Uncharted VS Fable, which is more complex, varied and deep game ?

In Fable you can

- buy homes

- affect the economy

- get various jobs

- marry

- have kids

- own a citiy

- become king or mayor, own a castle

- have a treasury

- affect the world, by completly changing its look and areas

- explore for 1000+1 secrets

- gather weapons, armor, items, potions, collectibles

- play mini games

- talk to NPCs

- have NPC followers

- boast about your deeds in the public

- affect trading routes

- kill various enemies using magic, sword or bow

- dig for treasure

- solve real puzzles

- discover new optional areas

- grow the hero in different ways

- follow a good or evil path

- explore a huge open world, some areas are as big as all Unchartd 1-2-3 areas put together

- rent homes

- own shops

- furniture homes

- kill boss monsters

- do unique side quests

- do the main story quests

- take part in mini wars

- kill a huge variety of enemy types

- have a mini map with full representation of the world

- own a dog

- fish

- visit different realms

- adventure

- be a guild member

- use various skills you gather, passive or active

- cast magic

- upgrade weapons

etc etc

.

In Uncharted you can

- shoot enemies in a linear coriddor

- ?

Uncharted.

Is this a joke?

I guess Fable, but that's nothing to brag about.

Seeing how I haven't played Fable The Lost Chapters yet, I can't give out an opinion on this.

Though I can say this.

Uncharted 2 > Fable 2

Uncharted 3 > Fable 3

Heard Fable 1 was fantastic though.

Uncharted.

parkurtommo

Is this a joke?

I guess Fable, but that's nothing to brag about.

toast_burner

Why not ?

I hate simplistic shallow linear games

Seeing how I haven't played Fable The Lost Chapters yet, I can't give out an opinion on this.

Though I can say this.

Uncharted 2 > Fable 2

Uncharted 3 > Fable 3

Heard Fable 1 was fantastic though.

LegatoSkyheart

Seeing how I haven't played Fable The Lost Chapters yet, I can't give out an opinion on this.

Though I can say this.

Uncharted 2 > Fable 2

Uncharted 3 > Fable 3

Heard Fable 1 was fantastic though.

LegatoSkyheart

Some aspects, like the huge cities, huge open world, simulation, changing world etc are vastly better in Fable 2-3 than in Fable 1

Fable 2-3 are way more complex and deep in that regard

Fable 2 had trading routes, with traders wandering around the areas and also you could create an army of NPCs, had one of the best followers system ever

[QUOTE="parkurtommo"]

Uncharted.

delta3074

[QUOTE="parkurtommo"]

Uncharted.

delta3074

Well Fable obviously.

The cows have been owned once again.

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

Is this a joke?

I guess Fable, but that's nothing to brag about.

loosingENDS

Why not ?

I hate simplistic shallow linear games

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="parkurtommo"]

Uncharted.

BPoole96

Or because they genuingly are blinded PS3 fans

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

Is this a joke?

I guess Fable, but that's nothing to brag about.

loosingENDS

Why not ?

I hate simplistic shallow linear games

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

Is this a joke?

I guess Fable, but that's nothing to brag about.

toast_burner

Why not ?

I hate simplistic shallow linear games

Well, by the list i made above Fable is a 10.000.000.000.000 times less simple, linear and shallow game than Uncharted

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

Why not ?

I hate simplistic shallow linear games

loosingENDS

Well, by the list i made above Fable is a 10.000.000.000.000 times less simple, linear and shallow game than Uncharted

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

Seeing how I haven't played Fable The Lost Chapters yet, I can't give out an opinion on this.

Though I can say this.

Uncharted 2 > Fable 2

Uncharted 3 > Fable 3

Heard Fable 1 was fantastic though.

delta3074

Yeah I bought it when it was like $2.49 or something like that.

I haven't started Downloading yet. :P

Some aspects, like the huge cities, huge open world, simulation, changing world etc are vastly better in Fable 2-3 than in Fable 1

Fable 2-3 are way more complex and deep in that regard

Fable 2 had trading routes, with traders wandering around the areas and also you could create an army of NPCs, had one of the best followers system ever

loosingENDS

In this regard, since I have played Fable 2 and 3 on the 360.

Fable 2 > Fable 3.

Though I've heard Fable The Lost Chapters is Vastly Superior than Fable 2.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="parkurtommo"]

Uncharted.

parkurtommo

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]Both games are simple, linear and shallow. One is just more simple and linear than the other.

toast_burner

Well, by the list i made above Fable is a 10.000.000.000.000 times less simple, linear and shallow game than Uncharted

No, actually if you had ever played the game you would know every single thing of those is in them

But obviously you have not

So, which are the "outright lies" ? LOL

Uncharted, but neither one has what you would call deep or varied gameplay.

[QUOTE="parkurtommo"][QUOTE="delta3074"]you fanboys make yourselves so obvious, it's pretty clear that fable is more complex (differnt quests,character developement, different weapons ,different armour and NPC's who react to your behaviour) more varied (not just shoot people and fetch things and it's a sanbox game) and deeper (theres no character development or RPG elements in uncharted) to sy otherwise is just stupid really, not a fair comparison but what can you do,loldelta3074

Fable has little to no variation in the story, you can choose to kill a character or do something evil every now and again but it does nothing to change the overall story :?soulitane

Pretty sure you get different endings based on what you do.

[QUOTE="BPoole96"][QUOTE="delta3074"]you fanboys make yourselves so obvious, it's pretty clear that fable is more complex (differnt quests,character developement, different weapons ,different armour and NPC's who react to your behaviour) more varied (not just shoot people and fetch things and it's a sanbox game) and deeper (theres no character development or RPG elements in uncharted) to sy otherwise is just stupid really, not a fair comparison but what can you do,lolloosingENDS

Or because they genuingly are blinded PS3 fans

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

Well, by the list i made above Fable is a 10.000.000.000.000 times less simple, linear and shallow game than Uncharted

loosingENDS

No, actually if you had ever played the game you would know every single thing of those is in them

But obviously you have not

So, which are the "outright lies" ? LOL

"explore a huge open world, some areas are as big as all Uncharted 1-2-3 areas put together" The map of the fable games is very small and very linear, if you put every level of Uncharted 2 together it would probably be larger than any of the fable games.

"affect trading routes" Granted I haven't played Fable 3 but this is a complete lie if you're referring to the first 2 games, the traders are just NPCs that spawn at set locations and walk a set path, they don't actually have any kind of economy or anything.

[QUOTE="soulitane"]Fable has little to no variation in the story, you can choose to kill a character or do something evil every now and again but it does nothing to change the overall story :?waltefmoney

Pretty sure you get different endings based on what you do.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="parkurtommo"]

Uncharted.

parkurtommo

If I remember correctly, it all came down to a single choice, which gave you some bonus but hardly changes the overall story. If the choices were actually complex then the whole game would be based upon them rather than you pretty much having to be good, you could choose to side with evil. In the end all the choices are just something that moves a slider across pretty much.soulitane

In Fable 1 people were scared of you if you were evil and cheered for you if you were good.

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]The list was full of exageration and outright lies.

toast_burner

No, actually if you had ever played the game you would know every single thing of those is in them

But obviously you have not

So, which are the "outright lies" ? LOL

"explore a huge open world, some areas are as big as all Uncharted 1-2-3 areas put together" The map of the fable games is very small and very linear, if you put every level of Uncharted 2 together it would probably be larger than any of the fable games.

"affect trading routes" Granted I haven't played Fable 3 but this is a complete lie if you're referring to the first 2 games, the traders are just NPCs that spawn at set locations and walk a set path, they don't actually have any kind of economy or anything.

Actually the areas in Fable are huge, Uncharted is mainly taking place in coriddors and tiny hubs

Fable is mainly taking place in huge open hubs

The difference in walkable area size is devastating, i am sure all Uncharted 1-2-3 walkable areas are smaller than the biggest Fable hub

Also the traders can be killed, so you can affect the trading routes, how is another matter

So, no lies there

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="delta3074"]yeah, because clearly you can interact with the other characters in uncharted and they respond to the way you behave towrds them and clearly Uncharted has chracter development and RPG elements, it's also clear that Unchrted is a sanbox game with a storyline that varies completely depending on the COMPLEX choices you make *sarcasm*delta3074

[QUOTE="soulitane"]If I remember correctly, it all came down to a single choice, which gave you some bonus but hardly changes the overall story. If the choices were actually complex then the whole game would be based upon them rather than you pretty much having to be good, you could choose to side with evil. In the end all the choices are just something that moves a slider across pretty much.waltefmoney

In Fable 1 people were scared of you if you were evil and cheered for you if you were good.

The first two Fables I would give it to, but after that, neither of them are that complex or varied, and certainly isn't deep. imo. Now on the other hand, Uncharted doesn't need complexity for it to be enjoyable so I say Uncharted wins!

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

No, actually if you had ever played the game you would know every single thing of those is in them

But obviously you have not

So, which are the "outright lies" ? LOL

loosingENDS

"explore a huge open world, some areas are as big as all Uncharted 1-2-3 areas put together" The map of the fable games is very small and very linear, if you put every level of Uncharted 2 together it would probably be larger than any of the fable games.

"affect trading routes" Granted I haven't played Fable 3 but this is a complete lie if you're referring to the first 2 games, the traders are just NPCs that spawn at set locations and walk a set path, they don't actually have any kind of economy or anything.

Actually the areas in Fable are huge, Uncharted is mainly taking place in coriddors and tiny hubs

Fable is mainly taking place in huge open hubs

The difference in walkable area size is devastating, i am sure all Uncharted 1-2-3 walkable areas are smaller than the biggest Fable hub

Also the traders can be killed, so you can affect the trading routes, how is another matter

So, no lies there

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="soulitane"]If I remember correctly, it all came down to a single choice, which gave you some bonus but hardly changes the overall story. If the choices were actually complex then the whole game would be based upon them rather than you pretty much having to be good, you could choose to side with evil. In the end all the choices are just something that moves a slider across pretty much.soulitane

In Fable 1 people were scared of you if you were evil and cheered for you if you were good.

Fable 1 was a great game though.

I was always good anyway.

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

In Fable 1 people were scared of you if you were evil and cheered for you if you were good.

waltefmoney

Fable 1 was a great game though.

I was always good anyway.

I agree, one of my favourite games, just they didn't give any reason to be bad. I was always good as well, the sounds of the villages running away always annoyed me.soulitane

I like how when they're carrying firewood and you come nearby they just drop it and start clapping.

YOu can do more in Fable because it is an RPG. But, Uncharted is the better franchise.

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

[QUOTE="loosingENDS"]

No, actually if you had ever played the game you would know every single thing of those is in them

But obviously you have not

So, which are the "outright lies" ? LOL

loosingENDS

"explore a huge open world, some areas are as big as all Uncharted 1-2-3 areas put together" The map of the fable games is very small and very linear, if you put every level of Uncharted 2 together it would probably be larger than any of the fable games.

"affect trading routes" Granted I haven't played Fable 3 but this is a complete lie if you're referring to the first 2 games, the traders are just NPCs that spawn at set locations and walk a set path, they don't actually have any kind of economy or anything.

Actually the areas in Fable are huge, Uncharted is mainly taking place in coriddors and tiny hubs

Fable is mainly taking place in huge open hubs

The difference in walkable area size is devastating, i am sure all Uncharted 1-2-3 walkable areas are smaller than the biggest Fable hub

Also the traders can be killed, so you can affect the trading routes, how is another matter

So, no lies there

Killing traders isn't the same as affecting trade routes, the traders don't supply the shops, their stock just automatically replenishes out of nowhere after a set time. Yes you can kill traders, but thats no different to killing any other NPC in the game.

Why compare two dissimilar games?

I might as well compare them with Flight Simulator X which a heck of a lot more complex than any of those games.

[QUOTE="soulitane"]I agree, one of my favourite games, just they didn't give any reason to be bad. I was always good as well, the sounds of the villages running away always annoyed me.waltefmoney

I like how when they're carrying firewood and you come nearby they just drop it and start clapping.

Wait,you're comparing an RPG and an action-adventure/TPS? :?

You do realize those two are entirely different genres? :?

But since this is a Loosey's thread,I'll go with Uncharted.Never enjoyed Fable,way too simplistic for my taste...

In Fable you can:

Do fetch quests and talk to hoes.

In Uncharted you can:

Use a grenade launcher

Use an AK 47

Use a pistol thing

Use a handgun thing

Use another handgun thing

Use an RPG

Run

Walk

Roll

Jump

Dance like a sex pervert after killing someone online

kill someone online

cpture a flag on line

carry treasure online

discover treasure offline

throw a grenade

shoot strong enemies

shoot weak enemies

try to shoot allies which in turn makes them walk to the side (very good AI)

talk to peaople in cutscenes

watch cutscenes

do puzzles

carry littled gas things that explode upon shooting them

customize your character's appearance (character skin store)

level up on line

do quests

go to mountains

go in mountains

fight yetis

fight blue yetis

fight many blue yetis

AND THAT'S JUST UNCHARTED 2

Uncharted is the better game

Fable also has better art than Unfarted, Steve Jobs am cry.