Alan Wake, or Red Dead?

Im kinda torn on which game to get and I think that both will be good games, however there is something inside of me that says that Alan Wake is more likely to be disappointing and not live up to expectations. I think if done correctly Alan wake could get a score in the 9.5 range, but if done incorrectly it will end up in the 7.5 range. I think Red Dead is the more safe pick, I think its ceiling is lower but I think it has better odds of being an overall good game, in the 8.0 range to 9.2 range. I just hope Alan Wake has enough content in it. I was a little saddened with how short Splinter Cell was, and I know they are totally diff games, but I just hate it when they make games so short even though the game itself was really good. I guess I just like longer games like Fallout 3, or Mass effect, or Halo and MW2 with all the coop stuff. Sorry if Im rambling on incoherently I am just getting what I think off my mind so sorry if this whole post doesnt make much sense lol. What do you guys think?

iam getting both but ill go with red since it has MP

Red Dead will have a good review because of hype too, Alan Wake is not as anticipated as Red Dead and Remedy likes that. I really want to see Alan Wake get a good score, I don't like Rockstar because they made GTA and I have a feeling that Red Dead will be nothing but a western GTA with more nudity, I don't want to see or play any of that.