What will score higher??? Uncharted or ODST

which one do you think will recieve a higher score from Gamespot.

8.5 to be exactMeowmixxvi

It depends if the reviewers prefer a game that pushes technology in video games to a new level or if they would rather play a two year old engine which was dated at its release.

It depends if the reviewers prefer a game that pushes technology in video games to a new level or if they would rather play a two year old engine which was dated at its release.

LiquidShnake

im guessing the same. 8.5 to be exactMeowmixxvi

I think Uncharted 2 will get a 9.0 or higher and ODST will get no higher than 8.5.

9.5-10 for U2

8-8.5 for Halo.

Almost certainly Uncharted. Not to take anything away from U2 because it certainly looks like a solid game (and could very well be a better game than ODST) but it just reeks of runaway hype-train at this point, whereas ODST is going to have to deal with the expansion debacle plus the inevitable Halo backlash.

• Uncharted - 9.5
• Halo 3 ODST - 7.0

Almost certainly Uncharted. Not to take anything away from U2 because it certainly looks like a solid game (and could very well be a better game than ODST) but it just reeks of runaway hype-train at this point, whereas ODST is going to have to deal with the expansion debacle plus the inevitable Halo backlash.

PBSnipes

• Uncharted - 9.5
• Halo 3 ODST - 7.0

Nike_Air

^This.

9.5 uncharted, 8.5 odst

I will stick with Uncharted 9.0 I think ODST will get a 7.5-8.0.

without a doubt Uncharted 2.

odst will be only be ok...

Uncharted2 will probably be AAA. I think Halo ODST will be AA at best

Definately Uncharted. You can argue that both games are more of the same, but Unrchartedseems like more of the sequa, compared to ODST that seems like more of an expansion.

I'm picking up ODST first day, but I wouldn't be surprised if Uncharted scores higher. :P

It depends if the reviewers prefer a game that pushes technology in video games to a new level or if they would rather play a two year old engine which was dated at its release.

LiquidShnake

tell us how you really feel :P

U2> Expansion...

U2> Expansion...

ps3wizard45

[QUOTE="ps3wizard45"]

U2> Expansion...

Jandurin

New enemies, new allies, new moves, new story, new features. Pretty much new everything.

Halo ODST has VERY few new enemies. Almost every enemy is a repeat from Halo 3. Almost every gun is a repeat from Halo 3. The vehicles are the same. The engine is the same.

Uncharted 2: 9-9.5
ODST: 8.5-9

Uncharted 2 weak multiplayer great single player and ODST great online perhaps decent singleplayer.

Uncharted 2 weak multiplayer great single player and ODST great online perhaps decent singleplayer.

sexy_robot_man

New enemies, new allies, new moves, new story, new features. Pretty much new everything.

Halo ODST has VERY few new enemies. Almost every enemy is a repeat from Halo 3. Almost every gun is a repeat from Halo 3. The vehicles are the same. The engine is the same.

trakem

New enemies -- Unless I'm mistaken, Uncharted 2 will be filled with the likes of "nameless enemy #13" and "bad guy in red shirt #52". Sure there will be a couple of main villains, but you're comparing apples to oranges in that regard.

New allies -- As far as I know, there isn't a single character in ODST that's in the other Halo games.

New moves -- Do you really think Uncharted 2 is going to be light-years ahead of the original? Sure there'll be some tweaks and additions, but I highly doubt there'll be anything revolutionary.

New story -- Funny, I don't remember playing as a team of ODSTs in New Mombasa before in Halo.

New features -- ODST visor, silenced SMG, old-is-new-again pistol, Firefight, new MP maps.

Maybe I've missed something (and there's a good chance I have), but you're either reading too much into the old "expansion" tag that was on ODST, or you're grossly overestimating Uncharted 2. Either way, they both pale in comparison to standalone PC expansions like Crysis Warhead, Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts and Dawn of War: Dark Crusade.

[QUOTE="Jandurin"][QUOTE="ps3wizard45"]

U2> Expansion...

trakem

New enemies, new allies, new moves, new story, new features. Pretty much new everything.

Halo ODST has VERY few new enemies. Almost every enemy is a repeat from Halo 3. Almost every gun is a repeat from Halo 3. The vehicles are the same. The engine is the same.

Except U2's GAMEPLAY will be exactly the same as UC1. Whereas ODSTs GAMEPLAY will be totelly different to Halo 3's.

And gamplay is bigger than all that superficial stuff.

or you're grossly overestimating Uncharted 2PBSnipes

[QUOTE="Meowmixxvi"] 8.5 to be exactJandurin

:lol: . OMG Let's see:

• AAA vs AA
• Full game vs Expasion
• Graphics King graphics vs H3 graphics
• 12h+ SP vs 5h SP
• etc...need I go on?

Uncharted 2 will be taking Big ****s on Halo 3 ODST. PERIOD.

:)

Surely Uncharted !!!!

ODST will sell more, but i think UC2 will get better reviews.bizzy420

i think everyone here can agree on that :P

Uncharted. I admit to not knowing much about ODST though.

Uncharted 2: 9.5

Halo 3 ODST: 8.5