What do you think looks more interesting, Alan Wake or Heavy Rain?

We have Alan Wake. See the trailer

And then there's Heavy Rain. See the trailer

What one are you more interested in?

Alan Wake, by far.

Alan Wake based on the fact that I really don't want to play an interactive cutscene with glorified quick time events.

Quick time events are not good.

Both for me I can't wait to get my hands on them.

as a owner of both the 360 and ps3, I would say Alan Wake. I'm just not feeling the heavy rain hype.

edit: but if the pc version of alan wake is still coming out, I will get that version

definitely alan wake.

alan wake

Both, my fear from the what I've seen of alan wake is that it will be a glorified tps.

Am I the only person who'd take Heavy Rain over Alan Wake? >.>

heavy rain- intrigue

alan wake - suspense

Alan Wake for me, I'm not sure if I'll enjoy the gameplay of HR.

Alan Wake by a long shot.

They both seem pretty interesting but Heavy rain looks like CSI'ish and i likes me some CSI lol

Honestly? Without putting on me lemming mask? Both. Both look equally awesome.

heavy rain, but i dont have a ps3 so ill have to deal with my rental of alan wake when it comes out

Honestly? Without putting on me lemming mask? Both. Both look equally awesome.

BioShockOwnz

Alan Wake (360)for me

Although I might buy Heavy Rain (PS3) as well depending on how much money I have left.

Alan Wake, but my expectations are low. The E3 demo looked really boring, the action was a large step down from Max Payne, and unless the story is really great I'll probably skip it. But Heavy Rain looks worse, made by the makers of Indigo Prophecy.

alan wake 100%

the action was a large step down from Max Paynedarkmoney52

Honestly? Without putting on me lemming mask? Both. Both look equally awesome.

BioShockOwnz

Alan Wake, but my expectations are low. The E3 demo looked really boring, the action was a large step down from Max Payne, and unless the story is really great I'll probably skip it. But Heavy Rain looks worse, made by the makers of Indigo Prophecy.

darkmoney52

Alan wake my most anticipated game for years now

alan wake looks more interesting to me and i really want it but heavy rain looks good too though and i loved indigo prophecy.

It was Heavy Rain for a while, now its Alan Wake.

I'm not sure, Alan wake looks like it has better gameplay by far, but i want to play them both.

[QUOTE="darkmoney52"] the action was a large step down from Max PayneCherokee_Jack

Honestly, my hype meter is pretty low on both anymore.

Alan Wake sounded great... over four years ago. Now that the PC version is in serious doubt, I'd have to rent a 360 for a run though, and I won't bother unless it looks to be a fantastic experience. From what we've seen recently, I'm startig to doubt that will be worth the effort.

My Heavy Rain Hype-O-Meter never got very high to start with... certainly not as high as Alan Wake did. My main interest in Heavy Rain was the deep story line. The gameplay news we've had has tempered what little enthusiasm I had for it. When it comes out I'll likely read more on it, and see what it's all about because atm we still don't know much. But I'm not expecting great things anymore.

Who knows? Both might still surprise me when they release. And I loooove surprises! You don't get many in the gaming world these days:lol:

[QUOTE="darkmoney52"]

Alan Wake, but my expectations are low. The E3 demo looked really boring, the action was a large step down from Max Payne, and unless the story is really great I'll probably skip it. But Heavy Rain looks worse, made by the makers of Indigo Prophecy.

hy4k

Agreed.

I have to go with Alan Wake, although I will play both games.

Heavy Rain, since I can get it.

Both the trailers are good and interesting. Alan Wake's trailer looks like a movie trailer. I would go see it if it was a real movie. Also, I feel that Alan Wake is in a little bit of an identity crisis. Is it a movie, mystery, action, or shooter game?

Alan Wake looks more playable to me. Still i think heavy Rain will be a great game aswell