I'd vote KOTOR, but I personally don't consider it console RPG, mainly because then you can call any game on a console a "console RPG", even if it's also a PC game, so you'd need to add TES at least. I will refrain from voting, then.
KOTOR??! lol FF and Pokemon are in a completely different league. They've both become phenomena and can both be considered some of the best RPGs of all time. But I prefer FF more... but i'm waiting for April 22, Woot!
KOTOR??! lol FF and Pokemon are in a completely different league. They've both become phenomena and can both be considered some of the best RPGs of all time. But I prefer FF more... but i'm waiting for April 22, Woot!nacademy
Pokemon is the second highest selling franchise and I think FF is the third. Of course, Mario is the first. But yeah, as far as RPG's go, they take the cake.
Fire Emblem and Paper Mario are the biggest RPG franchise from Nintendo, not Pokemon.Redgarl
i am very sure its pokemon... but it doesnt really matter, because those are what ive put up, and im to lazy to change it. plus, changing it now, however slightly, will still mess up the data.
Fire Emblem and Paper Mario are the biggest RPG franchise from Nintendo, not Pokemon.Redgarl
Considering that Pokemon is the second highest selling franchise in the gaming industry, I say no. They are second only to Mario, but Paper Mario and Mario RPG certainly didn't provide all of those sales.
[QUOTE="Redgarl"]Fire Emblem and Paper Mario are the biggest RPG franchise from Nintendo, not Pokemon.HappySunnGuy
i am very sure its pokemon... but it doesnt really matter, because those are what ive put up, and im to lazy to change it. plus, changing it now, however slightly, will still mess up the data.
Paper Mario is the only title to got the Player choice Honor on GC. I admit that pokemon sell incredebly well on handles, but on GC, I don't remember any good pokemon game.
You're comparing 2 full franchises to a miniature series? If so: KOTOR1 > FF7, FF8, FF10, FF6, FF12, FF3 > Pokemon Red, Blue, and Yellow > KOTOR2 > All other FFs > All other Pokemon games. :D
In other words, my vote goes to KOTOR even though KOTOR is more of a PC-designed RPG (be it on consoles or not).
[QUOTE="HappySunnGuy"][QUOTE="Redgarl"]Fire Emblem and Paper Mario are the biggest RPG franchise from Nintendo, not Pokemon.Redgarl
i am very sure its pokemon... but it doesnt really matter, because those are what ive put up, and im to lazy to change it. plus, changing it now, however slightly, will still mess up the data.
Paper Mario is the only title to got the Player choice Honor on GC. I admit that pokemon sell incredebly well on handles, but on GC, I don't remember any good pokemon game.
yes, but franchises dont have to come from consols.
[QUOTE="Redgarl"]Fire Emblem and Paper Mario are the biggest RPG franchise from Nintendo, not Pokemon.MrDziekuje
Considering that Pokemon is the second highest selling franchise in the gaming industry, I say no. They are second only to Mario, but Paper Mario and Mario RPG certainly didn't provide all of those sales.
While still best sellers, the quality of the pokemon series started going downhill after G/S. While Fire Emblem is still as good as ever. Also there's Earthbound and Golden Sun, Which as a Nintendo fan i would much rather represent the company over pokemon.
[QUOTE="project343"]You're comparing 2 full franchises to a miniature series? If so: KOTOR1 > FF7, FF8, FF10, FF6, FF12, FF3 > Pokemon Red, Blue, and Yellow > KOTOR2 > All other FFs > All other Pokemon games. :D
well, whats a bigger rpg franchise on the xbox consols right now?
Those are some great RPGs but Pokemon just owns them so much IMO. I dont think i have enjoyed an RPG that much with the exception of Super Mario RPG: legend of the Seven Stars
Its a virtual tie between Paper Mario: TYD and Skies of Arcadia Legends for me, so I didn't vote.
AFBrat77
Skies of Arcadia is the best RPG ever made. I never enjoyed an RPG so much in my life.
I voted Fina Fantasy because I've played every single one of them and none of em were bad, except Dirge of Cerberus and Final Fantasy VIII.
I only played the first KOTOR. Excellent game. Dialogue really draws you in. Really hoping there will be a 3rd installment.
Pokemon was great...in the past..they keep rehashing the same crap with new weirder and weirder looking creatures. It has gone stale. The new DS pokemon looks like freakin GBA game for god sakes.
Log in to comment