40 minutes in the game without dying :(

But lets face the reality here, the face of PC gaming is World of Warcraft now, the core side at least.

[QUOTE="bigblunt537"]

[QUOTE="Baranga"]

I think PC gamers value Stalker more than Crysis.

PC360Wii

I value Crysis more then Stalker. I never understood that radio active wall that you die when you go through so I've never made it pass 40 minutes in the game without dying :(

But lets face the reality here, the face of PC gaming is World of Warcraft now, the core side at least.

Unfortunately I agree. Although I hate mmorpg's and rts. I remember when pc was flooded with fps and many different varieties. Sometimes I don't even know why I have a gaming pc. I think it's because I like pretty graphics.

When i saw this topic i thought that it would be a PS3 fanbay trying to make a comparison thread to try and exclude 360/PC games from a console comparison. Then i started reading it and i thought good its just a fair discussion about games. When you started going on about MGS then i thought that was fine as you might love this game but when you ended it with "There it is, the greatest exclusive game this generation is METAL GEAR SOLID 4!! Congratulations, PS3 owner, you have not only greatest exclusive game this generation, but also the greatest game by far this generation!!" that just made me think this is just another fanboy comparison.

Am sure you will correct me if am wrong.

>.> What a dookie list,imo.

Console users may be obsessed with exceeding Crysis on their system of choice, plus it may be one of the most technically and graphically advanced games on PC, but it is certainly not one of our best exclusives.

Besides best is subjective, someone may not see any of these games as being the best because they are a racing/RTS fan.

Gears of War

Witcher easily destroys all those above games.

What a completely biased thread. lmao You do realize that Crysis won best shooter of 2007 award right TC?

Crysis has the best gameplay out of all the games by the way. MGS4 had some pretty mediocre gameplay, especially when compared to Splinter Cell, the only real good thing about it was the Octocamo.

I think PC gamers value Stalker more than Crysis.

Baranga

Console users may be obsessed with exceeding Crysis on their system of choice, plus it may be one of the most technically and graphically advanced games on PC, but it is certainly not one of our best exclusives.

Besides best is subjective, someone may not see any of these games as being the best because they are a racing/RTS fan.

AnnoyedDragon

I would have to give this to...Gears of War. Not two! two, to me, sucked. But i enjoyed the first a lot. I would then give MGS4 second place, followed by Crysis and then Super Mario Galaxy. But that is my opinion.

A poll such as this merely determines which type of fanboy is more prevalent on system wars.

Gears of War isn't exclusive :x

Such a massive amount of great exclusives for PC.

Until God of War is released, Metal Gear Solid is the best game this generation.mithrixx

Now that's a great sentence. ;)

But I enjoyed GeoW1 more than 2, is true. Still I haven't played Crysis yet, but it seems to be a wonderful game with unbelieavable graphics. I've never had a thing for Mario galaxy though. Zelda is my thing along with Super Smash Bros Brawl.

MGS4 is the overall game. It has just about everything. The story lines outshines all those games TC selected. Kojima FTW!!

MGS4 is just a great game. 1 among the best of the bests.

MGS4 was fanservice but not much more. The story didn't make sense, and there were wayyy too many installs and cutscenes breaking up the fun.
Crysis was incredibly generic and it never even impressed me with the visuals safe for having a player shadow.
And GeoW made me ashamed to play it because of the incredibly stupid muscleheads and hollywood story, but it was actually more fun than the other 2.
They are 8.0 games to me, maybe GeoW an 8.5. SMG was more like a 9ner. It was lengthy, varied, quality, original, and colorful.
But i know everyone disagrees. I probably don't make sense to You but You people don't make sense to me.

Gears of War isn't exclusive.