What do you think madden will score?(Updated version with poll)

Only ps3 and 360 version

OFFICAL WEBSITE

http://www.easports.com/maddennfl/home.jsp

It got a 9/10 on teamxbox

http://reviews.teamxbox.com/xbox-360/1362/Madden-NFL-08/p1/

a 9/10 at gametrailers

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/23439.html

a 9/10 at 1up

http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3161871&sec=REVIEWS

a 9/10 at gamedaily

http://www.gamedaily.com/games/madden-nfl-08/xbox-360/game-reviews/item/5984/1712/

a 8.6/10 at sportsgamer

http://www.sportsgamer.com/games/madden/

a 5 star at yahoo

http://videogames.yahoo.com/xbox360/madden-nfl-08/reviews/

a 5 star at painstakinglydrafted world

http://painstakinglydrafted.wordpress.com/2007/08/11/madden-nfl-08-review/

a 9/10 at gametab

http://www.gametap.com/home/read/article/8a2509011445079b01144807a11e0fed

a 93% at game rankings

http://gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/938343.asp?q=madden%20nfl%2008

Will update later

got a 9/10 on team xboxHuxley_04

holy crap I think we have a winner this year:D

Sounds great... wondering how the wii version did now, before I make a purchae.kittykatz5k

they have been quit on the wii version....

doesnt look good...

What's taking GS so long to review it? Why are they ALWAYS the LAST one's to review a game?briguyb13

I could care less about what they have to say about the game,that video just confirmed my purchase.

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]Sounds great... wondering how the wii version did now, before I make a purchae.ginglejangle

they have been quit on the wii version....

doesnt look good...

Spesifically what about it doesn't look good? I havn't looked into madden soI'm a bit confused.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]Sounds great... wondering how the wii version did now, before I make a purchae.kittykatz5k

they have been quit on the wii version....

doesnt look good...

Spesifically what about it doesn't look good?

The fact that they haven't said a word about the Wii version and that they haven't released the Review copies yet..

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]Sounds great... wondering how the wii version did now, before I make a purchae.Huxley_04

they have been quit on the wii version....

doesnt look good...

Spesifically what about it doesn't look good?

The fact that they haven't said a word about the Wii version and that they haven't released the Review copies yet..

I'm not following this train of logic... the fact that they reviewed this version first makes the wii version bad?

[QUOTE="Huxley_04"]kittykatz5k

I'm not following this train of logic... the fact that they reviewed this version first makes the wii version bad?

If their keeping the game a secrte from us...it must not be to good.

I mean I havent even heard much about the wii version

EA found it this gen.....it only took the third try lol (third times a charm I guess). Madden is smooth and fun again this year.MikeE21286

yep,How would you rate it?

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="Huxley_04"]ginglejangle

I'm not following this train of logic... the fact that they reviewed this version first makes the wii version bad?

If their keeping the game a secrte from us...it must not be to good.

I mean I havent even heard much about the wii version

I didn't hear much about any version, that makes this game horrible, right? This game might be bad, but you're using reasoning that makes absoutly no sense.

I'm in the middle of my first game (my very first one got interrupted) SO far 9/10 would be my rating. The new weapons system is really good.MikeE21286

Thats good to hear,is the gameplay really like a chess match?

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="Huxley_04"]kittykatz5k

I'm not following this train of logic... the fact that they reviewed this version first makes the wii version bad?

If their keeping the game a secrte from us...it must not be to good.

I mean I havent even heard much about the wii version

I didn't hear much about any version, that makes this game horrible, right? This game might be bad, but you're using reasoning that makes absoutly no sense.

Ok let me rephrase this then.

If they havent been saying much about a game or hypying it alot before a game releases then there must be a reasonwhy they are not doing it....in most cases it will be bad.

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="Huxley_04"]ginglejangle

I'm not following this train of logic... the fact that they reviewed this version first makes the wii version bad?

If their keeping the game a secrte from us...it must not be to good.

I mean I havent even heard much about the wii version

I didn't hear much about any version, that makes this game horrible, right? This game might be bad, but you're using reasoning that makes absoutly no sense.

Ok let me rephrase this then.

If they havent been saying much about a game or hypying it alot before a game releases then there must be a reasonwhy they are not doing it....in most cases it will be bad.

You still havn't presented any facts as to why the game is bad. This is about as justified a claim as saying brawl won't have online because the devs didn't flat out spell it out in big bold words that it has online. You maybe right, and you probably are right, seeing as the videos I've seen on this look worse than their 07 version... but your train of logic is derailed into nothing but superstition.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

kittykatz5k

You still havn't presented any facts as to why the game is bad. This is about as justified a claim as saying brawl won't have online because the devs didn't flat out spell it out in big bold words that it has online. You maybe right, and you probably are right, seeing as the videos I've seen on this look worse than their 07 version... but your train of logic is derailed into nothing but superstition.

I never said the game will be bad.

but...no hype=bad game.

i still find the graphics dissapointing, looks like a xbox/ps2 game in higher res.ElectronX

not at all,I compared 07(360)to 07 for ps2.

and the ps2 version looked like grabge compared to it.

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

ginglejangle

You still havn't presented any facts as to why the game is bad. This is about as justified a claim as saying brawl won't have online because the devs didn't flat out spell it out in big bold words that it has online. You maybe right, and you probably are right, seeing as the videos I've seen on this look worse than their 07 version... but your train of logic is derailed into nothing but superstition.

I never said the game will be bad.

but...no hype=bad game.

Why am I getting the sudden urge to yell objection? Oh, right, cause you still havn't presented any evidence and you blatently contradicted yourself in your own post.

The last good sports game I played was Blitz 98'. I would really like to get into this on my 1080p 65" TV for my PS3, I'd get the 360 version, but there's a problem there, it's hooked up to my 480i. So I guess the PS3 version.wemhim

Call me crazy all you want, but I just got a madly sick idea! You take that console, ok.... then you hook it up to the 1080p tv!

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]I'm in the middle of my first game (my very first one got interrupted) SO far 9/10 would be my rating. The new weapons system is really good.ginglejangle

Thats good to hear,is the gameplay really like a chess match?

Not right now lol....I forgot it was only on pro..35-0 me. 2 picks to the house.

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]I'm in the middle of my first game (my very first one got interrupted) SO far 9/10 would be my rating. The new weapons system is really good.MikeE21286

Thats good to hear,is the gameplay really like a chess match?

Not right now lol....I forgot it was only on pro..35-0 me. 2 picks to the house.

so when you get on a harder diffuclutly.....its basicly a chess match before the snap?

[QUOTE="wemhim"]The last good sports game I played was Blitz 98'. I would really like to get into this on my 1080p 65" TV for my PS3, I'd get the 360 version, but there's a problem there, it's hooked up to my 480i. So I guess the PS3 version.kittykatz5k

Call me crazy all you want, but I just got a madly sick idea! You take that console, ok.... then you hook it up to the 1080p tv!

you dont know his situation....

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

kittykatz5k

You still havn't presented any facts as to why the game is bad. This is about as justified a claim as saying brawl won't have online because the devs didn't flat out spell it out in big bold words that it has online. You maybe right, and you probably are right, seeing as the videos I've seen on this look worse than their 07 version... but your train of logic is derailed into nothing but superstition.

I never said the game will be bad.

but...no hype=bad game.

Why am I getting the sudden urge to yell objection? Oh, right, cause you still havn't presented any evidence and you blatently contradicted yourself in your own post.

well look at the screens and the preivews.

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]I'm in the middle of my first game (my very first one got interrupted) SO far 9/10 would be my rating. The new weapons system is really good.ginglejangle

Thats good to hear,is the gameplay really like a chess match?

Not right now lol....I forgot it was only on pro..35-0 me. 2 picks to the house.

so when you get on a harder diffuclutly.....its basicly a chess match before the snap?

oh yeah, like if you have a smart safety on your team, you can read the other teams play and audible your D into the right situation (like a Darren Sharper) and if you have a smart qb (like Peyton) he can see the D's play and audible and what not, and then there's tons of audibles too.

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

I never said the game will be bad.

but...no hype=bad game.

ginglejangle

Why am I getting the sudden urge to yell objection? Oh, right, cause you still havn't presented any evidence and you blatently contradicted yourself in your own post.

well look at the screens and the preivews.

Nya-na... you're the one on offence here, that's your job if you want to insult it, to know what you're insulting it about..

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="MikeE21286"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]I'm in the middle of my first game (my very first one got interrupted) SO far 9/10 would be my rating. The new weapons system is really good.MikeE21286

Thats good to hear,is the gameplay really like a chess match?

Not right now lol....I forgot it was only on pro..35-0 me. 2 picks to the house.

so when you get on a harder diffuclutly.....its basicly a chess match before the snap?

oh yeah, like if you have a smart safety on your team, you can read the other teams play and audible your D into the right situation (like a Darren Sharper) and if you have a smart qb (like Peyton) he can see the D's play and audible and what not, and then there's tons of audibles too.

wow that sounds awesome I can't wait to get my hands on it.

[QUOTE="wemhim"]The last good sports game I played was Blitz 98'. I would really like to get into this on my 1080p 65" TV for my PS3, I'd get the 360 version, but there's a problem there, it's hooked up to my 480i. So I guess the PS3 version.kittykatz5k

Call me crazy all you want, but I just got a madly sick idea! You take that console, ok.... then you hook it up to the 1080p tv!

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"][QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

I never said the game will be bad.

but...no hype=bad game.

kittykatz5k

Why am I getting the sudden urge to yell objection? Oh, right, cause you still havn't presented any evidence and you blatently contradicted yourself in your own post.

well look at the screens and the preivews.

Nya-na... you're the one on offence here, that's your job if you want to insult it, to know what you're insulting it about..

well how come the 360 and ps3 version the only one with the hype?

cause....their the better version

look at the add...best football game ever....and then it has the 360 logo no wii logo

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]

[QUOTE="wemhim"]The last good sports game I played was Blitz 98'. I would really like to get into this on my 1080p 65" TV for my PS3, I'd get the 360 version, but there's a problem there, it's hooked up to my 480i. So I guess the PS3 version.wemhim

Call me crazy all you want, but I just got a madly sick idea! You take that console, ok.... then you hook it up to the 1080p tv!

I'd still take the extra 30 frames and cshaper look over the ps3 version, but your choice.

If the Wii version is similar or better than last year's version I'll be getting it for Wii. I'd like it to have graphics better than a PS2 port but the game play on the Wii version (of 07) blew all other console versions out of the water.cametall

it only scores 5 points higher and had extra time...looks like the 360 version will be the best this year

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

well look at the screens and the preivews.

ginglejangle

Nya-na... you're the one on offence here, that's your job if you want to insult it, to know what you're insulting it about..

well how come the 360 and ps3 version the only one with the hype?

cause....their the better version

look at the add...best football game ever....and then it has the 360 logo no wii logo

And I keep telling you present evidence. I've seen about equal hyper for the 360 as I have for the wii... and I remain pretty ontop of the gmaing news.

[QUOTE="wemhim"][QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]

[QUOTE="wemhim"]The last good sports game I played was Blitz 98'. I would really like to get into this on my 1080p 65" TV for my PS3, I'd get the 360 version, but there's a problem there, it's hooked up to my 480i. So I guess the PS3 version.kittykatz5k

Call me crazy all you want, but I just got a madly sick idea! You take that console, ok.... then you hook it up to the 1080p tv!

I'd still take the extra 30 frames and cshaper look over the ps3 version, but your choice.

Wow early reviews ... Madden is crap . Its the same thing as
last year . EA sucks . Bottom line only rednecks american
can buy this crap ... Well that sums up americans ( no
im not american )
iNeedFreedom

First of all, my cousin is the reddest neck I know... NO ONE on this board qualifies as a redneck. Second, what shame is there to being a redneck?

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"][QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]Sounds great... wondering how the wii version did now, before I make a purchae.Huxley_04

they have been quit on the wii version....

doesnt look good...

Spesifically what about it doesn't look good?

The fact that they haven't said a word about the Wii version and that they haven't released the Review copies yet..

What are you talking about, last week I think on On the Spot, Alex Navarro played Madden 08 on the Wii with Ryan Davis and he said they had just gotten their review copies a couple days before the show originally aired.

[QUOTE="iNeedFreedom"]Wow early reviews ... Madden is crap . Its the same thing as
last year . EA sucks . Bottom line only rednecks american
can buy this crap ... Well that sums up americans ( no
im not american )
kittykatz5k

First of all, my cousin is the reddest neck I know... NO ONE on this board qualifies as a redneck. Second, what shame is there to being a redneck?

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]

[QUOTE="iNeedFreedom"]Wow early reviews ... Madden is crap . Its the same thing as
last year . EA sucks . Bottom line only rednecks american
can buy this crap ... Well that sums up americans ( no
im not american )
iNeedFreedom

wtf is your problem...don't act like a dumba$$ just because you don't have the privelege of being an AMERICAN...and I can't believe you thinkMadden 2008is crap when it's already recieved great reviews. & no, not only rednecks buy this crap...thats like saying "only retards are members of gamespot.com"

[QUOTE="kittykatz5k"]

[QUOTE="iNeedFreedom"]Wow early reviews ... Madden is crap . Its the same thing as
last year . EA sucks . Bottom line only rednecks american
can buy this crap ... Well that sums up americans ( no
im not american )
iNeedFreedom

First of all, my cousin is the reddest neck I know... NO ONE on this board qualifies as a redneck. Second, what shame is there to being a redneck?

You said redneck and american like they were insults. I won't bring up that american comment, as it leads to discussions of almost epic levels of stupidity... but the red neck comment I stand by my own.

Wow early reviews ... Madden is crap . Its the same thing as
last year . EA sucks . Bottom line only rednecks american
can buy this crap ... Well that sums up americans ( no
im not american )
iNeedFreedom

go read the reviews....they have had this game for 3 weeks and love it.

ea embargoed any reviews under a 9minimozee

uh what?