Uncharted vs. Mass Effect

Two completely different types of games. And both good in their own way.PS3Compass

Yup.

[QUOTE="PS3Compass"]Two completely different types of games. And both good in their own way.BioShockOwnz

Yup.

Ok then, graphically?

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="PS3Compass"]Two completely different types of games. And both good in their own way.--JpR--

Yup.

Ok then, graphically?

Uncharted wins in that department. :)

Have not played uncharted, but I know for a fact Mass Effect offers more, and is not linear.

i prefer mass effect because, well, i prefer RPGs to shooters. ask me which i prefer, crysis or witcher and its witcher for me every time....because i prefer RPGs and witcher is a great RPG.

graphically uncharted takes the title though. mass effect suffers from too many graphical probs to make a proper comparison. i prefer the character models in ME mind (when the textures do decide to kick in....why use the UE3 engine bioware?), but overall uncharted is a better looking game imho.

ive only played the uncharted demo though so if there are graphical probs with the full game then....no idea :S.

Gameplay - Apples to oranges, but I would probably take Mass Effect, it combines two great tastes, WRPG and TPS, and they taste great together.

Graphics - Uncharted, but ME has a great art style and a serious sense of atmosphere. Most of the character models are well done, though some are far better than others. Some have facial movements and lip synching that is fluid and perfect, while others look like poorly constructed animatronic puppets.

Value - Well this is where ME will kill Uncharted for me. I'm already 8 hours in to ME and I feel like I'm only scratching the surface. Even if Uncharted is decent length for an action game, a single play-through of ME is likely to go much longer than multiple play-through of Uncharted.

Mass effect is a bad bad game. I feel so dumb for wasting $60 on it, it is beyond boring, the combat is lame, all you do it watch people talk and talk and talk, and don't even get me started on the glitches (texture pop ins, constant loading, and horrible frame rate) sometimes I wonder if the 360 was the right choice for mass effect to be on. Also get used to watching your character ride in an elevator, you are gonna see it ALOT. catlin_czirr

[QUOTE="catlin_czirr"]Mass effect is a bad bad game. I feel so dumb for wasting $60 on it, it is beyond boring, the combat is lame, all you do it watch people talk and talk and talk, and don't even get me started on the glitches (texture pop ins, constant loading, and horrible frame rate) sometimes I wonder if the 360 was the right choice for mass effect to be on. Also get used to watching your character ride in an elevator, you are gonna see it ALOT. ICollegeStudent

Graphically its a toss up. Uncharted has the better technical graphics, but I really enjoyed Mass Effect's art style. PBSnipes

Graphically its a toss up. Uncharted has the better technical graphics, but I really enjoyed Mass Effect's art style. PBSnipes

Mass Effect, best RPG I ever played. Blew awayevery JRPGs I played up to now. dkhw

[QUOTE="dkhw"]Mass Effect, best RPG I ever played. Blew awayevery JRPGs I played up to now. catlin_czirr

[QUOTE="ICollegeStudent"][QUOTE="catlin_czirr"]Mass effect is a bad bad game. I feel so dumb for wasting $60 on it, it is beyond boring, the combat is lame, all you do it watch people talk and talk and talk, and don't even get me started on the glitches (texture pop ins, constant loading, and horrible frame rate) sometimes I wonder if the 360 was the right choice for mass effect to be on. Also get used to watching your character ride in an elevator, you are gonna see it ALOT. catlin_czirr

Two completely different types of games.PS3Compass

[QUOTE="ICollegeStudent"][QUOTE="catlin_czirr"]Mass effect is a bad bad game. I feel so dumb for wasting $60 on it, it is beyond boring, the combat is lame, all you do it watch people talk and talk and talk, and don't even get me started on the glitches (texture pop ins, constant loading, and horrible frame rate) sometimes I wonder if the 360 was the right choice for mass effect to be on. Also get used to watching your character ride in an elevator, you are gonna see it ALOT. catlin_czirr

You probably don't like RPGS in general.

Ive only played uncharted and saw my friend play Mass effect and graphic wise uncharted wins. Its a very very beautiful game. Mass effect though does look really good for an RPG and its the only game i want off of the 360. But uncharted is an amazing game overall and i experienced almost 0 problems with the game.

[QUOTE="catlin_czirr"]Well excuse me for having an opinion, and GASP not liking Mass Effect, i know it's shocking! :roll:jangojay

You probably don't like RPGS in general.

[QUOTE="--JpR--"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="PS3Compass"]Two completely different types of games. And both good in their own way.PS3Compass

Yup.

Ok then, graphically?

Uncharted wins in that department. :)

Easily, Someone looking at screenshots may think there close but when played in motion Mass Effect actually isnt nearly as impressive due to framerate problems and texture pop in. Uncharted runs much smoother and the animations are some of the best in any game to date. Both are good looking games and are very fun.( Each are among my favorite on each console. But Uncharted is a better looking game.

[QUOTE="--JpR--"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="PS3Compass"]Two completely different types of games. And both good in their own way.PS3Compass

Yup.

Ok then, graphically?

Uncharted wins in that department. :)

agree but not by that much...i didnt like the graphic style of ME

[QUOTE="jangojay"]

[QUOTE="catlin_czirr"]Well excuse me for having an opinion, and GASP not liking Mass Effect, i know it's shocking! :roll:OfficialJab

You probably don't like RPGS in general.

Story and character development are the main draws for RPGS. Mass Effect excells at both but has some gameplay/framerate issues. If he really thinks that those things make the game horrible then he obviously doesn't appreciate RPGS for what they are.

Graphically, Uncharted. The game is flat out gorgeous.

Overall though the nod still goes to Mass Effect. Uncharted is pretty short (I'm about 3 hrs in and my save file says I'm 55% done) and Mass Effect is a heck of a lot less linear, meaning there are several different gaming experiences to be had here. Plus, I'm a sucker for a good WRPG and Mass Effect is far better than just "good" so I'm hooked.

Mass Effect looks like a bit boring IMO, space RPG, i'm sorry but they should've paid for Star Ocean 4, you can't make better space RPG's than SO :)...Mass effect - is ok

Uncharted - 2 thumbs up, just too freaking good