Sorry PS3 fanboys, but you can't claim 2008 to be your year......not yet anyways

PS3 vs 360 only. (Retail)

2007 has been claimed as the Xbox 360's year, and lets take a look to see why.

360
Forza 2 - AAA
Bioshock - AAA
Halo 3 - AAA
Lost Planet - AA
C&C3 - AA
Eternal Sonata -AA
PGR4 - AA
Ace Combat 6 - AA
Mass Effect - AA

PS3
Warhawk - AA
Heavenly Sword - AA
Uncharted - AA
UTIII - AA
MLB 07: The Show - AA

So thats 9 360 games: 3 AAA's and 6 AA's against 5 PS3 games: 5 AA's. Clearly, the 360 takes it. It's not even close. Now lets look at this year so far.

360
Gears of War 2 - AAA
Ninja Gaiden II - AA
Tales of Vesperia - AA
Viva Pinata 2 - AA
Fable 2 - AA

PS3
MGS4 - AAAA
LittleBigPlanet - AAA
Motorstorm 2 - AA
MLB 08: The Show - AA

So thats 5 360 games:1 AAA and 4 AA's against 4 PS3 games: 1 AAAA, 1 AAA and 2 AA's. Yeah, PS3 wins, but only just. Theres certainly not as big a gap between the two line-ups as there was in 2007.

AND

We still have Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Red Alert 3, Naruto: The Broken Bond, Left 4 Dead and The Last Remnant coming on the 360's side. With Valkyria Chronicles, White Knight Chronicles (if it gets a Gamespot review this year), Naruto: Ultimate Ninja Storm and Resistance 2 coming on the PS3's side.

How anyone can claim this is the PS3's year, especially at this point in time, is beyond me.

(As usual, if ive missed any games let me know! not intentional!)

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong, isnt red alert 3 and L4D are on the pc so they arent exclusives.

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong.

imelitenow

Not this year

PS3 vs 360 only. (Retail)

2007 has been claimed as the Xbox 360's year, and lets take a look to see why.

360
Forza 2 - AAA
Bioshock - AAA
Halo 3 - AAA
Lost Planet - AA
C&C3 - AA
Eternal Sonata -AA
PGR4 - AA
Ace Combat 6 - AA
Mass Effect - AA

PS3
Warhawk - AA
Heavenly Sword - AA
Uncharted - AA
UTIII - AA
MLB 07: The Show - AA

So thats 9 360 games: 3 AAA's and 6 AA's against 5 PS3 games: 5 AA's. Clearly, the 360 takes it. It's not even close. Now lets look at this year so far.

360
Gears of War 2 - AAA
Ninja Gaiden II - AA
Tales of Vesperia - AA
Viva Pinata 2 - AA
Fable 2 - AA

PS3
MGS4 - AAAA
LittleBigPlanet - AAA
Motorstorm 2 - AA
MLB 08: The Show - AA

So thats 5 360 games:1 AAA and 4 AA's against 4 PS3 games: 1 AAAA, 1 AAA and 2 AA's. Yeah, PS3 wins, but only just. Theres certainly not as big a gap between the two line-ups as there was in 2007.

AND

We still have Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Red Alert 3, Left 4 Dead and The Last Remnant coming on the 360's side. With Valkyria Chronicles and Resistance 2 coming on the PS3's side.

How anyone can claim this is the PS3's year, especially at this point in time, is beyond me.

(As usual, if ive missed any games let me know! not intentional!)

-DrRobotnik-

[QUOTE="imelitenow"]

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong.

-DrRobotnik-

Not this year

then it cant be exclusive since it will be on the ps3

It's probably because of MGS4's score of 10. And PSN improvements, LBP. R 2, Home etc. And the majority of hyped games on the 360 flopped this year while nearly every big game on PS3 has met the hype.

You also missed WKC. You included ToV which doesn't come out in Europe until 2009, so including WKC sounds fair.

And you're a Microsoft Fanboy, this thread fails.Primo295

Actually you are the failure.

PS3 has it ATM, but if Resistance flops, and Banjo magically gets AAA (or something to that extent). It would be very very close.

because quality>quantity, especially when some of those AA titles was hyped to be AAA titles and the whole too Human fiasco doesn't help the 360's software this year to contest that so far, this is ps3's yearermacness

Im not looking at hype or anything like that. Just games and their GS scores. Yeah, quality is better that quantity, hence why the PS3 edges out the 360 so far. But calling it the PS3s year is silly.

And you're a Microsoft Fanboy, this thread fails.Primo295

Why is he a MS fanboy? He just posted facts :?

PS3 vs 360 only. (Retail)

2007 has been claimed as the Xbox 360's year, and lets take a look to see why.

360
Forza 2 - AAA
Bioshock - AAA
Halo 3 - AAA
Lost Planet - AA
C&C3 - AA
Eternal Sonata -AA
PGR4 - AA
Ace Combat 6 - AA
Mass Effect - AA

PS3
Warhawk - AA
Heavenly Sword - AA
Uncharted - AA
UTIII - AA
MLB 07: The Show - AA

So thats 9 360 games: 3 AAA's and 6 AA's against 5 PS3 games: 5 AA's. Clearly, the 360 takes it. It's not even close. Now lets look at this year so far.

360
Gears of War 2 - AAA
Ninja Gaiden II - AA
Tales of Vesperia - AA
Viva Pinata 2 - AA
Fable 2 - AA

PS3
MGS4 - AAAA
LittleBigPlanet - AAA
Motorstorm 2 - AA
MLB 08: The Show - AA

So thats 5 360 games:1 AAA and 4 AA's against 4 PS3 games: 1 AAAA, 1 AAA and 2 AA's. Yeah, PS3 wins, but only just. Theres certainly not as big a gap between the two line-ups as there was in 2007.

AND

We still have Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Red Alert 3, Left 4 Dead and The Last Remnantcoming on the 360's side. With Valkyria Chronicles and Resistance 2 coming on the PS3's side.

How anyone can claim this is the PS3's year, especially at this point in time, is beyond me.

(As usual, if ive missed any games let me know! not intentional!)

-DrRobotnik-

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="imelitenow"]

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong.

imelitenow

Not this year

then it cant be exclusive since it will be on the ps3

im not calling it exclusive. Im comparing 360's 08 lineup to PS3's 08 lineup.

It was never the year of PS3, Cows think one Good game makes up that the crap library they've had in the past, the more im starting to realize that the Cows are the Sheeps of last gen.

Team_Microsoft

now thats a fanboy post right there, i have a ps3 and im enjoying every single title, R2 must be one of the greatest titles this year aside from MGS4 ofcourse.

i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.jakarai

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

It's probably because of MGS4's score of 10. And PSN improvements, LBP. R 2, Home etc. And the majoity of hyped games on the 360 flopped this year while nearly every big game on PS3 has met the hype.

You also missed WKC. You included ToV which doesn't come out in Europe until 2009, so including WKC sounds fair.

Floppy_Jim

PSN improvements? Do you mean Sony playing catch up whereabout XBL had those features long before PSN?

Where is this fantasy World "HOME"?

Yeah like Socom and Haze matched the hype:lol:

[QUOTE="imelitenow"][QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="imelitenow"]

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong.

-DrRobotnik-

Not this year

then it cant be exclusive since it will be on the ps3

im not calling it exclusive. Im comparing 360's 08 lineup to PS3's 08 lineup.

i bet there is more games that are coming out for the PS3 besides those 2:?, and i think that the PS3 already won 2008.

It's probably because of MGS4's score of 10. And PSN improvements, LBP. R 2, Home etc. And the majoity of hyped games on the 360 flopped this year while nearly every big game on PS3 has met the hype.

You also missed WKC. You included ToV which doesn't come out in Europe until 2009, so including WKC sounds fair.

Floppy_Jim

PSN improvements? Do you mean Sony playing catch up whereabout XBL had those features long before PSN?

Where is this fantasy World "HOME"?

Yeah like Socom and Haze matched the hype:lol:

Tales of vesperia(8.5) was Reviewed and sold injapan and US still counts...

PS3 vs 360 only. (Retail)

2007 has been claimed as the Xbox 360's year, and lets take a look to see why.

360
Forza 2 - AAA
Bioshock - AAA
Halo 3 - AAA
Lost Planet - AA
C&C3 - AA
Eternal Sonata -AA
PGR4 - AA
Ace Combat 6 - AA
Mass Effect - AA

PS3
Warhawk - AA
Heavenly Sword - AA
Uncharted - AA
UTIII - AA
MLB 07: The Show - AA

So thats 9 360 games: 3 AAA's and 6 AA's against 5 PS3 games: 5 AA's. Clearly, the 360 takes it. It's not even close. Now lets look at this year so far.

360
Gears of War 2 - AAA
Ninja Gaiden II - AA
Tales of Vesperia - AA
Viva Pinata 2 - AA
Fable 2 - AA

PS3
MGS4 - AAAA
LittleBigPlanet - AAA
Motorstorm 2 - AA
MLB 08: The Show - AA

So thats 5 360 games:1 AAA and 4 AA's against 4 PS3 games: 1 AAAA, 1 AAA and 2 AA's. Yeah, PS3 wins, but only just. Theres certainly not as big a gap between the two line-ups as there was in 2007.

AND

We still have Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Red Alert 3, Left 4 Dead and The Last Remnant coming on the 360's side. With Valkyria Chronicles and Resistance 2 coming on the PS3's side.

How anyone can claim this is the PS3's year, especially at this point in time, is beyond me.

(As usual, if ive missed any games let me know! not intentional!)

-DrRobotnik-

It was never the year of PS3, Cows think one Good game makes up that the crap library they've had in the past, the more im starting to realize that the Cows are the Sheeps of last gen.

Team_Microsoft

Cows the sheeps of last gen? That's strechting it just a bit don't you think. Please name the games that are not on PC or coming to PC that makes the Xbox 360 soooo much better then the PS3?

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

It's probably because of MGS4's score of 10. And PSN improvements, LBP. R 2, Home etc. And the majoity of hyped games on the 360 flopped this year while nearly every big game on PS3 has met the hype.

You also missed WKC. You included ToV which doesn't come out in Europe until 2009, so including WKC sounds fair.

Team_Microsoft

PSN improvements? Do you mean Sony playing catch up whereabout XBL had those features long before PSN?

Where is this fantasy World "HOME"?

Yeah like Socom and Haze matched the hype:lol:

dont bash those games, i put in many hours into Socom and Haze and enjoyed them alot.

[QUOTE="Primo295"]And you're a Microsoft Fanboy, this thread fails.MrSlippery39

Actually you are the failure.

PS3 has it ATM, but if Resistance flops, and Banjo magically gets AAA (or something to that extent). It would be very very close.

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="imelitenow"][QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="imelitenow"]

i beleive that The Last Remnant is also on the ps3, but correct me if im wrong.

imelitenow

Not this year

then it cant be exclusive since it will be on the ps3

im not calling it exclusive. Im comparing 360's 08 lineup to PS3's 08 lineup.

i bet there is more games that are coming out for the PS3 besides those 2:?, and i think that the PS3 already won 2008.

Yeah there is, and more 360 games on the way too. I only picked those games because they have a good chance of AA at least.

[QUOTE="Team_Microsoft"][QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]

It's probably because of MGS4's score of 10. And PSN improvements, LBP. R 2, Home etc. And the majoity of hyped games on the 360 flopped this year while nearly every big game on PS3 has met the hype.

You also missed WKC. You included ToV which doesn't come out in Europe until 2009, so including WKC sounds fair.

imelitenow

PSN improvements? Do you mean Sony playing catch up whereabout XBL had those features long before PSN?

Where is this fantasy World "HOME"?

Yeah like Socom and Haze matched the hype:lol:

dont bash those games, i put in many hours into Socom and Haze and enjoyed them alot.

So you list Bioshock for the 360 in 2007 but not for the PS3 in 2008?
DireToad

Apparently. Although you can argue this thread is more about 2008 than 2007.

So you're not going to add WKC then? It's out in December and since the PS3 is region-free, anyone can play it this year (Albeit it in Japanese). Yet European members of the site can't play Tales of Vesperia at all.Floppy_Jim

I don't think we use imports on SW's lists.

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.-DrRobotnik-

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.jakarai

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

But i can play them on my 360 right now. In 2007, i couldnt play them on my PS3. Im looking at exclusives, but only between the PS3 and 360.

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.jakarai

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

it wouldn't be convenient for the 360 list if he did ;)

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.jakarai

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

This makes sense... TC you need to add Bioshock and Eternal Sonata for the PS3 since it is PSe vs Xbox in 08...

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.jakarai

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]So you're not going to add WKC then? It's out in December and since the PS3 is region-free, anyone can play it this year (Albeit it in Japanese). Yet European members of the site can't play Tales of Vesperia at all.fakecliche

I don't think we use imports on SW's lists.

Oh, OK. But in the interest of fairness, I think the TC should write "In NA and Japan only" next to ToV. There are quite a few Europeans on this site, although the majority seem to be American.

Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts is the only game out of those 4 that is exclusive. Red Alert 3 and Left 4 Dead are coming to the PC and The Last Remnant is multiplat. I can't see Banjo and Kazooie being anymore than a AA at best.

PS3 vs 360 only. (Retail)

2007 has been claimed as the Xbox 360's year, and lets take a look to see why.

360
Forza 2 - AAA
Bioshock - AAA
Halo 3 - AAA
Lost Planet - AA
C&C3 - AA
Eternal Sonata -AA
PGR4 - AA
Ace Combat 6 - AA
Mass Effect - AA

PS3
Warhawk - AA
Heavenly Sword - AA
Uncharted - AA
UTIII - AA
MLB 07: The Show - AA

So thats 9 360 games: 3 AAA's and 6 AA's against 5 PS3 games: 5 AA's. Clearly, the 360 takes it. It's not even close. Now lets look at this year so far.

360
Gears of War 2 - AAA
Ninja Gaiden II - AA
Tales of Vesperia - AA
Viva Pinata 2 - AA
Fable 2 - AA

PS3
MGS4 - AAAA
LittleBigPlanet - AAA
Motorstorm 2 - AA
MLB 08: The Show - AA

So thats 5 360 games:1 AAA and 4 AA's against 4 PS3 games: 1 AAAA, 1 AAA and 2 AA's. Yeah, PS3 wins, but only just. Theres certainly not as big a gap between the two line-ups as there was in 2007.

AND

We still have Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, Red Alert 3, Left 4 Dead and The Last Remnant coming on the 360's side. With Valkyria Chronicles, White Knight Chronicles (if it gets a Gamespot review this year) and Resistance 2 coming on the PS3's side.

How anyone can claim this is the PS3's year, especially at this point in time, is beyond me.

(As usual, if ive missed any games let me know! not intentional!)

-DrRobotnik-

Good thread

people need to realise this

[QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="jakarai"][QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.DireToad

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

But i can play them on my 360 right now. In 2007, i couldnt play them on my PS3. Im looking at exclusives, but only between the PS3 and 360.

I thought i was being completely logical. think about it.

[QUOTE="DireToad"][QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"][QUOTE="jakarai"][QUOTE="-DrRobotnik-"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]i would take this thread seriously if you didn't list so many multiplat games on the xbox 360s side.-DrRobotnik-

multiplats that arent on the PS3. Hmm...see what im getting at? I didnt even use the word exclusive in my post.

So why leave Bioshock and Eternal Sonata off the list for PS3 for 2008? They didn't release on the Xbox 360 this year.

But i can play them on my 360 right now. In 2007, i couldnt play them on my PS3. Im looking at exclusives, but only between the PS3 and 360.

I thought i was being completely logical. think about it.

Think about what? That you willingly omit certain games on the PS3 to make your point look valid?

Who cares if you could play those games in 2007? Isn't the thread about what games came out in 2008?DireToad

Exactly, this is a thread comparing PS3s 08 lineup with 360s 08 lineup. Obviously, im not going to include games on the PS3's list that i can play on the 360, and vice versa. So listing Bioshock on the PS3s list doesnt make sense, since its in no way exclusive. At least in 2007, Bioshock was 360 exclusive when only focusing on the PS3 and 360.