Uncharted VS A. Creed VS Mass EFFECT

Length

Uncharted 15 hours long

AC 40 hours long

ME 50 to 70 hours long

ME wins for bang for the buck in game time.

The you progress through the missions

Uncharted Linear always moving on to a new place (so it seams their is no back tracking)

AC all your objectives are in the same sandbox map. Think of it as GTA without the guns and doing missions just chasing people

ME Linear like Uncharted with probably revisiting locations aka Resident Evil like on a bigger scale. Back tracking events

Tie between ME and Uncharted. Their is only so much u can do in one city in AC.

Graphics

Uncharted Real time lighting etc etc with zero jaggies, great deal of people consider it the new graphics king. THe demo showed that u can walk ankle deep in water and have wet shoes, u can walk waist deep and have wet pants etc etc ur whole body is wet.

AC Similiar to Uncharted just not as pretty.

ME Recycled enviroments just like Oblivion (which is WHY IT CAN FIT on a DVD) If it weren't for the environment recycling it would of had a harder time fitting on DVD and keeping its quality.

Uncharted wins in Graphics because during ME high resolution moments they blur the background during conversations and etc showing the limits of the hardware being maxed on the characters. Uncharted keeps a blend of nice graphics on Character and backdrop at all times. On top of the cool water effects and lush environments.

Gameplay

Uncharted Camera angles like Gears and Resident Evil, running around like Tomb Raider, Shooting like Gears & RE. With some puzzle solving and hand to hand fighting.

AC not entirely sure some hand to hand combat with knifes etc. Lots of chasing down enemies while running on roof tops and streets. Could be similiar to Hitman.

Mass Effect Auto combat with select screen options, with the occasional gun control. Much of hte 50 to 70 hours will be spent talking to other NPC's. Actually gameplay time will be considerably shorter. Maybe 30 to 45 hours.

Uncharted wins due to more going on, and more control. GS will say"Identity issues."

Final GS predictions

Uncharted 8.5

AC 8.0

ME 8.5 to 9.0

Seams like a fair look at each.

Tie between ME and Uncharted. Their is only so much u can do in one city in AC.

caseypayne69

This isnt a fair look at each, youare very uneducated about both ME and AC. I cant stand it when people make threads in their ignorance.

Graphics

AC Similiar to Uncharted just not as pretty.

caseypayne69

Gameplay

Mass Effect Auto combat with select screen options, with the occasional gun control. Much of hte 50 to 70 hours will be spent talking to other NPC's. Actually gameplay time will be considerably shorter. Maybe 30 to 45 hours.caseypayne69

What was the last BioWare game you played? That is probably exactly opposite to their st-yle.

I will juddge only between AC and Uncharted because didnt play ME yet.

I played the Uncharted demo and i already played about 3h of AC and i prefer the Uncharted gampelay.

lol... you know nothing of ME...wolverine4262

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...caseypayne69

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place.caseypayne69

How about you actually, you know...watch a gameplay video. Everything is in real time.

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...caseypayne69

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...caseypayne69

I know it uses Recyled environments.LINK? Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up.LINK? Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that.Opinion and meaningless in this context. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR.Its Not. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take placeShows how much you know. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...caseypayne69

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

The combat gameplay in Mass Effect is third person tactical, not turn-based. If you are to do a thread bashing a game, please research the game before you do so.

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...caseypayne69

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

Length

Uncharted 15 hours long

AC 40 hours long

ME 50 to 70 hours long

ME wins for bang for the buck in game time.

The you progress through the missions

Uncharted Linear always moving on to a new place (so it seams their is no back tracking)

AC all your objectives are in the same sandbox map. Think of it as GTA without the guns and doing missions just chasing people

ME Linear like Uncharted with probably revisiting locations aka Resident Evil like on a bigger scale. Back tracking events

Tie between ME and Uncharted. Their is only so much u can do in one city in AC.

Graphics

Uncharted Real time lighting etc etc with zero jaggies, great deal of people consider it the new graphics king. THe demo showed that u can walk ankle deep in water and have wet shoes, u can walk waist deep and have wet pants etc etc ur whole body is wet.

AC Similiar to Uncharted just not as pretty.

ME Recycled enviroments just like Oblivion (which is WHY IT CAN FIT on a DVD) If it weren't for the environment recycling it would of had a harder time fitting on DVD and keeping its quality.

Uncharted wins in Graphics because during ME high resolution moments they blur the background during conversations and etc showing the limits of the hardware being maxed on the characters. Uncharted keeps a blend of nice graphics on Character and backdrop at all times. On top of the cool water effects and lush environments.

Gameplay

Uncharted Camera angles like Gears and Resident Evil, running around like Tomb Raider, Shooting like Gears & RE. With some puzzle solving and hand to hand fighting.

AC not entirely sure some hand to hand combat with knifes etc. Lots of chasing down enemies while running on roof tops and streets. Could be similiar to Hitman.

Mass Effect Auto combat with select screen options, with the occasional gun control. Much of hte 50 to 70 hours will be spent talking to other NPC's. Actually gameplay time will be considerably shorter. Maybe 30 to 45 hours.

Uncharted wins due to more going on, and more control. GS will say"Identity issues."

Final GS predictions

Uncharted 8.5

AC 8.0

ME 8.5 to 9.0

Seams like a fair look at each.

caseypayne69

What a horrible comparison. It's quite apparent you know nothing about most of these games. Mass Effect has auto combat? The faces in Mass Effect show the 360's limitations because of blurring when the faces are 5 inches from the screen and are the main focus? Let alone that you see the faces in normal gameplay, even on planets with a 10 mile view. Mass Effect and Assassin's Creed linear? I guess you don't know about the countless hours of side quests and planets to explore in Mass Effect. I guess nobody also mentioned to you that you're free to travel about in Assassin's Creed, and take your time gathering intel until you're ready to go in for the kill.

I might as well have asked my mom what her comparison would be between the games.

[QUOTE="caseypayne69"]

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...killtactics

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

Yeah, seriously. I don't know how the guy can read.

Caseypayne69, put your hand 3 inches infront of your face. Notice anything? Everything else besides your hand blurs. This is because you're focus is on your hand, not the entire "scene" that your 90 degree area that your eyes can focus on. I'll also repeat myself: There are no special face models. During conversations, they don't replace the normal models with new ones. They zoom in. Why would the 360 lack the ability to render them then, but be capable of rendering them in 10 mile wide open areas?

No way in hell AC is 40 hours long.Legendaryscmt

Can anyone confirmed that AC is 40 hours long? I really hope it is.

[QUOTE="Legendaryscmt"]No way in hell AC is 40 hours long.lonsy02

Can anyone confirmed that AC is 40 hours long? I really hope it is.

If you do all the side quest.

Main Plot should only be 15-20 hours

[QUOTE="Legendaryscmt"]No way in hell AC is 40 hours long.lonsy02

Can anyone confirmed that AC is 40 hours long? I really hope it is.

Probably around 40 hours if you explore all three cities finding the most perfect way to take down your target.

mass effect wil obviously be the best

look at biowares history with star wars KOTOR, and jade empire

they create AAAmazing games

I don't know which will be the best, but I'm most excited for Mass Effect. Allof them look like they will be great games.

[QUOTE="killtactics"][QUOTE="caseypayne69"]

[QUOTE="wolverine4262"]lol... you know nothing of ME...Apathetic-Irony

I know it uses Recyled environments. Its backgrounds blur out during conversations, because thats the only way it could keep the detail up. Its a 50 to 70 hr game. KOTOR was boring half way through, I remember that. I'm seeling Oblivion and Keeping HS when I make my purchase for Uncharted. Since HS is 10 times cooler then Oblivion.

I know you want have full control of ur character if its anything like KOTOR. It will be more like walk forward hit a command and watch hte action take place. Where Uncharted and AC will give us more gameplay.

Yeah, seriously. I don't know how the guy can read.

Caseypayne69, put your hand 3 inches infront of your face. Notice anything? Everything else besides your hand blurs. This is because you're focus is on your hand, not the entire "scene" that your 90 degree area that your eyes can focus on. I'll also repeat myself: There are no special face models. During conversations, they don't replace the normal models with new ones. They zoom in. Why would the 360 lack the ability to render them then, but be capable of rendering them in 10 mile wide open areas?

Seriously why do people complain about this, this happens in movies too (for example in batman begins when the guy is in court and they ask if any1 from the wayne family is present or something like that). But arethey gonna tell me that or any movie that does that allhave bad quality.

mass effect wil obviously be the best

look at biowares history with star wars KOTOR, and jade empire

they create AAAmazing games

tidus222

-.- naming Jade Empire but not Neverwinter Nights & Baldurs Gates? (PC Version)? !!! blasphemy!

I'm starting to think the only reason people don't like Uncharted is because its on the PS3

Why does Mass Effect get alot of credit because its made by Bioware but Uncharted gets none and its made by Naughty Dog?

If my memory serves me right, both are good developers....so why is it one sided?

[QUOTE="caseypayne69"]

Length

Uncharted 15 hours long

AC 40 hours long

ME 50 to 70 hours long

ME wins for bang for the buck in game time.

The you progress through the missions

Uncharted Linear always moving on to a new place (so it seams their is no back tracking)

AC all your objectives are in the same sandbox map. Think of it as GTA without the guns and doing missions just chasing people

ME Linear like Uncharted with probably revisiting locations aka Resident Evil like on a bigger scale. Back tracking events

Tie between ME and Uncharted. Their is only so much u can do in one city in AC.

Graphics

Uncharted Real time lighting etc etc with zero jaggies, great deal of people consider it the new graphics king. THe demo showed that u can walk ankle deep in water and have wet shoes, u can walk waist deep and have wet pants etc etc ur whole body is wet.

AC Similiar to Uncharted just not as pretty.

ME Recycled enviroments just like Oblivion (which is WHY IT CAN FIT on a DVD) If it weren't for the environment recycling it would of had a harder time fitting on DVD and keeping its quality.

Uncharted wins in Graphics because during ME high resolution moments they blur the background during conversations and etc showing the limits of the hardware being maxed on the characters. Uncharted keeps a blend of nice graphics on Character and backdrop at all times. On top of the cool water effects and lush environments.

Gameplay

Uncharted Camera angles like Gears and Resident Evil, running around like Tomb Raider, Shooting like Gears & RE. With some puzzle solving and hand to hand fighting.

AC not entirely sure some hand to hand combat with knifes etc. Lots of chasing down enemies while running on roof tops and streets. Could be similiar to Hitman.

Mass Effect Auto combat with select screen options, with the occasional gun control. Much of hte 50 to 70 hours will be spent talking to other NPC's. Actually gameplay time will be considerably shorter. Maybe 30 to 45 hours.

Uncharted wins due to more going on, and more control. GS will say"Identity issues."

Final GS predictions

Uncharted 8.5

AC 8.0

ME 8.5 to 9.0

Seams like a fair look at each.

Apathetic-Irony

What a horrible comparison. It's quite apparent you know nothing about most of these games. Mass Effect has auto combat? The faces in Mass Effect show the 360's limitations because of blurring when the faces are 5 inches from the screen and are the main focus? Let alone that you see the faces in normal gameplay, even on planets with a 10 mile view. Mass Effect and Assassin's Creed linear? I guess you don't know about the countless hours of side quests and planets to explore in Mass Effect. I guess nobody also mentioned to you that you're free to travel about in Assassin's Creed, and take your time gathering intel until you're ready to go in for the kill.

I might as well have asked my mom what her comparison would be between the games.

Apparently you like others can't read. I said Uncharted was Linear, AC was sandbox style. And ME was a mix of the two with more options in travel. AC is Free to travel is sand box style just like I said, that you over looked.

You guys have selective reading.

Lets get the comparison more simple

Graphics

Uncharted > ME > AC

Gameplay

Uncharted = AC (but know one has played AC) > ME

High Definition sound

Uncharted 7.1 Uncompressed >>>> ME 5.1 compressed sound > AC 5.1

Do you really think A. Creed is going to end up taking 40 hours?Vandalvideo

If you do everything yes.

Uncharted is 10-15 with multi unlockable characters so they say. So 10-15 x how many people u can be.

ME > AC > UnchartedItalStallion777

second that. the tc talks as if uncharted is the best game to come out this year, but yet the hype is only AA? uncharted is going to be junk compared to me and will still be worse than ac.

I'm sorry, did he just use Audio as ownage? lol

I should've stopped reading when he said Mass Effect was linear. Or when he said that it uses recycled environments. Or when he said that the fact that it blurs backgrounds during conversation is a bad thing (it's called focus, Crysis does the same thing when you're changing the specs on your gun; OMG BAG GRAPHICS). Basically anyone who read the TC's thoughts is a little bit less intelligent, myself included.

I'm sorry, did he just use Audio as ownage? lol

I should've stopped reading when he said Mass Effect was linear. Or when he said that it uses recycled environments. Or when he said that the fact that it blurs backgrounds during conversation is a bad thing (it's called focus, Crysis does the same thing when you're changing the specs on your gun; OMG BAG GRAPHICS). Basically anyone who read the TC's thoughts is a little bit less intelligent, myself included.

LordMontezuma

dont worry about it. cows are just upset that sheep and lemmings both get at least one AAA this month, something the ps3 is not. as a result, they try to hype up their AA as much as possible, which eventually leads ot the inevitable 7.5

no offense but that uncharted sucked i played it and im glad its not on 360 "mass effect" all the way....

BTW mass effect should be way longer than 70 hours its like oblivion almost is'nt minus the horses and crap

[QUOTE="caseypayne69"]

Gameplay

Mass Effect Auto combat with select screen options, with the occasional gun control. Much of hte 50 to 70 hours will be spent talking to other NPC's. Actually gameplay time will be considerably shorter. Maybe 30 to 45 hours.Bansheesdie

What was the last BioWare game you played? That is probably exactly opposite to their st-yle.

KOTOR was totally auto combat.

No way in hell AC is 40 hours long.Legendaryscmt

Uncharted: 8.0

Assassin's Creed: 9.0

Mass Effect: 9.5

Write them down. I gurantee it.

[QUOTE="Legendaryscmt"]No way in hell AC is 40 hours long.VendettaRed07

its called the tc upped a few things on each game, then downsized ac and me in other places to make uncharted seem the best.

Assassins Creed 40 hours WTF?

ME 50-70 Hours WTF?

ME linear WTH?

that was terrrrrible