So it looks like Scribblenauts is getting the high 8s

Gametrailers review

IGN review

It's a pity the controls weren't just that tiny bit better because I think that one fix would have made this game 9+ material.

Still looks really cool though.

Yeah its a winner, just not as perfect as alot of people here thought it would be.

Spore of 2009.

I thought this game was a guaranteed AAAAE? :P

Ya know realistically there was probably 5-8 users hyping AAAA, countless hyping AAA and some AA

and thats just on gamespot, i haven't seen anyone on other sites hype it more than AAA, and as far as IGN goes, 0.3 below isn't horrible IMO

I thought this game was a guaranteed AAAAE? :P

Trinners

I do admit that the controls and physics are both exztremely ird. (stuff flps over WAY too easily.) but Id still give this game a 9 for the sheer innovation and fun in it.

wasn't this hyped as GOTY ? :lol:

I think it's hilarious that this game is getting 8s and 9s, people are saying its AAA material, and yet when people talk about the actual game it sounds like a 7.

wasn't this hyped as GOTY ? :lol:

anshul89

[QUOTE="anshul89"]

wasn't this hyped as GOTY ? :lol:

ReaperV7

OMG You have to give the link to that! Do you remember how long ago you read that!

[QUOTE="ReaperV7"][QUOTE="anshul89"]

wasn't this hyped as GOTY ? :lol:

flazzle

OMG You have to give the link to that! Do you remember how long ago you read that!

[QUOTE="flazzle"]

[QUOTE="ReaperV7"] its was hyped more than just GOTY.....DS fanboys were hyping it "game of the generation" ReaperV7

OMG You have to give the link to that! Do you remember how long ago you read that!

i'm almost entirely sure if someone here hyped it GOTG, they were alone so saying DS fanboys is wrong, as it implies more than 1 or 2

on topic: can't wait to buy it. looks good. oh jeez i'll have to be satisfied with an 8.7 type game! :roll:

I thought this game was a guaranteed AAAAE? :P

Trinners

I only saw one person say that. Lol. :P

I wanted it so bad, I new it wasn't going to get a 10. I thought a 8.0-9.0 (Which it got).

Haha GOTY and AAAA. This game flopped hard. PS2_ROCKS

Still could be handheld of the year, who knows? Yeah it flopped but not an epic flop.

Haha GOTY and AAAA. This game flopped hard. PS2_ROCKS

Well, technically it didn't flop yet. It has to flop here at GS.

However, I doubt the score will be anything near a 9 or 10.

This place needs an official way to hype games. Like, each new game should have an official voting thread prediction.

Haha GOTY and AAAA. This game flopped hard. PS2_ROCKS

I dont think its a flop at all but SW like over using words.

True it hasn't been reviewed here yet and we all know how unpredictable GS can be. Personally I like the concept of the game but I always felt it was being over hyped, like right after the E3 demo came out people started ridiculous claims.

Yeah the controls suck, big time. It's nearly unplayable... It's a shame they implemented the game mechanics pretty good but one thing broke the whole game. Kinda like Lair.

[QUOTE="flazzle"]

[QUOTE="ReaperV7"] its was hyped more than just GOTY.....DS fanboys were hyping it "game of the generation" ReaperV7

OMG You have to give the link to that! Do you remember how long ago you read that!

Hmm. I haven't found that statement here at GS. I did find some saying it's NOT 'game of the generation' though...