True or False? Wii-mote > PS3 wand > natal

seems very awkward using ps3 wand without nunchuk while playing RE5

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgDV48JbYXw

Would you play RE5 standing up ?

True, that RE5 control scheme is incedibly dumb. At this point I still think the wii mote is the most refined controller in terms of layout between the 2. I have no clue about Natal yet.

Would you play RE5 standing up ?

Nike_Air

Would you need to stand up to play RE5?

Both PS3 Wand andNatal have fatal flaws that make them worse than the Wii Mote.

PS3 Wand: No Nunchuk-like accesory...but why do that when you can just connect the whole Dualshock Controller to the wand...Right?

Natal: No Controller. Severly limits genre possibilities.

Wii Motion+ = PS3 Wand>Natal>Wii-mote

Thats what i believe. But Natal would only work for me if they gave you like lets say the halo battle rifle to play a gun game :p

How can you judge -- one is already out on the market and the other two aren't.

Edit: Wow, thats so fail. Who the hell thoughtthatwould be a good control scheme?

TRUE.

Wii Mote is #1.

I can't give an honest opinion about NATAL or PSWand until they are actually out. I can say Wii is #1, since I have actually tested it. :)

How can you judge -- one is already out on the market and the other two aren't.Haziqonfire

That is how you know it is better

[spoiler] Juuuust Kidding [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

Would you play RE5 standing up ?

me_rock

Would you need to stand up to play RE5?

to psycho analyze his response.. nike_air seems to be a ps3 fan... ps3 fans usually dislike x360 the most and obviously defend the ps3...

the first thing that came to his mind was.. "fine.. RE5 looks awkward with ps3 wand.. but what about natal? it definitely would be even more awkward playing RE5 with natal.. how would you play it.. standing up like in the promo videos?"

so being pressured to be the first poster to defend the ps3 by shifting the awkwardness to x360 natal.. he brain farted the statement "would you play RE5 standing up?"

p.s. that was all joking btw.. :P (don't hate me nike_air)

How can you judge -- one is already out on the market and the other two aren't.Haziqonfire

PS3 wand > natal = TRUE

Wiimote > PS3 Wand = FALSE

PS3 wand > natal = TRUE

Wiimote > PS3 Wand = FALSE

jakehouston88

PS3 wand > natal = TRUE

Wiimote > PS3 Wand = TRUE

jakehouston88

That's better, and true.:P

False. The PS3 wand means I can utilize motion sensing in some of my favorite high definition games as opposed to grainy standard definition games. Bentham

i like your icon:roll:fanboy.

[QUOTE="Bentham"]False. The PS3 wand means I can utilize motion sensing in some of my favorite high definition games as opposed to grainy standard definition games. gamedude234

i like your icon:roll:fanboy.

I'm sure he likes your Bowser on a MarioKart Icon.

Until the other two are actually available to me, the Wiimote is the best. After that, who knows.

I think theres definite promise for all three. I'm far more interested in natal than the PS3 wand however, simply because so far, I can't see what the wand will achieve that the wiimote hasn't.

False. The PS3 wand is more accurate than Motion Plus and NATAL is an entirely different animal altogether.

Anyone else lol'ing at the cows who already know the wand is best? :lol:

False. The PS3 wand is more accurate than Motion Plus and NATAL is an entirely different animal altogether.

foxhound_fox

WOW! you can predict the future!:o:roll:

true. Thewii motion plusis more accurate thanthe ps3 wandand NATAL is an entirely differentgimmick altogether.

foxhound_fox

fixed

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

[QUOTE="Bentham"]False. The PS3 wand means I can utilize motion sensing in some of my favorite high definition games as opposed to grainy standard definition games. SolidTy

i like your icon:roll:fanboy.

I'm sure he likes your Bowser on a MarioKart Icon.

me having a mariokart icon doesn't mean i'am a sheep. it shows i may be a mario fanboy, and in the end, who isn't?;) his icon shows he's a ps3 fanboy.which is untolerable.

WOW! you can predict the future!:o:roll:

gamedude234

Sorry sony, I'm not holding a cpntroller in one hand, and a wand in the other. Either make a nunchcuk attachmnt or forget about any real support.

By the way, is the want motion sensitive, or is just reading the light? What if i want to use the controller sideways for a racing game or a puzzle game?

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

WOW! you can predict the future!:o:roll:

foxhound_fox

at E3 sony showed that with the ps3wand you can hit a tennis ball in the virtual world:o

Too early to tell. However, I find the nunchuck/wii remote combination one of the best control schemes ever. You literally forget about the controls while playing at times, and that to me is a sign of close to perfect control scheme.

Nintendo really nailed it IMO.

And people forget they tested a camera option similar to NATAL, but passed.

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

WOW! you can predict the future!:o:roll:

foxhound_fox

What do you have against accelerometers? What does the Sony Wand rely on, a camera?

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

WOW! you can predict the future!:o:roll:

foxhound_fox

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

true. The wii motion plus is more accurate than the ps3 wand and NATAL is an entirely different gimmick altogether.

gamedude234

fixed

LOL, NOPE.

It has been proven that the early model of the PS3 wand is more accurate than the Wiimote with motion +.

;)

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

true. The wii motion plus is more accurate than the ps3 wand and NATAL is an entirely different gimmick altogether.

jakehouston88

fixed

LOL, NOPE.

It has been proven that the early model of the PS3 wand is more accurate than the Wiimote with motion +.

;)

It has not been proven and the Wii-mote is out with games and the wand is not.

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

true. The wii motion plus is more accurate than the ps3 wand and NATAL is an entirely different gimmick altogether.

jakehouston88

fixed

LOL, NOPE.

It has been proven that the early model of the PS3 wand is more accurate than the Wiimote with motion +.

;)

proven by who, you?:lol:i'd like a reliable source please.

It has not been proven and the Wii-mote is out with games and the wand is not.

BurningSludge

proven by who, you? :lol: i'd like a reliable source please.gamedude234

IGN tested the early model of the PS wand at E3 and said, "it is more accurate than the Wiimote a little."

seems very awkward using ps3 wand without nunchuk while playing RE5

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgDV48JbYXw

Mystery_Writer

As for the topic. If we are talking about impressive technology. I think it's Natal>Wand>Wiimote. If we are talking about application for gaming.. We have to wait and see...

[QUOTE="BurningSludge"]

It has not been proven and the Wii-mote is out with games and the wand is not.

jakehouston88

proven by who, you? :lol: i'd like a reliable source please.gamedude234

IGN tested the early model of the PS wand at E3 and said, "it is more accurate than the Wiimote a little."

IGN?lol in wHAT SENSE"A LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN the wiimote.?" notice they didn't mention the wii motion plus.

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

[QUOTE="BurningSludge"]

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]proven by who, you? :lol: i'd like a reliable source please.gamedude234

IGN tested the early model of the PS wand at E3 and said, "it is more accurate than the Wiimote a little."

IGN?lol in wHAT SENSE"A LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN the wiimote.?" notice they didn't mention the wii motion plus.

The PS wand is far more accurate than the normal Wiimote, and is a bit more acurrate than the Wii motion +.

:)

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

IGN tested the early model of the PS wand at E3 and said, "it is more accurate than the Wiimote a little."

jakehouston88

IGN?lol in wHAT SENSE"A LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN the wiimote.?" notice they didn't mention the wii motion plus.

The PS wand is far more accurate than the normal Wiimote, and is a bit more acurrate than the Wii motion +.

:)

"a little?"pfffffttt."a little" isn't going to persuade me to pay 360 euros for a gimmick

Sonys Wand = JOKE which isnt even funny. Natal = looks fun. Wii Mote = simple winner. If anyone proclaims Sony's wand is something more than a joke then i have to say your a crazy as that control scheme is just stupid with a capital STUPID.Dibdibdobdobo

i could not agree with you more.

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

IGN tested the early model of the PS wand at E3 and said, "it is more accurate than the Wiimote a little."

jakehouston88

IGN?lol in wHAT SENSE"A LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN the wiimote.?" notice they didn't mention the wii motion plus.

The PS wand is far more accurate than the normal Wiimote, and is a bit more acurrate than the Wii motion +.

:)

You misquoted me. The PS wand may be a little more accrate but it a lot less buttons and looks like a Vibrator.

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

[QUOTE="gamedude234"]

IGN?lol in wHAT SENSE"A LITTLE MORE ACCURATE THAN the wiimote.?" notice they didn't mention the wii motion plus.

The PS wand is far more accurate than the normal Wiimote, and is a bit more acurrate than the Wii motion +.

:)

You misquoted me. The PS wand may be a little more accrate but it a lot less buttons and looks like a Vibrator.

[QUOTE="Burning-Sludge"]

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

The PS wand is far more accurate than the normal Wiimote, and is a bit more acurrate than the Wii motion +.

:)

Dibdibdobdobo

You misquoted me. The PS wand may be a little more accrate but it a lot less buttons and looks like a Vibrator.

again, i agree with you.