Uncharted Review(IGN)

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/834/834931p1.html

9.1

GS will give it an 8.5, hoping for a 9.

:D

it will flop im guessing 6.5Guitartod

lmfao r u serious

it will flop im guessing 6.5Guitartod

LOL

[QUOTE="Guitartod"]it will flop im guessing 6.5Udsen

LOL

sadly i have to agree with him. GS has recently made a point of throwing curve balls. They could very well give this game the mantle of "identity crisis" and dock 3+ points for that.

[QUOTE="Udsen"]

[QUOTE="Guitartod"]it will flop im guessing 6.5-Serpahim-

LOL

sadly i have to agree with him. GS has recently made a point of throwing curve balls. They could very well give this game the mantle of "identity crisis" and dock 3+ points for that.

Or, give it a really good score like they did AC.

[QUOTE="-Serpahim-"][QUOTE="Udsen"]

[QUOTE="Guitartod"]it will flop im guessing 6.5Udsen

LOL

sadly i have to agree with him. GS has recently made a point of throwing curve balls. They could very well give this game the mantle of "identity crisis" and dock 3+ points for that.

Or, give it a really good score like they did AC.

yeah...u never know these days...its a gamble when it comes to GS :P It seems like the standards of what makes a good game vary drastically from reviewer to reveiwer...at least 1up ALL the reviewers think every game is crap. Here it all depends on who is reviewing, what day it is, and if he had a good night or not.

[QUOTE="Udsen"][QUOTE="-Serpahim-"][QUOTE="Udsen"]

[QUOTE="Guitartod"]it will flop im guessing 6.5-Serpahim-

LOL

sadly i have to agree with him. GS has recently made a point of throwing curve balls. They could very well give this game the mantle of "identity crisis" and dock 3+ points for that.

Or, give it a really good score like they did AC.

yeah...u never know these days...its a gamble when it comes to GS :P It seems like the standards of what makes a good game vary drastically from reviewer to reveiwer...at least 1up ALL the reviewers think every game is crap. Here it all depends on who is reviewing, what day it is, and if he had a good night or not.

1up is a joke. Either a game is OMGWTFGODLY!!!!!!!!!1 or #$*!

who knows which way this could go

AC got a 9 here and a 7.7 at IGN

usually IGN give higher reviews, so Uncharted will prob get a 8-8.5

1up is a joke. Either a game is OMGWTFGODLY!!!!!!!!!1 or #$*!

Udsen

1up is trash, but atleast they can agree to hate everything :P GS on the other hand...well, u never know.... :|

First of all congratulations to Naughty Dog for breaking there good game drought. Hip HipHooray and so forth. Secondly although it got a really good score and it looks like a mighty fun game that would i wouldn't complain about having on 360, i got this bad feeling that GS will score it low. I am thinking logically that it will get 9.0 or 8.5 but my gut says 6.5-7.5.

PS: IGN AC reveiw was a total travisty. They must have been having a bad day (AC 7.7, NFS: PS 6.8, A51:BS, 6.4) Then to give Kane and Lynch a seven???

[QUOTE="Udsen"]

1up is a joke. Either a game is OMGWTFGODLY!!!!!!!!!1 or #$*!

-Serpahim-

1up is trash, but atleast they can agree to hate everything :P GS on the other hand...well, u never know.... :|

God, sometimes I just think I give up on every site.

You never know who's opinion or viewpoint fits yours.

it will flop im guessing 6.5Guitartod

How do u figure? Assassins Creed may have got an AAA here but every other site seems to not agree. I think Uncharted has a great chance of getting AAA here. If Assassins can get an AAA, I dont see how Uncharted cant, but I guess its just up to who reviews it. If sports man reviews it, yes 6.5 maybe less.

Reasons I got a 360:

Bioshock

Deadrising

Fable 2

Perhaps Mass Effect... dunno.. Halo is stupid and pointless.

Reasons I will get a PS3:

R&C

Uncharted

MGS4

Warhawk

Perhaps Final Fantasy

Hmmmm

Oh yeah. We have a tie here.