Screenshot GT Academy Demo Vs Forza 3

Link

I leave it for you to judge for me I think GT Academy looks a little bit better than Forza 3.

Couldn't pick a winner from those screens, not enough going on

Great! Compare a 200mb demo that is a competition/showcase of physics with a full game!

We`ve all seen the TGS demo, we know how GT5 graphics are gonna be.

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

sikanderahmed

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

sikanderahmed

Well except the grass and the colorful environment GT demo beats F3 in everything in term of graphics and from what I played in the demo GT physics are slightly better than F3 and more realistic.

Judging by the pics. Forza has better textures while GT has better lighting

They look exactly the same in pictures that size.

[QUOTE="sikanderahmed"]

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

Racer850

Actually, it IS inferior. Its even inferior to Prologue. This demo is just as the warning says, a Physics demo. There are things that are in Prologue that are not here, maybe to cut the size of the demo aswell.

If you look closely GT lacks shadows in the second pic although there are lots of cloubs which are probably blocking out the sun. IN the third screen Forza has better grass and theres fans in the background.

[QUOTE="Racer850"][QUOTE="sikanderahmed"]

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

DragoonKain1687

Actually, it IS inferior. Its even inferior to Prologue. This demo is just as the warning says, a Physics demo. There are things that are in Prologue that are not here, maybe to cut the size of the demo aswell.

I am playing the demo right now and I can say I an not the least bit impressed with teh graphics of GT5. I don't think they look good at all. Aliasing on the shadows, sprites for the trees and crowd, the enviroment is bland as all hell... very underwhelming.

Good driving physics though. I tried bouncing off of a wall, didn't work to well.

saying that this is just phsyics demo therefore the graphics were downgraded might help cows sleep at night but that aint the case, the game will look same as the demo and why exactly would Polyphony downgrade the demo just to lower the demo size doesnt make any sense

I got pretty much the same impressions asWasdie above me from playing the demo.

Other than the time of day/brightness difference, they look about the same.

Worse than looking bad is looking boring. This demo seens extremely unapealing. People hype GT5 to have monstruosly awesome graphics and forget that despite the cell and all other things, its a game that run 60 fps at a pseudo 1080p resolution. PS3 can do great things but anyone shouldn't expect bullshot-like quality. With that in mind the demo is said to be only a showcase for physics and not the final product in any way, the release version should look better. But then again there is so much misinformation about GT5 that i don't knowhat to believe.

Now this looks awesome ;)!

Great! Compare a 200mb demo that is a competition/showcase of physics with a full game!

We`ve all seen the TGS demo, we know how GT5 graphics are gonna be.

Wassmansdorff

[QUOTE="sikanderahmed"]

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

Kashiwaba

Well except the grass and the colorful environment GT demo beats F3 in everything in term of graphics and from what I played in the demo GT physics are slightly better than F3 and more realistic.

Have you ever actually raced a car? I played the demo and its not more realistic then F3....

saying that this is just phsyics demo therefore the graphics were downgraded might help cows sleep at night but that aint the case, the game will look same as the demo and why exactly would Polyphony downgrade the demo just to lower the demo size doesnt make any sense

sikanderahmed

LOL, If final game will look like this trial it will look worse than Prologue:

http://www.eurogamer.net/videos/gran-turismo-5-frame-rate-analysis?size=hd

Or TGS build:

http://www.gamersyde.com/stream_gran_turismo_5_tgs09_replay-13050_en.html

http://www.gamersyde.com/stream_gran_turismo_5_tgs09_gameplay-13015_en.html

http://www.gamersyde.com/stream_gran_turismo_5_tgs09_ferrari_cockpit-12989_en.html

http://www.gamersyde.com/stream_gran_turismo_5_tgs09_replay-12996_en.html

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

[QUOTE="sikanderahmed"]

having played the demo and forza 3 and looking at those pics...i stick to what ive been saying, car models in GT5 look slightly better but other then that everything else is better in forza 3

Nagidar

Well except the grass and the colorful environment GT demo beats F3 in everything in term of graphics and from what I played in the demo GT physics are slightly better than F3 and more realistic.

Have you ever actually raced a car? I played the demo and its not more realistic then F3....

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

Well except the grass and the colorful environment GT demo beats F3 in everything in term of graphics and from what I played in the demo GT physics are slightly better than F3 and more realistic.

Kashiwaba

Have you ever actually raced a car? I played the demo and its not more realistic then F3....

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

meh both look pretty much the same. who cares about those damn details anyway, like you're going to pay attention to them when you're playing

i just want to play GT5 already..

GT has better car graphics

Forza3 has better everything else

For me though racing games are all about GAMEPLAY

GT has better car graphics

Forza3 has better everything else

For me though racing games are all about GAMEPLAY

kozzy1234

OH well back to Gran Turismo 1 and 2 I guess.

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

Have you ever actually raced a car? I played the demo and its not more realistic then F3....

Nagidar

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

I never said no I got Honda NSX 1999 but I never tried racing on circuit only did some highway racing (I wont call them a races since in most of them the speed didnt exceed 220 KMph) but I know how to tell if the car controlling is realistic or no.

meh both look pretty much the same. who cares about those damn details anyway, like you're going to pay attention to them when you're playing

i just want to play GT5 already..

kweeni

I'm with you, they need to release this damn game already.

[QUOTE="kozzy1234"]

GT has better car graphics

Forza3 has better everything else

For me though racing games are all about GAMEPLAY

3sFan

OH well back to Gran Turismo 1 and 2 I guess.

Yah I can't get into bumper cars anymore after the genre evolved on consoles with Forza, although at the time I loved them

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

Have you ever actually raced a car? I played the demo and its not more realistic then F3....

Nagidar

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

[QUOTE="kweeni"]

meh both look pretty much the same. who cares about those damn details anyway, like you're going to pay attention to them when you're playing

i just want to play GT5 already..

Nagidar

I'm with you, they need to release this damn game already.

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

Kashiwaba

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

I never said no I got Honda NSX 1999 but I never tried racing in circuit only did some highway racing (I wont call them a races since in most of the speed didnt exceed 220 KMph) but I know how to tell if the car controlling is realistic or no.

I have actually raced on a track, hell, I've even tested cars on a skid pad, the physics in GT are not more realistic then F3. Here's an example, this wasn't by me BTW, a Evo X FQ 360 was put to 3 tests against a GTR, when they tested the latteral G's, the Evo X hit 1.61, when I suped up a Evo X in F3 and turned hard into a corner, it hit 1.66 G's, now THATS accurate.

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

Arach666

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

Too bad it felt more realistic to me.

Arach666

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

Agreed, it goes, GTR2 > F3.

The only thing I hated about GTR2 was lack of vehicles...

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

That's a no. So how can you say it races or, "feels" more realstic when you have no basis for comparison?

Nagidar

I never said no I got Honda NSX 1999 but I never tried racing in circuit only did some highway racing (I wont call them a races since in most of the speed didnt exceed 220 KMph) but I know how to tell if the car controlling is realistic or no.

I have actually raced on a track, hell, I've even tested cars on a skid pad, the physics in GT are not more realistic then F3. Here's an example, this wasn't by me BTW, a Evo X FQ 360 was put to 3 tests against a GTR, when they tested the latteral G's, the Evo X hit 1.61, when I suped up a Evo X in F3 and turned hard into a corner, it hit 1.66 G's, now THATS accurate.

I never said said Forza 3 is an Arcade racer or its physics sux ==; but the way you control cars in GT felt slightly more realistic to me than F3.

[QUOTE="Nagidar"]

[QUOTE="Kashiwaba"]

I never said no I got Honda NSX 1999 but I never tried racing in circuit only did some highway racing (I wont call them a races since in most of the speed didnt exceed 220 KMph) but I know how to tell if the car controlling is realistic or no.

Kashiwaba

I have actually raced on a track, hell, I've even tested cars on a skid pad, the physics in GT are not more realistic then F3. Here's an example, this wasn't by me BTW, a Evo X FQ 360 was put to 3 tests against a GTR, when they tested the latteral G's, the Evo X hit 1.61, when I suped up a Evo X in F3 and turned hard into a corner, it hit 1.66 G's, now THATS accurate.

I never said said Forza 3 is an Arcade racer or its physics sux ==; but the way you control cars in GT felt slightly more realistic to me than F3.

One aspect does not make one more realistic than another, neither Forza nor GT have the steering quite right, but we're using controllers anyway, not like its easy to "feel" that.

As far as actual racing physics, F3 is better, at least, for now, we'll have to wait for the retail game to see if that will stand or not.

car models and the cockpit looks like 10x better on GT5, but the environments on Forza 3 looks way ahead of GT5

saying that this is just phsyics demo therefore the graphics were downgraded might help cows sleep at night but that aint the case, the game will look same as the demo and why exactly would Polyphony downgrade the demo just to lower the demo size doesnt make any sense

sikanderahmed

One aspect does not make one more realistic than another, neither Forza nor GT have the steering quite right, but we're using controllers anyway, not like its easy to "feel" that.

Nagidar

Get a steering wheel, PD plays the game with logitech steering wheels. You haven't experienced Gran Turismo if you don't have one.

I can guarantee at least 90% of the time trial winners will be using steering wheels

GT5 has better interior views and interior lighting. But is much fuzzier and distorted compared to Forza's clean looking interior views (which can be either good or bad, depending on what you prefer to look at). The exterior views, which of course don't really matter to racing enthusiasts, are about the same. Not that impressive for all the wait on GT5's behalf.

Both of the them look exactly the same. Cockpit and the actual car models look better in GT5, though. What I'm wondering is why it's 2009 and grass continues to look like a child scribbled a green crayon on the ground. Textures for both games for the ground are not very pleasant. :(

I am just wondering how anyone thinks forza 3 enviroments are better, with the difference between grass textures between the 2 games. It isn't just remotely better quality textures, it is like a generation ahead. The graphics look alot worse in forza 3. Like I have to lie to myself in order to say forza 3 looks better.

Both of the them look exactly the same. Cockpit and the actual car models look better in GT5, though. What I'm wondering is why it's 2009 and grass continues to look like a child scribbled a green crayon on the ground. Textures for both games for the ground are not very pleasant. :(

Xire_XII