R2, LBP, VC vs. GW2, BK, Fable 2 - who has a better holiday line up?

Resistance 2, LittleBigPlanet, Valkyria Chronicles vs. Gears of War 2, Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Fable 2 :

both have an adult shooter, a family friendly game, and a RPG exclusive to their console (tho there a differences btw the comparables, that's not what were looking at here) 

personally, i would go for Sony's line up (tho i have all of those games except Banjo Kazooie) 

Resistance 2, LittleBigPlanet, Valkyria Chronicles vs. Gears of War 2, Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Fable 2 :

both have an adult shooter, a family friendly game, and a RPG exclusive to their console (tho there a differences btw the comparables, that's not what were looking at here)

personally, i would go for Sony's line up (tho i have all of those games except Banjo Kazooie)

ender1601

I'd go with the 360, gor Gears 2 only :P

But the PS3's is also extremely strong. 

What are the reasons for excluding L4D in a 360 vs PS3 comparison?speedsix

well if you are going to get it then get it for pc mods and more content FTW. 

ps3-Mad_Rhetoric-

I have brought all of those games minus banjo, and i think the 360's line up is better.

Resistance is the same meh gameplay as the first.

little big planet is awesome

valkeryie chronicals is brilliant.

But gears 2 , fable 2 , left 4 dead are in a different league (Ok little big planet belongs in this league)

360 obviously.

*expects to see "PS3 obviously"*

The real winners are those with both consoles :)RotaryRX7

People like to say, 360's is better because it has more games. But what if some of those "more games" suck? I like both list but i've had more fun with LBP then any game I own on PS360. So i'll say PS3WatchmenWatchUs

Actually 360 has more A, AA and AAA games on its lineup. That means more quantity and quality, right?

I like the PS3 list better...But man am I happy I have both systemsHarlockJC

Same here.

PS3 for me. Not a big fan of Resistance 2, but I enjoyed the beta. I own LBP and it's a solid game. I am planning on getting Valkryia and even White Knight Chronicles.

I desperately want to play Gears 2 and Fable 2 as they both sound like solid games, and I dont really care about Banjo.

I own a PS3 only, and I love the lineup of games.

PS3 keeps on getting stronger and stronger.

The review scores say PS3

 The sales say Xbox 360.

Analyze that any way you wish.

I like the PS3 list better...But man am I happy I have both systemsHarlockJC

I prefer the 360 lineupPAL360

gears 2 > all PS3 linup

combin this with FABLE 2 and L4D and you have one of the best holday linup

BANJO is a flop like socom

Gears 2 >> Resistance

LBP >>> Banjo

Fable 2 >>> VC

Gears 2 and LBP are definately my two favourite games this holiday. Its really close which one has the best line up but i'd go with the PS3, just.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]I prefer the 360 lineupdruggyjoe3000

Thats great...im starting to be famous!!

neither

age of empires, skate it, ninjatown, lock's quest, chrono trigger, simcity creator, prince of persia: fallen king, moon, call of duty: world at war, ...

the DS is better than all

plus, i mean Wario Land(7.5), De Blob(8), Animal Crossing(7.5), Skate it(8.5 ign), Bomberman Blast(8 ign), World of Goo(9), Art Style Orbit(8 ign), Mega Man 9(8), Tales of Symphonia 2(6.7 ign), Dokapon Kingdom(8 ign),World at War (8.2 ign) aren't that bad

but i'd say DS, PS3, Wii, X360 for me, although nuts and bolts looks cool

I like the PS3 list better...But man am I happy I have both systemsHarlockJC

A dirt racer is the tie breaker.

PS3 has MGS4...360 doesnt. Therefore PS3 winsblazinpuertoroc

Gears of War 2 , Left 4 Daed , Banjo , Fable 2 is the better lineup . you sony fan boys forgot to mention that Left 4 dead is on the 360 and will never be on the PS3 . Resistance 2 is garbage  

 

Gears of War 2 , Left 4 Daed , Banjo , Fable 2 is the better lineup . you sony fan boys forgot to mention that Left 4 dead is on the 360 and will never be on the PS3 . Resistance 2 is garbage  

ExtremeOne316

  Resistance 2 is garbage  

ExtremeOne316