Who has the best controller? Wii, PS3. or 360?

Ok I just got my 360 this week, and I've been comparing the controllers of all 3 consoles, and honestly I have to say that the Wii still feels better to the hand, but I have to give the PS3 and 360 a tie when it comes to the controller, I really can't compare between the two. Which one do you guy's think is better?

360 controller because it actually contours perfectly to your hands.

Meh Wii. Don't really care for it. Not bad, but I don't like it more than other things.

Dualshock's analog sticks are far too close if your hands are any bigger than a pre-pubescent girls' hands.

It depends entirely on the game. I like the 360 controller for shooters (I hate shooters granted), PS3 controller for fighters (even if the triggers make me want to punch something) and the wiimote for quirky stuff, PC like like World of Goo or lost winds. I guess in terms of ranking it would be

Wiimote = Depends
360 controller = Depends
PS3 Controller = Depends
Winner = me.

I like the 360 controller a lot but have no problems with the PS3 Dualshock. I am baffled at some of the complaints for the PS3 controller honestly.

The Wii controller is so well designed.

I would honestly have to say the 360 controller. I prefer the analog sticks to the directional pad.

The PS3 controller feels uncomfortable for some reason.

The Wii conrtols have their place. They are great for sports games, sword fights, and pretty much most things except FPS shooters (aiming is a pain) and platformers (you don't need them for just moving and jumping.) However, some games use a balance between regular controls and motion controls, like Mario Galaxy. As much as I like them in most situations, there are still a few situations where I don't. That does not make them the best.

I will try not to start getting into too much detail, like I usually do.

360 is extremely well designed (considering MS hardware record you would think otherwise :P) and it has the right amount of weight for me unlike the PS3 control which without dual shock, feels like some cheap plastic. As for the wii, well it's fun when implemented well.

I like the 360 controller a lot but have no problems with the PS3 Dualshock. I am baffled at some of the complaints for the PS3 controller honestly.

The Wii controller is so well designed.

Alpha-Male22

I like the PS controller except for shooters. I also really hate what they did with the Triggers. I prefered it on dualshock 2. But overall it still takes a dump on the 360's sorry excuse for a Dpad.

Why isn't there a "keyboard and mouse" option?

Why isn't there a "keyboard and mouse" option?

Hanass

The Dualshock 3 is the best in every genre of gaming!

The Dualshock 3 is the best in every genre of gaming!

jakehouston88

Go ahead and plug your DS3 to your PC, and play a game of CS. You'll get pulverized.

I'm a PS3 and PC gamer, and I have to say that the 360 controller, on my pc, is amazing. it is much more comfortable than ps3 controller

The Dualshock 3 is the best in every genre of gaming!

jakehouston88

360 wins for everything.

PS3, the 360 controller is over sized and clunky. The Wii controller prevents laying on the couch.djsifer01

What do you mean?

[QUOTE="Hanass"]

Why isn't there a "keyboard and mouse" option?

tagyhag

[QUOTE="djsifer01"]PS3, the 360 controller is over sized and clunky. The Wii controller prevents laying on the couch.tagyhag

What do you mean?

You can't play laying down?

[QUOTE="tagyhag"]

[QUOTE="djsifer01"]PS3, the 360 controller is over sized and clunky. The Wii controller prevents laying on the couch.Miyuki-Chan

What do you mean?

You can't play laying down?

The 360 controller is my favorite. I love the button layout and it fits perfectly in my hands. The Dualshock controller feels a little awkward but its also decent. The wii controller (speaking of the wand and "nunchuck") is my least favorite; a single analog stick is just bad and I hate waggle controls.

Let's not be subjective here.

360 is as standard as it can get. PS3s adds motion. Wii has the classic controller for a standard layout that is equal to the 360. The Motion and pointer function of the remote stole this generation of consoles. There is little to argue about.

There should be less "oh it feels perfect in my hands". Come on... I can pick up any gamepad and use it just as well as any other.

They all have their ups and downs. The good thing about the Wii, you have more than one controlelr to choose from. The regualr Wiimote is better for pretty mucheverything, except button mashers, and fighting games...which are sometimes, the same thing. But then you have the classic controller and the GCN controller which take those places. IMO, the GCN is the best controler for fighting games. I have yet to lay my hands on a classic controller to say anything however.

360. Hate the PS3s analogs, they move to easy, and my hands just feel cramped on them, especially after being spoiled by sheer comfort in the 360s.kindaalemming

360 wired controller all day

but it really does depend on the game

I couldn't imagine playing ninja gaiden on a dual shock and i couldn't imagine playing god of war on the 360 pad

Easily the xbox 360 controller.Racer850

Is it what you are used to - that is a valid reason if you have nothing else.

Personally I still find the keyboard and mouse BY FAR to be far superior to the rest of them - it has the most options and is the only one you can set up properly as a left - handed a controller system.

A couple others have that option but it is lame at best.

the ps3 by far, the wii mote isn't so bad and the 360 is just plain horrible

Overall, Xbox 360.

The Dualshock 3 is the best in every genre of gaming!

jakehouston88

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

The Dualshock 3 is the best in every genre of gaming!

Hanass

Go ahead and plug your DS3 to your PC, and play a game of CS. You'll get pulverized.

Yeah, control sticks don't stand a chance against mouse+keyboard in a shooter.