Bioshock or Assasin's Creed?!

I've been having a large debate with my friends over which is better, Bioshock or Assasin's Creed. They all say Assasin's Creed, but I think it's mainly because they aren't into FPS. And I guess it all depends on your point of view, but as a player of both and a liker of both FPS and RPG, I say Bioshock. I think the storyline is more in depth. And the graphics kill me. And I could play it over and over and over and OVER and never get bored. Don't get me wrong, though, I love AC too. But what do you think?

Maddi 8)

I would go with bioshock its a really hot game

but it scared me sometimes

but its still very fun to play

u should get it

Bioshock does seem to be more in dept. Although I only tried the demo it really sucked me into the game immediately and I really felt like there were cyborg-zombies in my dark basement at the time. I had no idea what to expect from the story line, but I was pleasantly surprised. I can remember running to a corner and franticly looking around with my wrench when I was at one point trapped in a movie theater as if my life really depended on it, unlike AC in which I felt like I was playing a game.

AC was fun, yet I feel like it was the same mission over and over, and it really never was hard for me. Reminded me a lot of hitman in the way it allows you to go about the assassinations by force or stealth and it's pretty much open ended. A really fun concept, yet the actual missions could be fine tuned better. Not worth the 60 dollars (at the time) imo.

In all I would say Bioshock takes the cake for it's game play and story line, in fact I should go buy it .....

Just rent them both

In my opinion they both have no replayablity

Go with Bioshock.

Assassins Creed is a horrible game.

is this a joke? i didnt know you could even compare the two. you should read my reviews on both games, very brutally honest opinions there for you backed up with good reasons for my opinion. bioshock wins hands down.makchady

[QUOTE="makchady"]is this a joke? i didnt know you could even compare the two. you should read my reviews on both games, very brutally honest opinions there for you backed up with good reasons for my opinion. bioshock wins hands down.Strife88

ah hahahahaha yeah i thoroughly enjoyed assassins creed's story.............until the cliffhanger that made halo 2's ending look like a masterpiece. the present day parts were incredibly pointless and the whole plot in general was so far fetched its not even funny. but you can stand as a one man army because i guarentee you that far more people will say that assassins creed was a redundant piece of crap.

BIOSHOCK WINS! No competition. That was my favorite game of 2007. Assasins Creed was so boring to me.

i would definately take bioshock becuz it is a thriller in my opinion :)

wow... i never thought I'd have to choose between two games good enough for only rentals...

well, even though i think Bioshock is overrated, at least it's not as repetitive as AC

Bioshock, due to its story and customization of the character and the action is good.

While Assasins Creed is a good game it is limited in what you can do and there is hardly and gameplay changes throughout the whole game.

I love it how some people are telling TC to get one of the games... as if it he/she didn't already play them and is just asking for our opinions to settle a debte between him/her and his/her friends. He said he played both! don't you people read?

anyways, I prefered bioshock over AC by far, AC was such a traditional and archaic adventure game at times, but bioshock was a satisfying and deep game.

Thats a tough one.

i love both games

bioshock has a way better story and kept me entertained all the way though

Assin's Creed has some really badass moments, like the first real assassination. its amazing, but the rest of the game gets repetitive

altho both games are amazing, i say bioshock

It would definately have to be Bioshock- great atmosphere, great story, great graphics, great gameplay. Whereas Assassins Creed is quite repetitive and sometimes boring, such as when you have to travel to other cities via horseback. The graphics are pretty sweet though.

I would go with Assassins Creed.

I prefered Assassin's Creed over Bioshock.

Both are very good games, but Bioshock didn't suck me in like I thought it would. On the other hand I do really like stealthy games, and AC allows you to play that way, though it doesn't force you to - it's as stealthy as you choose to make it be

BioShock.

Bioshock for sure. Crazy fun gameplay with expansive player abilities, and a haunting enviornment that could only be described as Disney Land on a bad acid trip.

Assasin's Creed was ok, fairly repetetive, with ridiculous deathbed conversations and a plot not fit for the bad REMAKE of The Twilight Zone.

uhhh I kind of regret buying Assassin's Creed.

It is one of the view games I would never bother playing through again... ever.

really different games, but if I had to pick I would go with Bioshock all the way