This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for wickerman2004
wickerman2004

3878

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 13

User Lists: 0

#1 wickerman2004
Member since 2004 • 3878 Posts

Round 3. You can only vote once. Voting ends Saturday.
Castlevania moved on due to receiving higher number of votes overall.
Winners of this round face off against each other in the final round!!!

Zelda: Link to the Past - 1
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 0
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 1

Ocarina of Time - 0
Golden Eye:007 - 1

Kid Icarus - 0
Super Bomberman - 1

Balloon Fight - 0
Castlevania - 1

Mario Brothers - 1
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 0

Avatar image for REVOLUTIONfreak
REVOLUTIONfreak

18418

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 0

#2 REVOLUTIONfreak
Member since 2005 • 18418 Posts

Zelda: Link to the Past - 2
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 0
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 2

Ocarina of Time - 0
Golden Eye:007 - 2

Kid Icarus - 0
Super Bomberman - 2

Balloon Fight - 1
Castlevania - 1

Mario Brothers - 2
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 0

This should be interesting

Avatar image for Smoke2Much
Smoke2Much

1520

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 23

User Lists: 0

#3 Smoke2Much
Member since 2006 • 1520 Posts

Zelda: Link to the Past - 3
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 0
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 3

Ocarina of Time - 0
Golden Eye:007 - 3

Kid Icarus - 1
Super Bomberman - 2

Balloon Fight - 1
Castlevania - 2

Mario Brothers - 3
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 0

Avatar image for nightclaw
nightclaw

3049

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 32

User Lists: 0

#4 nightclaw
Member since 2005 • 3049 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 3 Star Fox - 0 Metroid - 0 Super Mario Brothers 3 - 3 Ocarina of Time - 0 Golden Eye:007 - 3 Kid Icarus - 1 Super Bomberman - 2 Balloon Fight - 1 Castlevania - 2 Mario Brothers - 3 Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 1
Avatar image for BassBoy45
BassBoy45

5330

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#5 BassBoy45
Member since 2006 • 5330 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 4
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 0
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 4

Ocarina of Time - 1
Golden Eye:007 - 3

Kid Icarus - 2
Super Bomberman - 2

Balloon Fight - 1
Castlevania - 3

Mario Brothers - 4
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 1
Still had to vote for OoT because it is paired against another non-oldschool game, this will be the last round of that with more than 1 N64 option.
Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#6 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 5
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 0
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 5

Ocarina of Time - 1
Golden Eye:007 - 4

Kid Icarus - 3
Super Bomberman - 2

Balloon Fight - 1
Castlevania - 4

Mario Brothers - 4
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 2
Avatar image for Squidward117
Squidward117

4374

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#7 Squidward117
Member since 2005 • 4374 Posts

Zelda: Link to the Past - 6
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 1
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 5

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

Kid Icarus - 3
Super Bomberman - 3

Balloon Fight - 2
Castlevania - 4

Mario Brothers - 4
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 3

Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#8 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

Avatar image for arfy2
arfy2

1613

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#9 arfy2
Member since 2006 • 1613 Posts

Zelda: Link to the Past - 7
Star Fox - 0

Metroid - 1
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 6

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 5

Kid Icarus - 3
Super Bomberman - 4

Balloon Fight - 2
Castlevania - 5

Mario Brothers - 5
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 3

Avatar image for Squidward117
Squidward117

4374

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#10 Squidward117
Member since 2005 • 4374 Posts

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

jacobs1282

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

Avatar image for arfy2
arfy2

1613

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#11 arfy2
Member since 2006 • 1613 Posts
:lol: I was going to do that but couldn't be bothered...
Avatar image for REVOLUTIONfreak
REVOLUTIONfreak

18418

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 0

#12 REVOLUTIONfreak
Member since 2005 • 18418 Posts

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

jacobs1282
i think its easily the best game ever, its just not the best OLD SCHOOL GAME...in fact, its not really even old school so thats why i dont want it to win
Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#13 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts
[QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

Squidward117

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

Avatar image for animorphsfan
animorphsfan

1511

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#14 animorphsfan
Member since 2006 • 1511 Posts

Zelda: Link to the Past - 7
Star Fox - 1

Metroid - 1
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 7

Ocarina of Time - 3
Golden Eye:007 - 5

Kid Icarus - 4
Super Bomberman - 4

Balloon Fight - 3
Castlevania - 5

Mario Brothers - 5
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 4

Avatar image for mos333
mos333

2865

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

#15 mos333
Member since 2005 • 2865 Posts
:lol: Oot is getting owned!
Avatar image for REVOLUTIONfreak
REVOLUTIONfreak

18418

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 0

#16 REVOLUTIONfreak
Member since 2005 • 18418 Posts
[QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

jacobs1282

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P
Avatar image for gameman9
gameman9

5949

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#17 gameman9
Member since 2004 • 5949 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 8 Star Fox - 1 Metroid - 1 Super Mario Brothers 3 - 8 Ocarina of Time - 4 Golden Eye:007 - 5 Kid Icarus - 4 Super Bomberman - 5 Balloon Fight - 4 Castlevania - 5 Mario Brothers - 5 Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 5
Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#18 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts
[QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

REVOLUTIONfreak

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P



:roll: Ok I understand your point, now how about this. Is it the only game that has ever been given a 10 by all of these sources? I think not, :wink: Look here, it's average score is not perfect and the player reviews, which are generally more accurate than anything else, is not perfect.. Granted 9.7 - 9.8 aint bad, but it's not perfect. Nintendo Power didn't even give it a perfect score (9.5) and it's a Nintendo game. Again as I said before I am not saying it is a bad game. I loved it, but the fact is that it is not the best ever. It getting a 10 does not make it the best game ever. Games get perfect scores, it happens, but they can not all be the best right? So now show me how it's the best ever? I don't want opinions, everyone has there own. I want you to show me, a non-believer, how it is the #1 game of all time. I wont agree with you, but at least you will have made a valid point, and you can rise to actual fan and not simple fanboy.
Avatar image for REVOLUTIONfreak
REVOLUTIONfreak

18418

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 0

#19 REVOLUTIONfreak
Member since 2005 • 18418 Posts
[QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

jacobs1282

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P



:roll: Ok I understand your point, now how about this. Is it the only game that has ever been given a 10 by all of these sources? I think not, :wink: Look here, it's average score is not perfect and the player reviews, which are generally more accurate than anything else, is not perfect.. Granted 9.7 - 9.8 aint bad, but it's not perfect. Nintendo Power didn't even give it a perfect score (9.5) and it's a Nintendo game. Again as I said before I am not saying it is a bad game. I loved it, but the fact is that it is not the best ever. It getting a 10 does not make it the best game ever. Games get perfect scores, it happens, but they can not all be the best right? So now show me how it's the best ever? I don't want opinions, everyone has there own. I want you to show me, a non-believer, how it is the #1 game of all time. I wont agree with you, but at least you will have made a valid point, and you can rise to actual fan and not simple fanboy.

1. If OoT isnt the best game ever, than what exactly is :?

2.  Im sure if you were to compare other games that got 10's, there average would be even lower than OoT's.....still making it the best game ever.  I think its the best game ever because....

A. For its time (i dont know when you first played it), there was NOTHING out there even remotely like it.  It had gameplay that was simple, unique, addictive, and still challenging..... and it still has one of the best stories ive ever read.  I find all of the connections in Zelda games to be very immersive, especially considering they all link back to OoT.

B.  It of course is my favorite game, and I have a lot of memories from playing it when i was younger

Avatar image for bededog
bededog

8579

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 28

User Lists: 0

#20 bededog
Member since 2005 • 8579 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 9
Star Fox - 1

Metroid - 1
Super Mario Brothers 3 - 9

Ocarina of Time - 5
Golden Eye:007 - 5

Kid Icarus - 5
Super Bomberman - 5

Balloon Fight - 5
Castlevania - 5

Mario Brothers - 6
Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 5
Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#21 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts
[QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

REVOLUTIONfreak

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P



:roll: Ok I understand your point, now how about this. Is it the only game that has ever been given a 10 by all of these sources? I think not, :wink: Look here, it's average score is not perfect and the player reviews, which are generally more accurate than anything else, is not perfect.. Granted 9.7 - 9.8 aint bad, but it's not perfect. Nintendo Power didn't even give it a perfect score (9.5) and it's a Nintendo game. Again as I said before I am not saying it is a bad game. I loved it, but the fact is that it is not the best ever. It getting a 10 does not make it the best game ever. Games get perfect scores, it happens, but they can not all be the best right? So now show me how it's the best ever? I don't want opinions, everyone has there own. I want you to show me, a non-believer, how it is the #1 game of all time. I wont agree with you, but at least you will have made a valid point, and you can rise to actual fan and not simple fanboy.

1. If OoT isnt the best game ever, than what exactly is :?

2. Im sure if you were to compare other games that got 10's, there average would be even lower than OoT's.....still making it the best game ever. I think its the best game ever because....

A. For its time (i dont know when you first played it), there was NOTHING out there even remotely like it. It had gameplay that was simple, unique, addictive, and still challenging..... and it still has one of the best stories ive ever read. I find all of the connections in Zelda games to be very immersive, especially considering they all link back to OoT.

B. It of course is my favorite game, and I have a lot of memories from playing it when i was younger



I played it the day it was released, and yes I agree with you on all of your points, it is still not good enough to say it is above all else the best game ever. As for your question of what is the best game of all time I'd have to say Super Mario Bros, (this is not my favorite game of all time mind you) but to this day it has sold more copies than any other game... or any 2 games for that matter in gaming history and made way for the most popular line of games, period. Again this is not my favorite series, but Mario is the most recognizable video game character and has the largest, longest running, and most profitable game series to date.
Avatar image for REVOLUTIONfreak
REVOLUTIONfreak

18418

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 0

#22 REVOLUTIONfreak
Member since 2005 • 18418 Posts
[QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

jacobs1282

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P



:roll: Ok I understand your point, now how about this. Is it the only game that has ever been given a 10 by all of these sources? I think not, :wink: Look here, it's average score is not perfect and the player reviews, which are generally more accurate than anything else, is not perfect.. Granted 9.7 - 9.8 aint bad, but it's not perfect. Nintendo Power didn't even give it a perfect score (9.5) and it's a Nintendo game. Again as I said before I am not saying it is a bad game. I loved it, but the fact is that it is not the best ever. It getting a 10 does not make it the best game ever. Games get perfect scores, it happens, but they can not all be the best right? So now show me how it's the best ever? I don't want opinions, everyone has there own. I want you to show me, a non-believer, how it is the #1 game of all time. I wont agree with you, but at least you will have made a valid point, and you can rise to actual fan and not simple fanboy.

1. If OoT isnt the best game ever, than what exactly is :?

2. Im sure if you were to compare other games that got 10's, there average would be even lower than OoT's.....still making it the best game ever. I think its the best game ever because....

A. For its time (i dont know when you first played it), there was NOTHING out there even remotely like it. It had gameplay that was simple, unique, addictive, and still challenging..... and it still has one of the best stories ive ever read. I find all of the connections in Zelda games to be very immersive, especially considering they all link back to OoT.

B. It of course is my favorite game, and I have a lot of memories from playing it when i was younger



I played it the day it was released, and yes I agree with you on all of your points, it is still not good enough to say it is above all else the best game ever. As for your question of what is the best game of all time I'd have to say Super Mario Bros, (this is not my favorite game of all time mind you) but to this day it has sold more copies than any other game... or any 2 games for that matter in gaming history and made way for the most popular line of games, period. Again this is not my favorite series, but Mario is the most recognizable video game character and has the largest, longest running, and most profitable game series to date.

i can see your point and partly agree....but overall i still think OoT is the best game ever
Avatar image for HyruleanLink
HyruleanLink

5221

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#23 HyruleanLink
Member since 2005 • 5221 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 10 Star Fox - 1 Metroid - 1 Super Mario Brothers 3 - 10 Ocarina of Time - 6 Golden Eye:007 - 5 Kid Icarus - 5 Super Bomberman - 6 Balloon Fight - 5 Castlevania - 6 Mario Brothers - 6 Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 6
Avatar image for jacobs1282
jacobs1282

298

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 0

#24 jacobs1282
Member since 2005 • 298 Posts
[QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="REVOLUTIONfreak"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"][QUOTE="Squidward117"][QUOTE="jacobs1282"]

Ocarina of Time - 2
Golden Eye:007 - 4 (What's up with you guys? Golden Eye is barely even Nintendo anymore...)

It's still counts in my book since it was for a Nintendo system and I don't want to see OoT win this. (Puts up flame shield) OoT is not the best game ever created as many like to believe, hell it's not even the best LoZ game ever. Great yes, Perfect 10 great? No

REVOLUTIONfreak

Ummm... jacobs? http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=top_rated&sort=score&page_type=games&dlx_type=all&date_filter=all&sortdir=asc

In the buisness we like to call that "OH SNAP!!"
Your rebuttal?

I am well aware of what the idiots who call themselves reviewers on this site awarded OoT and I disagree with them. They are well known for giving bad reviews and scores to games that don't deserve them or deserve better and your link only furthers my point of how badly they wrongfully score games. I mean come on THPS3 is a perfect 10? You have got to be kidding me. I'm sorry but if your only arguement for the greatness of the game is "GS gave it a 10 blah blah, I'm another OoT fanboy" then you have no business even trying to argue the point. I think OoT was a great game easily one of if not the best game for the N64, but perfect 10? Best of all time? Not even close.

you still forget that EGM gave it a 10, and IGN gave it a ten, top that :P



:roll: Ok I understand your point, now how about this. Is it the only game that has ever been given a 10 by all of these sources? I think not, :wink: Look here, it's average score is not perfect and the player reviews, which are generally more accurate than anything else, is not perfect.. Granted 9.7 - 9.8 aint bad, but it's not perfect. Nintendo Power didn't even give it a perfect score (9.5) and it's a Nintendo game. Again as I said before I am not saying it is a bad game. I loved it, but the fact is that it is not the best ever. It getting a 10 does not make it the best game ever. Games get perfect scores, it happens, but they can not all be the best right? So now show me how it's the best ever? I don't want opinions, everyone has there own. I want you to show me, a non-believer, how it is the #1 game of all time. I wont agree with you, but at least you will have made a valid point, and you can rise to actual fan and not simple fanboy.

1. If OoT isnt the best game ever, than what exactly is :?

2. Im sure if you were to compare other games that got 10's, there average would be even lower than OoT's.....still making it the best game ever. I think its the best game ever because....

A. For its time (i dont know when you first played it), there was NOTHING out there even remotely like it. It had gameplay that was simple, unique, addictive, and still challenging..... and it still has one of the best stories ive ever read. I find all of the connections in Zelda games to be very immersive, especially considering they all link back to OoT.

B. It of course is my favorite game, and I have a lot of memories from playing it when i was younger



I played it the day it was released, and yes I agree with you on all of your points, it is still not good enough to say it is above all else the best game ever. As for your question of what is the best game of all time I'd have to say Super Mario Bros, (this is not my favorite game of all time mind you) but to this day it has sold more copies than any other game... or any 2 games for that matter in gaming history and made way for the most popular line of games, period. Again this is not my favorite series, but Mario is the most recognizable video game character and has the largest, longest running, and most profitable game series to date.

i can see your point and partly agree....but overall i still think OoT is the best game ever



And thus ends the argument (if it could even be called an argument) we both understand the others opinion and both made valid points to our claims. Not that my personal opinion of you should matter, but you present yourself as a true fan and not just another fanboy by stating actual reason for your opinion other than "IT SCORED 10's!". My original post was never supposed to turn into this debate anyway but Squidward acted childish when trying to prove a point that subsequently he didn't even follow up on and you had to take over and did a much better job of anyway.
Avatar image for kryptofreak120
kryptofreak120

5524

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 15

User Lists: 0

#25 kryptofreak120
Member since 2005 • 5524 Posts
Zelda: Link to the Past - 11 Star Fox - 1 Metroid - 1 Super Mario Brothers 3 - 11 Ocarina of Time - 7 Golden Eye:007 - 5 Kid Icarus - 5 Super Bomberman - 7 Balloon Fight - 5 Castlevania - 7 Mario Brothers - 6 Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars - 7