So was AC on PS3 having Frame rate issues BS?

First we hear IGN say it has bad framerates, then GS tells us they have great framerates. So which was true? Did we ever find out who was right?

Gamespot was right. IGN was wrong.

IGN's review was done by a huge XBOX fanboy btw.

Gamespot was right. IGN was wrong.

IGN's review was done by a huge XBOX fanboy btw.

Out_Kast3000

i thought gamespot was teh biased

now its ign? lol

Gamespot was right. IGN was wrong.

IGN's review was done by a huge XBOX fanboy btw.

Out_Kast3000

No sane person would trust you

Which site are we posting on?therealmcc0y

GS, wait it is GS right? *looks at top of monitor* Yup, definetly GS.

[QUOTE="Out_Kast3000"]

Gamespot was right. IGN was wrong.

IGN's review was done by a huge XBOX fanboy btw.

ParadiddleFill

i thought gamespot was teh biased

now its ign? lol

Fanboys change the rules when it suits them.

Its GS scores alwaysthat mattershere, no matter what anyone says

Gamespot was right. IGN was wrong.

IGN's review was done by a huge XBOX fanboy btw.

Out_Kast3000

BlimBlim(Gamersyde) said PS3 was worse by 2-3 fps. He did a side by side comparison.

Also GS is the only site who reviewed both and said PS3 had better framerate, every other site that played both said 360 had better framerate.

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

Pripyat

typo...?

sure.

AC version is better on PS3 according to GS.

GS IS WHAT MATTERS HERE

the framerate issues are bs, i've been playing the game and its been steady so far, the game has started off kinda slow, hope it picks up soon.mmirza23

\Did you notice any Jaggies or AA problems?

[QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

therealmcc0y

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

[QUOTE="therealmcc0y"][QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

Pripyat

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

Ive heard everywhere that their both equal.

[QUOTE="mmirza23"]the framerate issues are bs, i've been playing the game and its been steady so far, the game has started off kinda slow, hope it picks up soon.black_awpN1

\Did you notice any Jaggies or AA problems?

BlimBlim(Gamersyde) said PS3 was worse by 2-3 fps. He did a side by side comparison.

Harbadakus

I picked the game up on PS3, and I haven't noticed any framerate issues. At least none discernible to the naked eye.

[QUOTE="therealmcc0y"][QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

Pripyat

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

GS says otherwise, sorry mate PS3 has better version

[QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

therealmcc0y

typo...?

sure.

AC version is better on PS3 according to GS.

GS IS WHAT MATTERS HERE

:lol: as far as reviews go yes, gamespot is what matters here. Reviews are subjective so we need a set standard to judge games by in System Wars. But with objective matters like frame rate which can be proven one way or another, Gamespot is certainly not the ultimate truth. They may well be right on this occasion but thinking like that is crazy. If they turn around and said the world was about to end you'd have to believe them based on your logic.

[QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

therealmcc0y

typo...?

sure.

AC version is better on PS3 according to GS.

GS IS WHAT MATTERS HERE

GS says GTA SA on XBOX has longer loading times, are you going to tell me thats true

GS says CoD 2 has ragdoll physics, is that true?

[QUOTE="Pripyat"][QUOTE="therealmcc0y"][QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

black_awpN1

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

Ive heard everywhere that their both equal.

Then check out the links to hear otherwise.

[QUOTE="Pripyat"][QUOTE="therealmcc0y"][QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

therealmcc0y

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

GS says otherwise

You can cling on to that typo all you want, no one sane cares.

First we hear IGN say it has bad framerates, then GS tells us they have great framerates. So which was true? Did we ever find out who was right?

black_awpN1

dood, ive played a bunch of the game, and have as of yet to experience any, annnny frame rate issues...my bro has the 360 version as well....and i dont see any frame loss there either. so i dont know what any reviewer who claimed framerate problems is talking about.

unless i have a magic 360&PS3! they both look equally stunning....you cannot cannot i repeat cannot tell the differrence between the versions

and i do play my PS3 on a samsung 30 inch HDTV in 1080p/i

[QUOTE="mmirza23"]the framerate issues are bs, i've been playing the game and its been steady so far, the game has started off kinda slow, hope it picks up soon.black_awpN1

Did you notice any Jaggies or AA problems?

[QUOTE="black_awpN1"]

First we hear IGN say it has bad framerates, then GS tells us they have great framerates. So which was true? Did we ever find out who was right?

saolin323

I only saw Screen tearing in the Cutscenes where you can move the camera around. black_awpN1

[QUOTE="Harbadakus"]

BlimBlim(Gamersyde) said PS3 was worse by 2-3 fps. He did a side by side comparison.

QuasidodoJr

I picked the game up on PS3, and I haven't noticed any framerate issues. At least none discernible to the naked eye.

ok, I suppose that was an estimate, he said that the PS3 version was definitely slower by a tiny amount. (2-3 frames, possibly more since it was noticeable.)

[QUOTE="Pripyat"][QUOTE="therealmcc0y"][QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

therealmcc0y

Yes, a typo. x360 have better frame rate, PS3 have better lighting. Read the other reports.

GS says otherwise, sorry mate PS3 has better version

yeah but in this case GS can be proven wrong :|

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

Pripyat

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Oh ever so delusional proud lemming

[QUOTE="Pripyat"]

PS3 having better frame rate and x360 better lighting was a typo in the GS review, at least two other reviews have reported the exact opposite thing.

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834770p4.html

http://www.pro-g.co.uk/xbox360/assassins_creed/review-2.html

Metal_RAY

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Oh ever so delusional proud lemming

:lol: Delusional Denyall :lol:

When Gamespot scores R&C 7.5, then Gamespot is biased and IGN is right! When Gamespot says AC has a better framerate on PS3 (while every other known website on the face of the planet says that PS3 has the worse framerate) then Gamespot is the only website that isn't biased! PS3 fanboys never fail to amuse me.
And who cares about the framerate anyway? The PS3 always has that washed out look because its graphic card is slightly weaker than the 360's. The 360 can handle more high and low contrasts and high and low fidelity colors than the PS3's graphics card can. That's why all multiplatform games look nicer on the 360 with deeper colors and better lighting.Ninjaogta

Majority of the users complained about the reviewer, not the site.