What score on GS have you disagreed with the most?

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome.  Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

Tony Hawk 3

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome.  Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

helium_flash

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

[QUOTE="helium_flash"]

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome. Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

-Sora

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

Every xbox and 360 AAA, they're all overrated.

But on a more serious note: THPS3.  

Deus Ex. No 10.0? Blasphemy!

Other notable ones are MGS1 and 3, Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles, Xenosaga 3, and Mario Kart 64.

[QUOTE="-Sora"][QUOTE="helium_flash"]

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome. Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

mjarantilla

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

Well on GS thats how it works

[QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="-Sora"][QUOTE="helium_flash"]

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome. Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

-Sora

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

Well on GS thats how it works

Well I was about 11 when this game was released, but I seriously didn't like the review for The Legend of Dragoon.

6.4 gamespot review.  

[QUOTE="helium_flash"]

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome. Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

-Sora

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

Gameplay - 10

Graphics - 9

Sound - 8

Value - 9

Tilt - 10

I wrote a review on it if you want to see it. 

Twilight Princess is the most recent 1 for me...

but then again i cant really think of any old 1's either :S

[QUOTE="-Sora"][QUOTE="helium_flash"]

I personally thought that The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess on the Cube should have gotten a 9.5. That game was awesome. Instead GS gave it an 8.9

What reviews have you disagreed with the most?

helium_flash

9.5? what are you giving it in each catogorey?

Gameplay - 10

Graphics - 9

Sound - 8

Value - 9

Tilt - 10

I wrote a review on it if you want to see it. 

Yea good review

For a game that literally millions of people LOVED,

GameSpot's 6.4 for Mario Kart 64 seems a little ridiculous.

Every xbox and 360 AAA, they're all overrated.

Vyse_The_Daring

:lol:   .....Fanboy :|

MGS1 and 3 should have got a better score, especially 1 that game was a masterpiece, an instant classic and it didn´t even get AAA.Eddie-Vedder

Agreed,  I actually thought MGS2 was overrated though, thought it was deserved high AA while 1 and 3 deserved AAA :D

Twilight Princess is the most recent 1 for me...

but then again i cant really think of any old 1's either :S

dreamachine

update:  THPS3 and chrono cross seemed stupidly high. THPS3 didnt deserve a 10 imo and CC was nowhere near good enough as chrono trigger (which in my mind means that if cross scored 10, then trigger deserves 11 :S)

mario kart 64 deserved more than what it got n all as did double dash

GTA San Andreas.

twilight princess got the score it deserved

Legend of freaking Dragoon. 

Yep, Twilight Princess, especially on the Wii.mjarantilla

same. 

Shenmue 2 for Xbox.

Got a 7.SOMETHING, I believe.

Happens to be my favorite game of last Gen. (although Halo 1 and Jade Empire are close).

Okay, maybe all three tied.

Age of Empires. Great game for it's time, really, but they underrated.:(

Twilight Princess, should have got 9.2(Wii)

Gameplay-10

Graphics-9

Sound-9

Value-8

Tilt-10

The wiimote use i thought was very good, i didnt want to go back to the GC controller

For a game that literally millions of people LOVED,

GameSpot's 6.4 for Mario Kart 64 seems a little ridiculous.

 

CelineDion

In all seriousness...this is completely true!  The game was vastly underrated.  Should've been in the 8s.

Had a loooong post written up, hit the *&$##&&#&##&&#ing punkass Back button on my laptop and lost it all. UGH.

Anyway...

Midnight Club II for PS2. I was obsessed with the game and thought it deserved at least a AA. Jeff G-Man gave it a 7.2 or something and I hated him for it :P In the end though, I agreed with him. 

TimeSplitters: Future Perfect was another one. I had so much fun playing that game it should have been against the law. It should have also been against the law to give it an 8.2 or whatever it got. Loved that game.

This gen, definitely Resistance. 8.6 is a great score, sure, but it deserves at least a 9.0. PDZ got a 9.0 and its nothing special. 

GS RFOM score 8.6, user score 8.7, average critic score 8.8. 

GS PDZ score 9.0, user score 8.5, average critic score 8.1.

"One of theeese things just doesn't beloong..." 

Resistance doesn't seem like anything particularly special when you first crack it open, but when you play through the whole campaign once or twice, then get into the online, you realize its a fantastic game. Should have really gotten AAA. 

Age of Empires. Great game for it's time, really, but they underrated.:(

Kev_Unreal

Wow.  I used to play the demo for that game wheni was younger and liked it a lot.  I would say low 8.  AoE2, well, that's different.  I would give that AAA definitely. 

RFOM deserved AAA, I mean if PDZ got 9.0 Resistance definitely deserved at least the same score.