Best Xbox 360 RPG

Hey everyone, I'm looking for a good RPG. It's been a long time since I've played a good RPG; in fact, the last one I really loved was Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic. Since then I've been hard pressed to find anything that even remotely satisfies me. It's a shame my PS3 doesn't have BC because I was really interested in picking up Persona 4...

Anyways, here are the RPG's I've tried and didn't really like:

1. Oblivion- Supposedly the best RPG ever made...in my opinion it was BORING!

2. Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2- Story wasn't really interesting or compelling, got bored of it a couple of hours in.

3. Final Fantasy XII- Such high hopes, such a disappointment to me...

4. Final Fantasy X- Very good RPG, but it's hard to live up to Final Fantasy VII...

So yeah...here are the RPG's I'm looking at. Which do you think would be best for me?

I've played some of Fallout 3 and I like it, but I'm worried it'll be like Oblivion all over again...I just got out of the bunker for the 1st time..

Valkyria Chronicles is REALLY cool, but I have a bunch of PS3 games and if possible, I'd like to boost up my 360 collection. If anyone has played VC AND any of the afforementioned 360 games, please comment for me. I'd like to know what you think.

Never played Fable, but heard great things about it. My best friend's favorite game, but he hated Fable 2...

Mass Effect is here because BioWare made the last RPG that really blew me away...

Eternal Sonata is there because I heard it was a good game...

HELP!

i might be kind of biased going for Fallout 3 since Morrowind, not Oblivion, was one of many favorite gmaes ever

Fallout 3 is not like Oblivion wiht guns and ive gotten the most enjoyment out of my 360 playing Fallout 3

Fable 2... It's witty, charming, has CO-OP, and replay value. Also, they are adding a DLC expansion for it on Jan.13

Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2- Story wasn't really interesting or compelling, got bored of it a couple of hours in. knicknut17

Eternal Sonata is there because I heard it was a good gameknicknut17

Thanks for all of your help. I decided to go with Mass Effect because at $14.99, why not??!?!?

I'm done with the 1st mission and about half way done with the 2nd one and so far I'm really liking the game a lot. The graphics are really detailed for an RPG and the story is quite interesting...I was actually looking for Tales of Vesperia at my local Gamestop, but they didn't have a copy with an original cover and manual (I'm a collector) so I'm going to hold off on that for a little while.

I actually prefer the story to be somewhat linear. Sandbox games drive me crazy sometimes because many times, I find them to be too open ended. I'll be sure to pick up Fallout 3 when Gamestop does a Buy 2 Get 1 Free sale or something like that. Target was selling the game for $39.99, but they sold out real quick...

Anyways, thanks for all of your help. Mass Effect looks like a really special RPG in my book.

This thread just sheds light on how crappy Xbox RPG's are. That and there are hardly any of them. Whatever happened to the Action Adventure Role Playing Games of Yester-Year?

2. Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic 2- Story wasn't really interesting or compelling, got bored of it a couple of hours in.

Fallout 3 :)

I've dismissed F3 being an rpg solely for the fact that it uses guns. So, I'd say Eternal Sonata.