Which of these titles will score the lowest on Gamespot? (Poll, 56k warning)

Which of the following games will get the LOWEST score on Gamespot? What is your reasoning behind your prediction?

Grand Theft Auto IV (PS3, 360)

Metal Gear Solid IV (PS3)

Halo 3 (360)

Super Smash Bros. Brawl (Wii)

I'm gonna bookmark this thread just to see whether or not the majority of SW will be surprised by these games and their scores later on this year.

Anyway, which of these titles will get the lowest score?

Either Smash or MGSIV.

Either Smash or MGSIV.

 

web966

Based on their past reviews, it seems this will be the case. Ironically, those will probably be the best two games of the four. 

Smash Brothers or GTA4 most likely.

Even if it's utterly amazing and the best game it can be..... MGS4. GS has never liked the series. SSMB maybe. Hell maybe Halo3's mediocre visuals will drop it down (don't spew that beta ver crap those are prettymuch final). Lazy_Boy88

smash

Halo 3: Could flop... seriously, it could. Bungie could spend a lot of time making the new multiplayer functions work while forgetting about the single player campaign. I really do not want to judge, because I know I will most likely find it bland and boring. Still will be a great game.
foxhound_fox

If the multiplayer is good enough, that doesn't really matter. Games like Unreal Tournament and Battlefield have shown this.

SSBB is the safe choice obviously.  Has never had AAA and the other ones all have had an AAA title before.

EDIT: I see lots of people leaning towards MGS4 as well, the only thing I can equate to my easy decision of SSBB over MGS4 is that I believe MGS4 will kinda get the MGS2 feel. I mean remember how hyped up MGS2 was compared to MGS3, and look, MGS2 got a 9.6.  The first MGS on new hardware is gonna get big scores like the first one on last hardware did IMO.

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]
Halo 3: Could flop... seriously, it could. Bungie could spend a lot of time making the new multiplayer functions work while forgetting about the single player campaign. I really do not want to judge, because I know I will most likely find it bland and boring. Still will be a great game.
TyrantDragon55

If the multiplayer is good enough, that doesn't really matter. Games like Unreal Tournament and Battlefield have shown this.

Games like Battlefield and Unreal didn't leave cliffhangers.

[QUOTE="TyrantDragon55"]

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]
Halo 3: Could flop... seriously, it could. Bungie could spend a lot of time making the new multiplayer functions work while forgetting about the single player campaign. I really do not want to judge, because I know I will most likely find it bland and boring. Still will be a great game.
Puppa_Shogun

If the multiplayer is good enough, that doesn't really matter. Games like Unreal Tournament and Battlefield have shown this.

Games like Battlefield and Unreal didn't leave cliffhangers.

Considering that Halo 3 is supposed to be the end of the series, I doubt it will either.

If the multiplayer is good enough, that doesn't really matter. Games like Unreal Tournament and Battlefield have shown this.TyrantDragon55

Why'd you even put SSBB on there? It's not really in the same league as the otehrs, it's like a party fighting game. If you wanted a wii titles you should have put Mario Galaxy.

So SSBB, since it will probably get AA.

[QUOTE="TyrantDragon55"]If the multiplayer is good enough, that doesn't really matter. Games like Unreal Tournament and Battlefield have shown this.foxhound_fox

It didn't stop Halo 2 did it?

My most aniticipated title up there is smash bros, and that will get the lowest score.

"no innovation", "no use of wii mote" "only updated graphics". It will get in the 8s. 

It didn't stop Halo 2 did it?TyrantDragon55

[QUOTE="TyrantDragon55"]It didn't stop Halo 2 did it?foxhound_fox

I thought we were talking about scores here? Obviously no game is going to please everyone.

I thought we were talking about scores here? Obviously no game is going to please everyone.TyrantDragon55

An easy poll question to answer: Metal Gear Solid IV.

It's the only one on the list that is a PS3 exclusive, and this site will target it with a hate rating like all the rest of the PS3 exclusives, pure and simple.

[QUOTE="TyrantDragon55"]I thought we were talking about scores here? Obviously no game is going to please everyone.foxhound_fox

Agreed, we'll just have to wait and see.