Which game will score higher? GTA4 - MGS4 or GoW2?

I say GTA4 overall

Any other prediction?

EDIT: Since ppl getting confused GoW2 = GeoW2. Im talking about Gears of War 2!!! ok??!! got it now!!!?? :)

GTA IV > Gears 2 > MGS4

Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

Even though i want it to be MGS4, it looks like it will be GTA4 because the number of multiplayer modes and the always magnificent 100 hour single player mode.

GTA IV > Gears 2 > MGS4

[QUOTE="MrKittle"]Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.EuroMafia

No? Why?

MGS4 Kojima won't allow himself to go out without a bang.jangojay

[QUOTE="EuroMafia"]

GTA IV > Gears 2 > MGS4

[QUOTE="MrKittle"]Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

No? Why?

Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

and Gears 1 look a lot better than MGS4!

What God of War II? Do you time travel or something? your talking about GeoW2, get it right next time it confuses alot of people - Anyway

GTA4 > MGS4 > GeoW2 or MGS4 > GTA4 > GeoW2

Most likely GTA4, but personaly i'll enjoy MGS4 more.Tykain

I second that.

[QUOTE="MrKittle"]Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.PAL360

and Gears 1 look a lot better than MGS4!

No...

Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

gta will score 9.5 and so will gears, mgs will either be 8.5 or 9.

Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

How do you know what Gears 2 looks like Graphically. There has not even been one screen shot. Also if the extra level they added on pC is an indication it will look better becuase that one level looked way dif then the rest of the game.

I agree that I am looking forward to MGS4 more though.

Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.MrKittle

How do you know what it looks like. The game hasn't even been shown yet. If you are going by graphics alone, you fail. Have you played either of these games yet? I didn't think so.

Im thinking all 3 games will get the same score since Gamespot only goes by .5's now instead of .1's. So my guess is all 3 will get a 9.5.EnergyAbsorber

Yes but Poll says about the overall score of gamerankings-metacritic sites and not GS :)

9.5 GTA4

9.5 MGS4

8.0 GeoW2

teh lulz, I can make teh biased as welllz!

I say GTAIV. I think MGS4 and Gears 2 will both score a 9.TMontana1004

I say MGS4 simply because it has a genius like Kojima doing his best. Plus this has much more innovation than either of those games. GTA4 and GeOW2 are just any sequels with more polish and little trinkets added on to bring them to this generation. MGS4 may follow the same stealth mechanics but its comepletely new in everything else.

PS

Don't have a PS3 have a 360 and no I am not getting a PS3. Therefore = NOT FANBOY RANT

GeOW2>GTA4>MGS4

Lets be serious, as much as I love the GTA and MGS4 series, Gears is on a different level.

GeoW2 - 9.5

GTA4 - 9.5

MGS4 - 8.5

Edit: Wow i just looked at the poll. There are some crazy Sony fanboys here. Even the most die-hard cow knows GTA4 and GeoW2 will score higher than MGS4. They are in a differnt level of games.

GTA IV > Gears 2 > MGS4

[QUOTE="MrKittle"]Not Gears 2, graphically it looks the same as Gears 1...I don't care about a new water engine and chainsaw battles, its the same game as Gears 1...not a bad thing but its not going to be as breathtaking as the first one. MGS4 or GTA4 will be close but because I want MGS4 more...I vote for MGS4.EuroMafia