What game(s) did you completely disagree with critics scores?

Im talking games that scored between a 5-6.5/7 that you thought were much better than what critics said. All platforms.

Not overrated games, im tired of GTA4 bashing

uncharted deserved a 9

Ratchet and Clank deserved a 8.5

Crackdown

Deus Ex

System Shock 2

Dark Sector

Mass Effect

I forgot what Kirby's air ride got, but it wasn't good.

I thought it was just as refreshing a take on the racing franchise as SSb was, the game just lacked polish.

I think crash bandicoot deserved more than a 6.8.

I haven't played too much of Silent hill origins, but i'm having so much fun with it, and i think a 6.5 is a bit too low.

EDIT: I forgot to mention MGS1 and Uncharted, aswell as Lost Odyssey.

-I think *gulp* Lair should have been a bit higher... the controls arent that bad people! It's the lack of mission directions!
-Also, I thought Ratchet and Clank for the PS3 should have been at least an 8.5. That was the biggest joke of a "review" I've ever read. No kidding.
-Dead Rising should have been a 9.0 also I believe

I think crash bandicoot deserved more than a 6.8. SSJ_Nega

Yeah for real man! I always thought that game was like a 9.0 on here or something, then I saw that score for it and I was like "WHAT?". Kinda crazy. The old Crash games are some of the best platformers of all time in my opinion. Heck, Crash stands out as my favorite game on the PS1. Too bad Naughty Dog doesnt have rights to it anymore... the new ones are sickening.

Guitar Hero: On Tour doesn't deserve a 6 just because the controls aren't as good as the console Guitar Heroes. It takes practice. PRACTICE people.

Oh, and 10 for SSBB.

Uncharted deserved a 9, No More Heroes deserved much less.

Too lazy to think of what else.

Deus Ex. God that was first review to piss me off.

gta4,mgs and cod4 over rated for sure!!!!blackdreamhunk

lulz

.

Gears of War should have been a 9, tops.

Blue Dragon. Easily an 8.

Of course thats just my opinion.

Mario Kart 64 .. it actually got a 6.4

maybe i loved it so much because i was young and didn't really have a clue about good games .. i thought Croc on PS was fun!

i can think of one that is worse...

Guitar Hero 3 !_! that game should of scored a 2, it was rubbish. they never should of let harmonics go.

Although to go on point with your topic, i would say Overlord got more slack then it deserved. it was a fantastic game.

Lost Odyssey got a 7.5 which should have gotten an 8.5 at least. I can overlook the technical issues and load times. It's probably the best 360 exclusive I've played so far and it's a really nice change of pace as far as 360 games go.

Audiosurf deserved at least a 9. I mean, you can ride your friggen music. Big music collection = infinite fun

Crash Bandicoot Wrath of Corex should have been 8, also all sly racoons have been at least 9.0

Ratchet and Clank should have at the very least gotten an 8.5-9.0, After playing it I really thought the reviewer here was an idiot especially with the "Too much variety" comment.

Uncharted deserved at least an 8.5

Dead Rising should have been scored slightly higher

and how Assassins Creed scored a 9.0 is mond boggling to me.... I would have given it an 8.0 at most.