Snake VS. Sam Fisher (It's final: Snake Wins!!! /thread)

There was some cat in the forums a while back saying Splinter Cell > MGS, so I thought I'd settle it.

I say Snake. Period. End of story.

What say you?

*Edit: And you said Snake! Snake wins! End of thread!

You all ready know my answer._S0LID_SNAKE_

Right on, my brother.

At least it's a sensible matchup.

Anyway they'll be all like hiding and sneaky and then Snake will be all like "oh snap here he comes!" and then he'll be all like "Box!" and Sam Fisher will be all like "lol where did he go?"

Garrett._en1gma_

Not an option, but good answer.Still Snake > Garret.

You all ready know my answer._S0LID_SNAKE_

[QUOTE="_en1gma_"]Garrett.jetthrovegas

Not an option, but good answer.Still Snake > Garret.

I like being different :D

Id pick Snake as well, however. If I had to choose.

While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.lowe0

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.
And while Splinter Cell's story is as predictable as any story with Clancy's name on it, I'll take it over the drug-induced hallucination that appears to be the plot of Metal Gear Solid.lowe0

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.jetthrovegas

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.
And while Splinter Cell's story is as predictable as any story with Clancy's name on it, I'll take it over the drug-induced hallucination that appears to be the plot of Metal Gear Solid.lowe0

Agree'd. I would put MGS as a action/stealth game. Kind of like how system shock and bioshock are fps/rpg. The better stealth game hands down is Splinter cell. Action wise is MGS.

[QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.jg4xchamp

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.Sully28

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Dude, 5 times??? More like 25!

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.Sully28

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Sorry but there arent any (!) over sams head when he see's snake, he would be comletely lost. As I said, stealth wise sam>snake. Sam would take him out without ever being seen

[QUOTE="Sully28"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.jetthrovegas

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Dude, 5 times??? More like 25!

You all ready know my answer._S0LID_SNAKE_

[QUOTE="Sully28"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.DoctorBunny

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Sorry but there arent any (!) over sams head when he see's snake, he would be comletely lost. As I said, stealth wise sam>snake. Sam would take him out without ever being seen

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.Sully28

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

[QUOTE="DoctorBunny"][QUOTE="Sully28"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.jg4xchamp

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Sorry but there arent any (!) over sams head when he see's snake, he would be comletely lost. As I said, stealth wise sam>snake. Sam would take him out without ever being seen

You realize his stealth is heavily based on being extremely quiet too right? but seeing how the majority of people saying snake never played splinter cell or are pissed that the ps3 crippled the game, I understand why.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="DoctorBunny"][QUOTE="Sully28"][QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="lowe0"]While I'm not going to involve myself in a debate over which fictional character is better, the Splinter Cell games are definitely better than the Metal Gear Solid games. The misions are complex and varied, you don't feel like you're treading the same ground repeatedly, the shadow mechanic is the best since Thief, and the plot plays out without breaking interactivity - you're not subjected to a cutscene every ten minutes. I can't wait to see how their reinvention of the series plays out.DoctorBunny

To each is own, I like the way MGS works, what with the lenghthy cutscenes and heady, politically charged firecracker dialogue.

Yeah snake for sure. He would kill same fisher 5 times before he hit the ground. Thats right, 5 times.

Sorry but there arent any (!) over sams head when he see's snake, he would be comletely lost. As I said, stealth wise sam>snake. Sam would take him out without ever being seen

You realize his stealth is heavily based on being extremely quiet too right? but seeing how the majority of people saying snake never played splinter cell or are pissed that the ps3 crippled the game, I understand why.

Wow, this is original. :roll:

Wow, this is original. :roll:

SuperVegeta518

HEY! Don't diss on me cause I'm derivative!

just to clarify, is it Snake before his genes started breaking down, or is it Old Snake versus Fisher?

if normal Snake and Sam were in a sneaking match, to see who could kill the other from behind, they would be locked in a stalemate until they both died of old age.

if it was in open combat, hand-to-hand, Snake would own. Sam has mad skills, training, and experience, but Snake was built from the ground up to be a super soldier. Snake has slightly more physical strength, more stamina, and quicker reflexes. He also doesn't rely on any specific fighting style, but Sam could choose not to employ his Krav Maga style.

also, what kind of equipment would they be wearing? Those sneaking suits they have are bullet-proof (some, at least)

but if it was a knife fight between them, then Sam would win. I'm pretty sure Sam is better with a knife.

if it was a sniper duel? tough one.

You realize his stealth is heavily based on being extremely quiet too right? but seeing how the majority of people saying snake never played splinter cell or are pissed that the ps3 crippled the game, I understand why.

DoctorBunny

Played SC on Xbox. MGS gameplay is much more fun. SC has bad animation, and you say it's more realistic but sam never turns off his goggles, hidden in shadows means all, he can stand indefinitely on two side walls with his feet. Sam doesn't even crawl.

[QUOTE="jetthrovegas"]

[QUOTE="_en1gma_"]Garrett._en1gma_

Not an option, but good answer.Still Snake > Garret.

I like being different :D

Id pick Snake as well, however. If I had to choose.

Wrong. Garrett > Snake

Snake. Sam's a little boring :P. Dark_Link142

Sam fisher's a walking stereotype, i agree.

As for Snake, he's a modern ninja with a phd in psychedelic philosophy. The story's ridiculous, but kinda cool.