What has more 8.5 GS rated games? PS3 or 360?

Just wondering.

Just wondering.

ProjectNatalFan

Just Search top rated under each console's library and you'll see.

Exactly 8.5?? lol what kind of question is that?? :lol:

Just Search top rated under each console's library and you'll see.

superapo

istn there a spreadsheet? i remember reading about it.

360 has more AA games rated 8.5 and up till 8.9. Around 50 vs 41. (counted)

[QUOTE="superapo"]

Just Search top rated under each console's library and you'll see.

ProjectNatalFan

istn there a spreadsheet? i remember reading about it.

I thought here on SW nobody cared about 8.5 games because nobody will buy them.player_leo

Only if they are fromWii games ;)

360 wins this battle, it has 6, PS3 has 4.

360 I believe. Depends on if you mean exclusive I think. I think 360 has access to more, the PS3 might have more 8.5 exclusives.

the PS3 might have more 8.5 exclusives.

MellowMighty

no idea, i would guess the ps3 thoughThePsTriple

And your guess would be wrong :shock:

well....let's take a look at the spreadsheet

360:

Alan Wake

Fable 2

Banjo Kazooie- Nuts and Bolts

Viva Piñata Trouble in paradise

Ace Combat 6

PGR 4

PS3:

Heavy Rain

Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack in Time

Valkyria Chronicles

Warhawk

8.5 console exclusives

XBOX 360:

-Alan Wake
-Toy Soldiers
-Shadow Complex
-Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts
-Portal: Still Alive
-Fable II
-Viva Pinata: Trouble in Paradise
-Tales of Vesperia
-Ikaruga
-Rez HD
-Mass Effect
-Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
-Project Gotham Racing 4
-Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
-Alien Hominid HD
-Rockstar Games presents Table Tennis

PS3:

-Heavy Rain
-Ratchet and Clank: A Crack in Time
-Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
-ZEN Pinball
-Valkyria Chronicles
-Warhawk
-MLB 08: The Show

I think I got them all. I just looked at the Top Games lists.

I dont know, but I do know the 360 has my favorite 8.5 rated game.

This seems like a rather random question. Now ask which console has the most 10s :o
:P

It matters because...?

I dont know, but I do know the 360 has my favorite 8.5 rated game.

Shirokishi_

It matters because...?

felipebo

you have to post this and why?

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

It matters because...?

ProjectNatalFan

you have to post this and why?

I could say the same to you and this thread, kind sir.

http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=0AriQpIFbPoEacGM1b0xxcGVucFQ3OFc4N3BNZmd2QkE&gid=1

Gamespot's current game spreadsheet.

Editor">[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

I dont know, but I do know the 360 has my favorite 8.5 rated game.

felipebo

That would be my second favorite.

The first, and my 2nd favorite game this gen is Alan Wake.

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

It matters because...?

felipebo

you have to post this and why?

I could say the same to you and this thread, kind sir.

well you could actually say nothing at all.

[QUOTE="felipebo"]Editor">[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

I dont know, but I do know the 360 has my favorite 8.5 rated game.

Shirokishi_

That would be my second favorite.

The first, and my 2nd favorite game this gen is Alan Wake.

IMO, best RPG on the 360. But which would be better than a JRPG where you're a morally ambiguous hero with a pet side-kick that can smoke?

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

you have to post this and why?

ProjectNatalFan

I could say the same to you and this thread, kind sir.

well you could actually say nothing at all.

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

I could say the same to you and this thread, kind sir.

felipebo

well you could actually say nothing at all.

ok now you try first.

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

[QUOTE="felipebo"] Tales Of Versperia?felipebo

That would be my second favorite.

The first, and my 2nd favorite game this gen is Alan Wake.

IMO, best RPG on the 360. But which would be better than a JRPG where you're a morally ambiguous hero with a pet side-kick that can smoke?

Definitely a kickass JRPG, best one this gen IMO...... thats been localized.

Tales of Graces is hands down the best JRPG Ive played this gen. Still Japan exclusive.

[QUOTE="felipebo"][QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

well you could actually say nothing at all.

ProjectNatalFan

ok now you try first.

OK, it's like this: You should only judge other's posts after you've judged your own.

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

That would be my second favorite.

The first, and my 2nd favorite game this gen is Alan Wake.

Shirokishi_

IMO, best RPG on the 360. But which would be better than a JRPG where you're a morally ambiguous hero with a pet side-kick that can smoke?

Definitely a kickass JRPG, best one this gen IMO...... thats been localized.

Tales of Graces is hands down the best JRPG Ive played this gen. Still Japan exclusive.

I dunno, I've heard about so many bugs and glitches that it kinda scared me away from it.

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

IMO, best RPG on the 360. But which would be better than a JRPG where you're a morally ambiguous hero with a pet side-kick that can smoke?

felipebo

Definitely a kickass JRPG, best one this gen IMO...... thats been localized.

Tales of Graces is hands down the best JRPG Ive played this gen. Still Japan exclusive.

I dunno, I've heard about so many bugs and glitches that it kinda scared me away from it.

Bamco released a revised, bug/glitchless version.

If localized, thats the version we'd get.

[QUOTE="felipebo"]

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

Definitely a kickass JRPG, best one this gen IMO...... thats been localized.

Tales of Graces is hands down the best JRPG Ive played this gen. Still Japan exclusive.

Shirokishi_

I dunno, I've heard about so many bugs and glitches that it kinda scared me away from it.

Bamco released a revised, bug/glitchless version.

If localized, thats the version we'd get.

After Vesperia, I have my doubts. It's like Namco is afraid of money and recognition.

Oh look what we have here lol.