I personally see nothing wrong with the idea of a third timeline existing where Link fails to defeat Ganondorf. Because there is already a timeline split thanks to OOT, its not that unbelievable that there would be one where Link failed. If you think about it, it does make sense and helps tie in the earlier games that were not as focused on trying together a story.
Here's an idea of how the timeline works, and I'm willing to discuss this point.
Link dies by Ganondorf's hands at some point in OOT after the Sacred Realm is opened(most likely when he was a child). With Link dead, Ganondorf sets his sights on collecting all the pieces of the triforce. Even though Link has been killed, the Triforce still splits, leaving Ganondorf with the Triforce of Power, Zelda(Who is still presumably alive) the Triforce of Wisdom, and the Triforce of Courage vanishes until someone worthy of its power appears(another Link). Ganondorf, obsessed with finding the Triforce of courage stays in the sacred realm(Because he could not simply wait for Link to show up) and slowly begins to change his appearance into the boar form that would be seen in the first three Zelda games.
Because Ganondorf is busy with his search in the sacred realm, the monarchy of Hyrule is restored. In addition, much of Hyrule escapes the horrors of OOT due to Ganondorf's search of the sacred realm. Since the hero of time was dead, the sacred realm remained open and more portals were uncovered in Hyrule by people searching for the Triforce. Over time, these people became corrupted and transformed, and many of them became followers of Ganondorf.
In the end, the Sacred Realm becomes corrupted and dark power flowed from the open portals. Realizing the danger, the King of Hyrule orders the seven sages to seal the Sacred Realm. This starts the Imprisoning War that ends with the deaths of many knights but with the success of the Sages. With Ganondorf sealed in the sacred realm, the people begin to forget about the Sacred Realm and as time passes, Ganondorf is able to create an alternate form that can enter the Light World(Hyrule)
As far as who the king is, I don't think his fate was ever depicted in OOT. So, it either would be the King of Hyrule who managed to restore himself to the throne after Ganondorf began his search in OOT or he's a descentet of OOT's Zelda.
*******
Now one thing I should note, is that I have no issue accepting the third split in the timeline. Many time travel storylines depict an alternate future where the hero fails. With that said, this is the best way to ensure the first three games stay within the series canon.
Log in to comment