Super Mario Galaxy > Halo 3? It's All in the Merits, Baby

11 Super Mario Galaxy merits.

8 Halo 3 merits.

SMG GOTY?
SMG > Halo 3?
11 > 8?
Is my fanboy side showing? :shock:

Discuss.

Mario Galaxy also has 5 bits listed under "The Good" along with 2 under "The Bad"

Compared to Halo 3's 4 under "The Good" and 3 under "The Bad"

:P

Mario Galaxy for GOTY!!

It'd be really cool if SMG won GOTY. I know I've been predicting Halo 3 to win GOTY here, but I have a soft spot for Mario platformers.

SMG looks absolutely stunning and Wii owners are very lucky. Time to steal a Wii, so hopefully more people I know buy it.

SMG is more deserving of GOTY as far as I'm concerned.

Galaxy for GOTY! :P

omg lol yes of course wii better than 360, therefore mario > halo 3.

lol wut?

to me it looks like halo 3 has better/more meaningfulmeritsArbiter1237

Who's to judge which merits hold more.... merit?

Anyways, you can't compare the two games.

merrits really dont matter

i assume that u just went and counted the merits for each game instead of looking at what each one was for

so im gunna leave this by saying Halo 3 > Super Mario Galaxy? ITS ALL ABOUT THE ONLINE

merrits really dont matter

i assume that u just went and counted the merits for each game instead of looking at what each one was for

so im gunna leave this by saying Halo 3 > Super Mario Galaxy? ITS ALL ABOUT THE ONLINE

Raider47

Can Master Chief turn into a bee?

OoOo What now!?

[QUOTE="Raider47"]

merrits really dont matter

i assume that u just went and counted the merits for each game instead of looking at what each one was for

so im gunna leave this by saying Halo 3 > Super Mario Galaxy? ITS ALL ABOUT THE ONLINE

tbone29

Can Master Chief turn into a bee?

OoOo What now!?

He's allergic, so the Arbitor just shoots them for him.

[QUOTE="Raider47"]

merrits really dont matter

i assume that u just went and counted the merits for each game instead of looking at what each one was for

so im gunna leave this by saying Halo 3 > Super Mario Galaxy? ITS ALL ABOUT THE ONLINE

tbone29

Can Master Chief turn into a bee?

OoOo What now!?

[QUOTE="tbone29"][QUOTE="Raider47"]

merrits really dont matter

i assume that u just went and counted the merits for each game instead of looking at what each one was for

so im gunna leave this by saying Halo 3 > Super Mario Galaxy? ITS ALL ABOUT THE ONLINE

SSCyborg

Can Master Chief turn into a bee?

OoOo What now!?

He's allergic, so the Arbitor just shoots them for him.

Nothing a fire suit can't fix. Mario will be shooting back in no time :P

Review wise, SMG wins. No doubt. The review is right there. It's clear. Fact. Whether you agree or not is different. The review says that SMG is better. But you know Gamespot. They'll pull a fast one.

"Halo 3 game of the year!!" -Gamespot

"But you yourselves gave SMG a better score..." -The masses

We can all agree on this... 11 > 8.

It might not mean much when it comes to GOTY or whether SMG or Halo 3 is better... but the sheep win the merit battle, right?

It doesnt have better graphics, online, multiplayer, and overrall longivity of Halo 3.

Take standards into account next time.

It doesnt have better graphics, online, multiplayer, and overrall longivity of Halo 3.

Take standards into account next time.

Synthetic_NinJI

I'll take fun into account.

Something I hold to equal standards from the Wii and 360.

Review wise, SMG wins. No doubt. The review is right there. It's clear. Fact. Whether you agree or not is different. The review says that SMG is better. But you know Gamespot. They'll pull a fast one.

"Halo 3 game of the year!!" -Gamespot

"But you yourselves gave SMG a better score..." -The masses

brightshadow525

Could you point out the part where he said Super Mario Galaxy is better than Halo 3?

Quality over quantity and more then your moneys worth and good multiplayer FTW

They scored the same and Wii's standards are lower than the 360's...

Not only that, they're two completely different genres. I think you're grasping at straws...w/e though. If it helps you sleep better then, Yay for merits!!! :|

How can you compare a FPS with a platformer? It doesn't make sesne just like this thread.