Skyrim vs Uncharted 3- Which One Will Be the Dominator?

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"]illegol copez! Fake!Fake!IDoItLikeAboss

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"][QUOTE="KarateeeChop"] heheheh damn you caught me red handed Ilikemyname420

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"][QUOTE="Ilikemyname420"] The AI in both Uncharted and Uncharted 2 were just bullet sponges. Increase the difficulty and they become even bigger bullet sponges with better accuracy. The biggest improvement they made in UC 2 was the fact that the enemy could lose sight of you but really that just made things even easier. Really the only hard parts are when they start chucking grenades like crazy. And Micheal Bay may wish he could make something like Uncharted....but everyone else would probably wish he wouldn't.KarateeeChop

nope. uncharted's AI is pretty laughable at times. reminds me of killzone.

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"] Your nuts. Uncharted 1 and especially Uncharted 2 had good A.I If you want to be that guy *cough uncharted hater* are be the typical SW devils advocate then at least know what your talking about. Maybe you should play the game while your at it. And yeah, that's funny because last time I checked the Uncharted franchise has sold at almost 10 mill while only being 4-5 years old. So appearently a lot of gamers wish he would And what I meant is that Uncharted also has the substance that Michael bay films don't have on top of the flashDiviniuz

nope. uncharted's AI is pretty laughable at times. reminds me of killzone.

[QUOTE="Ilikemyname420"]

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"] Ok. I believe you :) But I'm curious. What games have you enjoyed? What aspects did you like?IDoItLikeAboss

And I wouldn't say Uncharted 1/2 were bad games they just were not up my alley, then again I don't like alot of popular game series that other people seem to love: Halo1/2/3/ODST/Reach, the Assassins Creed series, the Fable series, the Gears of War series, the Resistance series etc.

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"][QUOTE="Ilikemyname420"] For PS3 exclusives top 5 I'd have to say: Demon's souls was probably my favorite I aslo liked MGS4, Yakuza 3 , Little Big Planet (preferred the first) and Infamous (also preferred the first).

Ilikemyname420

And I wouldn't say Uncharted 1/2 were bad games they just were not up my alley, then again I don't like alot of popular game series that other people seem to love: Halo1/2/3/ODST/Reach, the Assassins Creed series, the Fable series, the Gears of War series, the Resistance series etc.

skyrim will get more GOTY awards since it multiplat. but uncharted will obviously be the better gamelloveLamp

[QUOTE="TrapJak"]

[QUOTE="Ilikemyname420"]

Bad AI is still bad.

[QUOTE="TrapJak"]

[QUOTE="godzillavskong"] Looks pretty legit to me, or how did you put it, leggit.lol

Funny thing is I'm using an eyetoy...

[QUOTE="Ilikemyname420"]

[QUOTE="IDoItLikeAboss"] Haha that's cool. You have good tastes in games my dude:) except for the whole not liking U2 part:'( Shame on you for that. Haha just kidding :) On another note what did you like about MGS 4? I did like it a lot too, but just wondering because MGS was worse in a lot of ways at the things you criticised Uncharted for then Uncharted But i respect your opinion. I really really enjoyed Uncharted 2 ...like thoroughly as did a lot of my gaming buddies so its weird seeing so many on SW trash itIDoItLikeAboss

And I wouldn't say Uncharted 1/2 were bad games they just were not up my alley, then again I don't like alot of popular game series that other people seem to love: Halo1/2/3/ODST/Reach, the Assassins Creed series, the Fable series, the Gears of War series, the Resistance series etc.

My pick easily goes to Skyrim. Looks like a solid update to Oblivion in every category.

I have said this many times and gotten fllamed, score wise uncharted will score a 8.5 Naughty dog is not a certified AAA developer if you look at their previous games the vast majority are in the mid to high 8's, meanwhile Bethsade is in the high 8's to mid 9's. So I belive skyrim will win scorewise

Saleswise its no competition Skyrim is on all 3 platforms whilst Uncharted is exclusive.

[QUOTE="spike6958"]Out of those two, Skyrim without a doubt. Though I think it's far more likely to be Skyrim vs Gears 3. Gears 3 is adding a lot of stuff (4P Co-Op, vastly improved Horde, Beast Mode, and a massively improved Multiplayer with dedicated servers) where as Uncharted 3, from the videos I've seen and my time with the beta, seems to be no different from Uncharted 2, and while it was good 2 years ago, it seems underwhelming this time around. That said, even against Gears 3 I think Skyrim will still win.IDoItLikeAboss

Well, that's your opinion(how ever odd and strange it might be. It sounds like your that guy that likes to be a critic just because he can and that loves to play devils advocate)but I can offer my opinions as well And by the way before I continue what do you think about Gears, which is NOTHING but whack a mole gameplay except that Gears doesn't even have any seamblence of coherent story what so ever and its characters are walking cliches of roided out marines and alien locuts in a genetic and cliche all out war? can you say generic and played out to the max! Anyway,Ucharted 2 is one of the greatest games I've played in the past several years The story was good by video game standards. Not every story has to be super mind blowing unique. What's important is the execution and ND executed it and presented it well for video gamers to play and have the game being fun to play They added their own naughty dog flavor to the story and characters as well and that's what is important So who cares if the story is not an Oscar winning story or if the characters aren't the deepest moat complex characters know to man. (And by the way in video games I've hardly seen a story like Uncharted let alone any story executed and presented as well as Uncharteds) But what I loved was that the story tied perfectly into the epic set pieces and that there was interesting and insanely fun gameplay as a reault that matched. Everything tied together beautifully Story to set pieces to gameplay Its called integration at its best! And everything else from the graphics to the animation to the physics were stunning. Every single aspect of the game was top notch and polished It was an extremely polished product and at the end of the day an insanely FUN and memorable gameplay experience I forgot to mention and will quickly. The platforming had to be linear but its still responsive and fun to do and in the levels that were open you had more freedom to maneuver and climb But linear is not a bad word at all. It allows the developers to give you a certain experience and take you towards an end goal Moat of all im sick and tired of the SW myth that Uncharted is cut scene after cut scene and qte after qte When someone tries to make Uncharted out to be like that then that's how you know they have never even touched Uncharted before In Uncharted YOU ARE PLAYING what would other wise be a cut scene in another cinematic games cut scene Uncharted gives you tons of control..funny enough more then most games will ..and when there is a cut scene its such a fluid and seamless transition that you won't even notice. It's just that its linear, but that's so that Naughty dog can.take you along for one of the most epic rides of your life Bottom line. I might not like cinematic games or cinematic gameplay but I LOVE THE WAY NAUGHTY DOG DOES IT AND IS ABLE TO EXECUTES IT WITH THAT NAUGHTY DOG FLAVOR, POLISH, ATTENTION TO DETAIL, AND MEMORABLE AND LIKEABLE CHARACTERS AND AWESOME PACING AND GAMEPLAY AND I LOVE UNCHARTED and can't wait for November! I know many people in the real world that can't wait for Uncharted 3 and that were brought into.gaming by Uncharted 2's brillianceIDoItLikeAboss

I am sure I dont need to tell you my opinion on Gears of War considering it has nothing to do with the thread, but if you really want me to tell you. All I can say is, I gave it a 3/10. Gears of War turned me off from mainstream shooters for good.

The one thing I like about Uncharted is how it handled the cinematic gameplay, instead of watching it, you were playing it. But with that said, one plus did not make up for several things I disliked about it. I did not enjoy my somewhat limited experience with UC1+2, maybe they get better later on, but from my experience of it, I couldnt force myself to continue.

[QUOTE="lloveLamp"]skyrim will get more GOTY awards since it multiplat. but uncharted will obviously be the better gameslvrraven9

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Skyrim fo sho but at the end of the day, we'll all be ready to RAGE. :P

Funconsole

Sales-wise I don't think is a fair comparison. Skyrim is on 3 platforms. Scores? I hype both AAA. UC3 might score a smidge higher.

Looking forward to playing Uncharted 3, but the formula is just not as exciting as the first two were for me. Besides that, I am getting tired of anything that requires running around with guns right now anyway. Nothing will touch Skyrim this year for me, save maybe Dark Souls.

U3 will sell more on ps3 than skyrim on ps3 and 360 ...

[QUOTE="slvrraven9"][QUOTE="lloveLamp"]skyrim will get more GOTY awards since it multiplat. but uncharted will obviously be the better gamelloveLamp

U3 will sell more on ps3 than skyrim on ps3 and 360 ...

Aboogie5

[QUOTE="Aboogie5"]

U3 will sell more on ps3 than skyrim on ps3 and 360 ...

slvrraven9

Scores-wise, Skyrim. Sales-wise, Skyrim.

UC3 = scores king

Skyrim = GOTY king

call me on it!

UC3 = scores king

Skyrim = GOTY king

call me on it!

Mozelleple112