1.Super Mario Galaxy WII Nintendo 97.9%
2.The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time N64 Nintendo 97.5%
3.Metroid Prime GC Nintendo 96.3%
This topic is locked from further discussion.
the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game ever-D3MO-Highest rated doesn't necessarily equal best. :) Best is in the eye of the beholder.
[QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game evernintendofreak_2Highest rated doesn't necessarily equal best. :) Best is in the eye of the beholder.
Besides, Majora's Mask deserves it, not Ocarina of Time :P. Lol I kid.
I wonder if Nintendo can go for another one next gen. Maybe replace one of those 3, or come in at number 4.
Highest rated doesn't necessarily equal best. :) Best is in the eye of the beholder.[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game evertbone29
Besides, Majora's Mask deserves it, not Ocarina of Time :P. Lol I kid.
I can whole-heartedly agree on that. MM was much better.[QUOTE="paksiwin"]Wow i didnt know SMG topped OoT!
1.Super Mario Galaxy WII Nintendo 97.9%
2.The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time N64 Nintendo 97.5%
3.Metroid Prime GC Nintendo 96.3%
JLAudio7
[QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game everNickman71
If you didn't like it, it doesn't belong!
I guess I should write IMO after everything I say...because fanboys will ***** about it...
IMO THe only game that deserves to be up there is Ocarina of Time...I didn't like Metorid Prime, and SMG is not zomg best game ever..IMO.
You might think Big Rigs is the best game ever...and whatever I don't have a problem w/ it.
I disagree w/ those scores...sue me.
[QUOTE="Nickman71"][QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game ever-D3MO-
If you didn't like it, it doesn't belong!
I guess I should write IMO after everything I say...because fanboys will ***** about it...
IMO THe only game that deserves to be up there is Ocarina of Time...I didn't like Metorid Prime, and SMG is not zomg best game ever..IMO.
You might think Big Rigs is the best game ever...and whatever I don't have a problem w/ it.
I disagree w/ those scores...sue me.
I respect your opinion, and respectfully disagree. MP should be #1 on that list.
[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]It's kinda wierd how I don't like 2 of the 3 highest rated games of all time... ljlrjso wat theyI hated OoT and I didn't like MP that much. I have yet to play SMG though.
[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="Nickman71"][QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game everDr_Corndog
If you didn't like it, it doesn't belong!
I guess I should write IMO after everything I say...because fanboys will ***** about it...
IMO THe only game that deserves to be up there is Ocarina of Time...I didn't like Metorid Prime, and SMG is not zomg best game ever..IMO.
You might think Big Rigs is the best game ever...and whatever I don't have a problem w/ it.
I disagree w/ those scores...sue me.
I respect your opinion, and respectfully disagree. MP should be #1 on that list.
I respect ur opinion as well.
Everyone has different tastes.
[QUOTE="Dr_Corndog"][QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="Nickman71"][QUOTE="-D3MO-"]the only game that deservs to be up there of thsoe 3 is OOT...that game was epic...Metroid Prime I didn't like, and SMG isin't the best game ever-D3MO-
If you didn't like it, it doesn't belong!
I guess I should write IMO after everything I say...because fanboys will ***** about it...
IMO THe only game that deserves to be up there is Ocarina of Time...I didn't like Metorid Prime, and SMG is not zomg best game ever..IMO.
You might think Big Rigs is the best game ever...and whatever I don't have a problem w/ it.
I disagree w/ those scores...sue me.
I respect your opinion, and respectfully disagree. MP should be #1 on that list.
I respect ur opinion as well.
Everyone has different tastes.
Yup, I taste like waffles with dulce de leche.
1 for each gen, nice.
However I don't expect SMG to last in that #1 spot. Only a matter of time before we see 1-2 low scoring reviews that'll drop it. Still, yet another Nintendo game in the top 10. :)
I haven't played metroid or SMG, but they are completely right about the ocarina of time. by far and away the best game i have ever played.
For me Starcraft would come in a close second, with halo 1 as the third. halo not because it was an amazing game, but just cause i had soooo much fun with LAN parties with my freinds. Just great for laughs.
1 for each gen, nice.
However I don't expect SMG to last in that #1 spot. Only a matter of time before we see 1-2 low scoring reviews that'll drop it. Still, yet another Nintendo game in the top 10. :)
laus_basic
I hope some website or magazine doesn't just give it an incredibly low score so it's number 2 on the list. Of course, I doubt that will happen.
Good for Nintendo. Metroid Prime was an 8.6 out of 10 for me, and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was a 9.4 out of 10 for me. I thought Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess was better. It was better than Phantom Hourglass, though. I've yet to play Super Mario Galaxy, but if it tops what is considered the most revolutionary game ever, then I can't wait.
Metroid Prime doesn't deserve to be that high, and not higher than Half Life 2.
It was probably reviewed during a time of casual drug taking among reviewers. that's the only explanation I can think of.
Ocarina of Time yes I would put up there, Metroid Prime no. It's not THAT great to be #3 of all time.
So let me get this straight, whenever your games score high on GR your all primed to use it, but when the big N gets the top three you all back away? Stop being hypocritical, Gs scored all three of these games insanly high as well, and i'm sure galaxy would have been even higher if it had not been for this new review system.Battleer
I agree...
I want to see Cows' reaction to this... hamstergeddon
It was probably reviewed during a time of casual drug taking among reviewers. that's the only explanation I can think of.
PhoebusFlows
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment