What games really deserved AAAA status?

It seems to me that none of the games that score AAAA actually deserve it. So I was trying to think of any games all time that I think deserve a perfect 10.

This is what I came up with.


Mike Tyson's Punch Out

Baseball Stars

Super Mario Bros 3

The Legend of Zelda

Zelda: The Adventures of Link

The Legend of Zelda: A link to the past

Mario 64

Ocarina of Time

Final Fantasy 3(US)

Phantasy Star 2

Grand Theft Auto 3

Halo Combat Evolved

Knights of the Old Republic

Street Fighter 2

Metal Gear Solid


THIS GEN

The closest to AAAA that I have experienced this gen is the following games.

Oblivion

Red Dead Redemption
Bioshock

Having said that, I don't think any game this gen quite makes it to AAAA status. I haven't play SMG2 yet. I suspect that may be the only one but I won't know for sure until I try it myself.

there are those things called opinions

- Super Mario Galaxy 1,2

- Alan Wake

Oblivion

alexfla

...

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=27371827&tag=topics%3Btitle

there are those things called opinions

- Super Mario Galaxy 1,2

- Alan Wake

aia89

I have no problem with a game achieving a 10. It's known by know (surely) that a 10 on GS is not a *perfect* score.

I don't know of any other games that I would give a 10.

[QUOTE="alexfla"]

Oblivion

bad_fur_day

...

Thinking the same thing.

Mass Effect 2
Batman Arkham Asylum
Forza 3
Uncharted 2
GoW 3
Too Human

[spoiler] I am just joking about that last one :P [/spoiler]

We have a thread like this once every other day.

We have a thread like this once every other day.

Ragnarok1051

Oh. Lol. I guess mine wasn't all that orginial then either.

Alan Wake, Demon Soul, Fable 2, Lost Odyssey, Mass Effect

Older ones

Zelda OOT, WW, MM, FF7-8-9-10, All Sierra adventures, Heroes of M&M

[QUOTE="alexfla"]

Oblivion

bad_fur_day

...

It seems to me that none of the games that score AAAA actually deserve it. So I was trying to think of any games all time that I think deserve a perfect 10.

This is what I came up with.


Mike Tyson's Punch Out

Baseball Stars

Super Mario Bros 3

The Legend of Zelda

Zelda: The Adventures of Link

The Legend of Zelda: A link to the past

Mario 64

Ocarina of Time

Final Fantasy 3(US)

Phantasy Star 2

Grand Theft Auto 3

Halo Combat Evolved

Knights of the Old Republic

Street Fighter 2

Metal Gear Solid


THIS GEN

The closest to AAAA that I have experienced this gen is the following games.

Oblivion

Red Dead Redemption
Bioshock

Having said that, I don't think any game this gen quite makes it to AAAA status. I haven't play SMG2 yet. I suspect that may be the only one but I won't know for sure until I try it myself.

alexfla

From what i can think of right now, Halo 3, Mass Effects 1 and 2, and Bioshock.

Oblivion

alexfla

That too.

PC Dragon Age Origins was AAAA in my opinion.