Xbox 360 has the TPS, JRPG, Racing and FPS exclusive KINGS

This is absolutely fantastic. Forza 4 is the racing king. Gears 3 is the TPS King. Halo is the FPS king. And Lost Odyssey is the JRPG king. Can anyone make arguments otherwise? All the games are the top in their class.

what are you basing this on?

what are you basing this on?

CaseyWegner

Fanboyism

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

Phoenix534

Fanboyism

what are you basing this on?

CaseyWegner

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

then how is lost odyssey jrpg king?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

Then wouldn't a Pokemon game be the best JRPG?

Tales of Vesperia is currently the JRPG king of this generation.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

CaseyWegner

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

then how is lost odyssey jrpg king?

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

Tales of Vesperia is currently the JRPG king of this generation.

GeoffZak

I don't think they were exclusive. And I haven't heard much praise.

we all know how this thread will go down

1. you make a flame bait thread

2.people respond

3. your fanboyism goes out of control

4. people respond with TLDR answers that ends this thread

5. you disappear for a few days until something else comes up

im in the ball park right?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

You have sales.

Popularity is the same. If you have a 360/PS3, you know someone else has the rival console.

Mainstream appeal , its a shooter console, of course its the mainstream appeal. Also, KINECT.

we all know how thisthread will go down 1. you make a flame bait thread 2.people respond 3. your fanboyism goes out of control 4. people respond with TLDR answers that ends this thread 5. you disappear for a few days until something else comes up im in the ball park right?eboyishere

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

only halo and gears meet the criteria you created. everything else falls short.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

jimmypsn

then how is lost odyssey jrpg king?

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

Actually most of the JRPG fans I have seen don't enjoy the game, it's ones who dislike JRPGs that seem to enjoy it the most.

Allthough I will give you racing king, as Xbox has PGR AND Forza, the others I'd have to argue. Gears AND Uncharted are both = TPS Halo is a great Fps, but Resistance and mag are also good And JRPG???? PS3 Obviously wins that.ABCarmine

But gears has the overall mainstream appeal and sales to back it up. Amirite?

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]we all know how thisthread will go down 1. you make a flame bait thread 2.people respond 3. your fanboyism goes out of control 4. people respond with TLDR answers that ends this thread 5. you disappear for a few days until something else comes up im in the ball park right?jimmypsn

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

[QUOTE="ABCarmine"]Allthough I will give you racing king, as Xbox has PGR AND Forza, the others I'd have to argue. Gears AND Uncharted are both = TPS Halo is a great Fps, but Resistance and mag are also good And JRPG???? PS3 Obviously wins that.jimmypsn

But gears has the overall mainstream appeal and sales to back it up. Amirite?

[QUOTE="GeoffZak"]

Tales of Vesperia is currently the JRPG king of this generation.

jimmypsn

I don't think they were exclusive. And I haven't heard much praise.

Tales of Vesperia was the only reason I bought a 360. Just about every other exclusive title is mediocre on the 360. But that's just me.

Tales of Vesperia is only exclusive to the 360 outside of Japan. They released a PS3 version of it, but unfortunately it was never localized. So I had to buy a 360 after patiently waiting for the PS3 version to be localized.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]we all know how thisthread will go down 1. you make a flame bait thread 2.people respond 3. your fanboyism goes out of control 4. people respond with TLDR answers that ends this thread 5. you disappear for a few days until something else comes up im in the ball park right?eboyishere

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

jimmypsn

then how is lost odyssey jrpg king?

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

okay. what kind of category is "exclusive" genre king? ff13 scored better and probably sold betterthan lost odyssey but it can't be king because it's multiplat? this sounds pretty weak.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

then how is lost odyssey jrpg king?

CaseyWegner

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

okay. what kind of category is "exclusive" genre king? ff13 scored better and probably sold betterthan lost odyssey but it can't be king because it's multiplat? this sounds pretty weak.

That's why I made my categorization specific.

Eg. Lets look at PS3 FPS exclusves that can compete with halo possibly. Killzone. Nope. Resistance. Nope. Haze. heck no. Mag? No.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

I don't see how Lost Odyssey is JRPG king then.

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

jimmypsn

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

jimmypsn

okay. what kind of category is "exclusive" genre king? ff13 scored better and probably sold betterthan lost odyssey but it can't be king because it's multiplat? this sounds pretty weak.

That's why I made my categorization specific.

Eg. Lets look at PS3 FPS exclusves that can compete with halo possibly. Killzone. Nope. Resistance. Nope. Haze. heck no. Mag? No.

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

jimmypsn

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

Uncharted 1 8.0 ----> 9.5

One series getting better,ones getting less awesome. No need to be picky.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

what are you basing this on?

jimmypsn

I am basing this on scores, sales, overall popularity and mainstream appeal.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

eboyishere

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

Very popular among the japanese gamer RPG crowd who have played it. Everyone I'ved talked with enjoyed the game immensely unlike any other JRPG exclusive.

jimmypsn

okay. what kind of category is "exclusive" genre king? ff13 scored better and probably sold betterthan lost odyssey but it can't be king because it's multiplat? this sounds pretty weak.

That's why I made my categorization specific.

Eg. Lets look at PS3 FPS exclusves that can compete with halo possibly. Killzone. Nope. Resistance. Nope. Haze. heck no. Mag? No.

but it's specific to the point ofbeing manipulative. it's somehow king even though there's something that beats it.

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

jimmypsn

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

This is absolutely fantastic. Forza 4 is the racing king. ye Gears 3 is the TPS King. Halo is the FPS king. And Lost Odyssey is the JRPG king. Can anyone make arguments otherwise? All the games are the top in their class.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

TrapJak

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

Well I couldn't care less about realistic or semi realistic racing games or Halo, but that's just me.

Your other 2 choices are laughable though.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

TrapJak

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

ur being picky now why include just the sequel?

This is absolutely fantastic. Forza 4 is the racing king. Gears 3 is the TPS King. Halo is the FPS king. And Lost Odyssey is the JRPG king. Can anyone make arguments otherwise? All the games are the top in their class.

jimmypsn

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

okay. what kind of category is "exclusive" genre king? ff13 scored better and probably sold betterthan lost odyssey but it can't be king because it's multiplat? this sounds pretty weak.

CaseyWegner

That's why I made my categorization specific.

Eg. Lets look at PS3 FPS exclusves that can compete with halo possibly. Killzone. Nope. Resistance. Nope. Haze. heck no. Mag? No.

but it's specific to the point ofbeing manipulative. it's somehow king even though there's something that beats it.

Go ahead and make your argument why I'm wrong. I created this thread for discussion.

[QUOTE="TrapJak"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

jimmypsn

ur being picky now why include just the sequel?

and gears 3 isn't even out yet.

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

If this thread upsets you, may I suggest you do not post in it.

jimmypsn

naw actually im interested in it but like the guy said uncharted 2 outscored gears.....so

racing?possibly

FPS?dont know about that

JRPG? not into them but thats the ps3's backyard

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

This is absolutely fantastic. Forza 4 is the racing king. Gears 3 is the TPS King. Halo is the FPS king. And Lost Odyssey is the JRPG king. Can anyone make arguments otherwise? All the games are the top in their class.

scar-hawk

Your choices. Nothing wrong with that. I don't agree though.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

That's why I made my categorization specific.

Eg. Lets look at PS3 FPS exclusves that can compete with halo possibly. Killzone. Nope. Resistance. Nope. Haze. heck no. Mag? No.

jimmypsn

but it's specific to the point ofbeing manipulative. it's somehow king even though there's something that beats it.

Go ahead and make your argument why I'm wrong. I created this thread for discussion.

okay. a game is not king of anything if something else beats it.

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

but it's specific to the point ofbeing manipulative. it's somehow king even though there's something that beats it.

CaseyWegner

Go ahead and make your argument why I'm wrong. I created this thread for discussion.

okay. a game is not king of anything if something else beats it.

What would be your choices based on the categorizations that I've created. Don't hold back.

The FPS king will be RAGE. A multiplat.

BF3 has a shot too :P

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

Let me check the gamespot scores. Gears 1 and 2. 9.0 9.0

Uncharted 1 and 2 8.0 9.5

I think Gears is rated higher if my math is right.

jimmypsn

seeing how the 2nd out scored gears 2, then by your standards UC is evolving while Gears stayed the same?

I wouldn't choose Gears for ur arguments because gears wins in scores, sales, popularity. The trifecta.

your avoiding my question though

does that mean. by your standards, that uncharted is evolving while gears is still the same?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="jimmypsn"]

Go ahead and make your argument why I'm wrong. I created this thread for discussion.

jimmypsn

okay. a game is not king of anything if something else beats it.

What would be your choices based on the categorizations that I've created. Don't hold back.

whatever game outscored them be they exclusive or multiplat.

The FPS king will be RAGE. A multiplat.

BF3 has a shot too :P

theuncharted34

You need to read my thread a little closer. Those games aren't exclusive.

The FPS king will be RAGE. A multiplat.

BF3 has a shot too :P

theuncharted34

i keep hearng about rage, is it a bioshock/borderlands hybrid?

The FPS king will be RAGE. A multiplat.

BF3 has a shot too :P

theuncharted34