What would happen if GS scores God of War 2 like Twilight Princess?

Would you revolt and lash out if God of War 2 gets under 9.0?

A few things to keep in mind. The developers said that they did nothing new to GoW's formula. So it's basically like a continuation of the first one but with more intensity. Kind of like Twilight Princess....nothing new, just more intensity.

Just wondering since I know a lot of Nintendo-fans got furious over Twilight's score and Sony-fans over Virtua Fighter 5.

Well?

They wouldnt show there faces in public.

I'll do what I did with TP--Just ignore the review and buy it anyway. 

Seriously, when 95% of the game critics out there give the game a 9.5-10, and then GS gives it lower than a 9, I start to trust GS's reviews less.
  Rockclmbr6

QFT

It is getting utterly annoying about the Sony bias comments, just because they didn't give your PS3 games a 9 yet, get over it.

As for PS2, you had alot of them, so yeah, they're bias alright :roll:

GOW2 will probably get 9.1-9.3

they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360double-r

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Willy105

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

[QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 36088Ghost89

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

[QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Riviera_Phantom

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

But, you could easily turn off the speaker in the remote. Why penalise the Wii version for an optional feature...

Looks unprofessional to me.

I'll do what I did with TP--Just ignore the review and buy it anyway. 

Seriously, when 95% of the game critics out there give the game a 9.5-10, and then GS gives it lower than a 9, I start to trust GS's reviews less.
  Rockclmbr6

Agree 100%

[QUOTE="Riviera_Phantom"][QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 36088Ghost89

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

But, you could easily turn off the speaker in the remote. Why penalise the Wii version for an optional feature...

Looks unprofessional to me.

[QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Riviera_Phantom

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

It was? I thought it was kind of cool after I played it. Oh well.

[QUOTE="Rockclmbr6"]I'll do what I did with TP--Just ignore the review and buy it anyway.

Seriously, when 95% of the game critics out there give the game a 9.5-10, and then GS gives it lower than a 9, I start to trust GS's reviews less.
razzy1

Agree 100%

[QUOTE="Riviera_Phantom"][QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Willy105

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

It was? I thought it was kind of cool after I played it. Oh well.

[QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Riviera_Phantom"][QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Riviera_Phantom

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

But, you could easily turn off the speaker in the remote. Why penalise the Wii version for an optional feature...

Looks unprofessional to me.

Higher standards in sound? Sound is sound. Why didn't the GC get a higher graphics score?

If GOW2 gets lower than AAA, I will officially spot using GS as a review site. You cant innovate in everygame. Sumtimes u shouldnt fix it if it aint broke. Like GTA3 was good, then came Vice City which was more of the same with little ad ons, and then GTA:SA which was more of the same with a lil more added on. No innovation, but they were great games...Now if the underrate GoW2 because it "fails to innovate"...well, lets just say i will lose all respect for GSViviath

[QUOTE="Riviera_Phantom"][QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Riviera_Phantom"][QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 36088Ghost89

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

But, you could easily turn off the speaker in the remote. Why penalise the Wii version for an optional feature...

Looks unprofessional to me.

Higher standards in sound? Sound is sound. Why didn't the GC get a higher graphics score?

[QUOTE="88Ghost89"][QUOTE="Willy105"]

[QUOTE="double-r"]they wont under rate it since it is not on ps3 or wii ps2 is last gen and i think i their contract with M$, they can only underrate next gen games that are not on the 360Riviera_Phantom

But Zelda TP scored 8.9 on Gamecube.

That rating confuses me...anyone know why the GC deserved .1 more in sound than the Wii.

If it was graphics, yeah I would understand, more of an accomplishment for the GC but sound?

Double You, Tee, Eff

If GOW2 gets lower than AAA, I will officially spot using GS as a review site. You cant innovate in everygame. Sumtimes u shouldnt fix it if it aint broke. Like GTA3 was good, then came Vice City which was more of the same with little ad ons, and then GTA:SA which was more of the same with a lil more added on. No innovation, but they were great games...Now if the underrate GoW2 because it "fails to innovate"...well, lets just say i will lose all respect for GSViviath

If God of War 2 deserves an 8.7, it will score an 8.7. Twilight Princess fully deserved the score it got.project343

I'll do what I did with TP--Just ignore the review and buy it anyway. 

Seriously, when 95% of the game critics out there give the game a 9.5-10, and then GS gives it lower than a 9, I start to trust GS's reviews less.
  Rockclmbr6

Would you revolt and lash out if God of War 2 gets under 9.0?

A few things to keep in mind. The developers said that they did nothing new to GoW's formula. So it's basically like a continuation of the first one but with more intensity. Kind of like Twilight Princess....nothing new, just more intensity.

Just wondering since I know a lot of Nintendo-fans got furious over Twilight's score and Sony-fans over Virtua Fighter 5.

Well?

ASK_Story

I'd laugh then go out and buy it because God of War rocks \m/ :Dd_black

there would be a 2nd cow nuclear meltdown of a proportion like that of the GS 10 things to get us to buy a ps3 article caused, The nuclear fall out would last for years, We at system wars would have to mutate to survive..... 


I give you the cowming
the horror!!! the HORROR!!!!
WilliamRLBaker

Kind of like what happened to the hedgehogs after the Dreamcast died?

Too bad.

OMG.  I think if that happened, a plague of locusts will devour our souls!  The world will end!  I'd better rush out now and stock up on canned goods and beef-jerky just in case such a worse-case scenario occurs!

Or maybe nothing will happen and I will buy it anyway.