You can only have one. The Xbox or PS3, you get every game.

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

EDIT:Some of you can read (likeBlackTragedy) and understand what I've been saying. Some of you can not understand and I've been trying to explain this for the majority of my posts in this thread. Its not that hard. So stop with the "TC is bias"

Xbox360 gets all of thePS3 gets all of the

Xbox360 games PS3 games

CompatibleXboxgames PS2 games (cause the back words compatible version is being offered)

DVDs PS1 games (same reasoning for PS2)

CDs Blu-Rays, DVDs and CDs

Downloadable games on the marketplace Downloadable games on the PSN store

Only game I need is my GOW3 :D

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

I smell a fanboy.

Aside from that, I don't need BR movies, and I have a PS2 already, so I don't consider those things when the genie asks me what I want.

Its nothing against the PS3, its getting better as we speak, but the hypothetical conditions given don't help me in my decision.

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

Ya that's pretty much a gg right there.

PS3, because you'd said I would get all PS1/PS2/BluRay movies, after selling them all I'd be pretty set.

Lol pretty biased poll if you read the OP. I'd still take the PS3 though.DragonfireXZ95

Ya it is lol.

Anyways, even if I only got Ps3 games I'd still choose Ps3.

Hmmm if FFXIV gets announced for xbox 360, then xbox 360 because it has more games I like on it but if FFXIV is PS3 and PC only then I will take the PC :P

If you can't be satisfied with either of those, then you are a fool.

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

Only game I need is my GOW3 :D

SwagSurf

God of War III or Gears of War 3? :P

I'm guessing God of War by your signature.

Oh, and PS3, easily.

I couldn't imagine playing games like GoW III, Uncharted 2 or Killzone 2 on 360, so I'd go with PS3.Doolz2024

360 library is far bigger and imo better.

ill go with 360 cuz i like being the minority 8)

hah why am I getting called one sided? Yeah an advantage to the PS3 compared to the 360 would be that there would be more playstation games then there are xbox/xbox 360 games. That's part of the point :roll:.

I love how all the xbox fanboys seem to be forgetting that he mentionned that you could play all PS2 and PS1 games.

I love how all the xbox fanboys seem to be forgetting that he mentionned that you could play all PS2 and PS1 games.

Eggimannd

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

Lol, for starters, you couldn't have possibly made the OP any more biased. I mean, seriously, at least try to hide your fanboyism next time.

Second, this poll may as well be a headcount of how many cows or lems visit this topic. Utterly useless.

[QUOTE="paradigm68"]

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

_Impmacaque_

Lol, for starters, you couldn't have possibly made the OP any more biased. I mean, seriously, at least try to hide your fanboyism next time.

Second, this poll may as well be a headcount of how many cows or lems visit this topic. Utterly useless.

Re - title thread as: ... Why 360 > PS3... Then in body OP type: ... Just because.

Heck, just for fun I might even go along with it. :twisted:

[QUOTE="_Impmacaque_"]

[QUOTE="paradigm68"]

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

Lol, for starters, you couldn't have possibly made the OP any more biased. I mean, seriously, at least try to hide your fanboyism next time.

Second, this poll may as well be a headcount of how many cows or lems visit this topic. Utterly useless.

Humm, let's see - oh, I know, let's make a poll asking people to choose between three generations worth of video games spanning nearly two decades and between five or six years worth of game library that's probably a tenth of the collective size of the former.

Making absolute comparisons between the video game companies makes very little sense when you look at things objectively. Makes the whole thing sorta hard to take seriously.

[QUOTE="paradigm68"][QUOTE="_Impmacaque_"]

Lol, for starters, you couldn't have possibly made the OP any more biased. I mean, seriously, at least try to hide your fanboyism next time.

Second, this poll may as well be a headcount of how many cows or lems visit this topic. Utterly useless.

_Impmacaque_

Humm, let's see - oh, I know, let's make a poll asking people to choose between three generations worth of video games spanning nearly two decades and between five or six years worth of game library that's probably a tenth of the collective size of the former.

Making absolute comparisons between the video game companies makes very little sense when you look at things objectively. Makes the whole thing sorta hard to take seriously.

I love how all the xbox fanboys seem to be forgetting that he mentionned that you could play all PS2 and PS1 games.

Eggimannd

Maybe some people really love their Halo and Gears of War? Or perhaps some people don't care about BC, your opinion doesn't have to agree with everyone elses.

[QUOTE="_Impmacaque_"]

[QUOTE="paradigm68"] K explain. I prefer my Xbox atm (it changes for me :P). Explain why I am so biasedparadigm68

Humm, let's see - oh, I know, let's make a poll asking people to choose between three generations worth of video games spanning nearly two decades and between five or six years worth of game library that's probably a tenth of the collective size of the former.

Making absolute comparisons between the video game companies makes very little sense when you look at things objectively. Makes the whole thing sorta hard to take seriously.

Xbox 360 for me, but it's really close.

PS3 only has one game I'm remotely interested in (MotorStorm)

so Xbox.

But if it was PS2 or Orig, then the PS2, if that has relevancy.

PS3 obviously. You'd get all the exclusives, all the PS1/2 games, and all the Blu-ray movies, not to mention all the multiplats and DVDs since PS3 can also play DVDs. The only thing Xbox would have that you couldn't get by choosing the PS3 would be the 360 exclusives. Pretty unfair poll.

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

paradigm68

Sounds like the genie works for Sony. I'd chose the 360, but thankfully in real life I don't have to chose and I enjoy having both systems.

[QUOTE="paradigm68"]

A magic genie will give you a free console. You must choose betweenXbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you will be given EVERY disc (movies included) that the console can run. You will also have every down loadable game, unlimited online play and every accessory.

Note the if you choose the PS3 you get blu ray movies and all the PS2 and PS1 games (pretend that the genie gave you a PS3 that was back words compatible)

mythrol

Does the ps3 get mass effect 2, splinter cell conviction, alan wake and crackdown? No? then i'll take the 360

Errrrr..... errrrrr....... prooooobably ps3. But thats a toughy.