What's with all these perfect scores?

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

gamefreakwill

Yeah, that's exactly why 10/10 is "Prime" and not "Perfect" :|

2 games...get. over. it.

KevinV talks about this on the mgs4 official 10 thread i think btw.

Congrats, you made a whining thread!!

The fact is, 2 of this gen's greatest games have come out within months of each other. It just happened that way, and that's all.

Gamespot is not getting careless, they're just rating games!!

Amazing games deserve 10/10. There have been a lot of amazing games this gen.-Sphere-

Not really, no. But even though I haven't played MGS4 yet, from what I've heard, it's another one of those few games that would deserve a 10. However, I think this is mainly because MGS4 is unique in its formula, and because it relies so much more on story than on anything else, even gameplay.

Dude, there's only been 2 AAAA since the Dreamcast, and the Dreamcast had like 5, it's just a very good gen for games.Andrew_Xavier

try one.

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

gamefreakwill

MGS4 got a 10 and it's exclusive to PS3. Get over it...

[QUOTE="gamefreakwill"]

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

MaximumD

MGS4 got a 10 and it's exclusive to PS3. Get over it...

an xbox 360 game got 10 too

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"]Dude, there's only been 2 AAAA since the Dreamcast, and the Dreamcast had like 5, it's just a very good gen for games.warmaster670

try one.

Hmm, you're right, a bunch of 9.9s which would be 10s now though :D

[QUOTE="MaximumD"][QUOTE="gamefreakwill"]

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

TheVictor1

MGS4 got a 10 and it's exclusive to PS3. Get over it...

an xbox 360 game got 10 too

GTAIV is on PS3 as well, which also got 10. Just FYI. ;)

You mean all 2 of these perfect scores?

Whatever happened to the idea of a game deserving the score it gets?

[QUOTE="warmaster670"]

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"]Dude, there's only been 2 AAAA since the Dreamcast, and the Dreamcast had like 5, it's just a very good gen for games.Andrew_Xavier

try one.

Try one of the Dreamcast AAAAe? I own them all...If I'm a fanboy of anything, I'm a Dreamcast fanboy.

what would you call a SEGA fanboy anyway?

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"][QUOTE="warmaster670"]

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"]Dude, there's only been 2 AAAA since the Dreamcast, and the Dreamcast had like 5, it's just a very good gen for games.krunkfu2

try one.

Try one of the Dreamcast AAAAe? I own them all...If I'm a fanboy of anything, I'm a Dreamcast fanboy.

what would you call a SEGA fanboy anyway?

Hedgehog I suppose.

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"][QUOTE="warmaster670"]

[QUOTE="Andrew_Xavier"]Dude, there's only been 2 AAAA since the Dreamcast, and the Dreamcast had like 5, it's just a very good gen for games.krunkfu2

try one.

Try one of the Dreamcast AAAAe? I own them all...If I'm a fanboy of anything, I'm a Dreamcast fanboy.

what would you call a SEGA fanboy anyway?

Hopeful?...more likely I'd say "Far too optimistic dreamer".

what would you call a SEGA fanboy anyway?

krunkfu2

Dodo birds. Because dodo birds are extinct, and SEGA doesnt make consoles anymore.

This person is clearly a lemming with damage control since he said the 360 of GTAIV deserves a 10 because of download content.

Well let me tell you, reviewers review games that are on the disk, no download crap, the content which is already in the game.

[QUOTE="TheVictor1"][QUOTE="MaximumD"][QUOTE="gamefreakwill"]

Gamespot said they would never give another 10 again, what a lie! Seriously, with GTAIV and MGS4 whats with this? GTAIV doesn't totally deserve a 10, and neither does MGS4. They all have problems! GTAIV has targeting issues and pop-in problems, and those undermine the score. I love the game but it doesn't deserve a 10. As for MGS4, I'm not totally sure but I'll have to see what I experience. In short though, they're great games, really fantastic. Im happy PS3 guys got a great game with them now, they deserve it after all this waiting. But the games don't deserve perfect scores because they have problems with them one way or the other. The only other game I see that really doesn't have any problems at all is Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time, somethings magical about that game. And MGS4 and GTAIV don't deserve to be the best games of all time on this site, they should be after Ocarina and Chrono Trigger in my opinion. But still, these games aren't perfect, but I'm not saying they're bad, I think they both rock.

P.S.- if GTAIV's going to be the best game of all time on that list, the 360 version should be before the PS3 because of DLC.

RotaryRX7

MGS4 got a 10 and it's exclusive to PS3. Get over it...

an xbox 360 game got 10 too

GTAIV is on PS3 as well, which also got 10. Just FYI. ;)

yup, but it does not change the fact that an xbox 360 game has gotten a 10

Logically and philosophically, there is no perfect game that exist and that there never will that would result to no game deserving a 10.

A 10 here will never mean it's perfect. it will just mean it's so epic so great, etc.

[QUOTE="RotaryRX7"][QUOTE="TheVictor1"][QUOTE="MaximumD"]MGS4 got a 10 and it's exclusive to PS3. Get over it...

WhenLegendsmeet

an xbox 360 game got 10 too

GTAIV is on PS3 as well, which also got 10. Just FYI. ;)

yup, but it does not change the fact that an xbox 360 game has gotten a 10

Yes, but my point is, it's not exclusive, which is what the whole point was when MaximumD posted.

Him responding with, Xbox has one too is pointless since PS3 has that same 10 as well anyways. That's all I'm saying...

"But, buh, bu....there is no way that it just might actually be a great game that is so well made that it deserves a 10. I just cannot comprehend such a possibility. I mean, afterall, it is on the PS3, and I love teh 360.":cry:

Here, for you.