Bioshock or Half-Life 2?

I believe these two games are very comparable; so which do you think does the story driven tactical FPS adventure better: Bioshock or Half-Life 2?

I personally think it's too close to call. Both are just so amazing and immersive.

they arent very tactical they are just both awesome and atmospheric, but yeah its too hard to say. i loved every minute of both of them

Bioshock is just a better game overall, HL2 helped bring gaming into the same spotlight as movies, but Bioshock is just an all-time great.

i enjoyed HL2 a lot more than Bioshock

HL2 was so much better to me. The music, atmosphere, characters, all of it was just fantastic.

Bioshock beats down HL2 on graphics, but I like the story more.

you can't go wrong with either one.

you can't go wrong with either one.

dwarfwasonfire

Man that is a hard decision both games rock. Bioshock is a great game espcially played with surround sound in a dark room. Half-Life is a great game in it's own right, but the Orange Box version is probably the best gaming value for the 360 and PC ever made. 5 Games in one package, all of them stellar, not to mention one of them is Portal which is a dramatcially underated game. Get them both, they both are replayable over and over.

you can't go wrong with either one.

dwarfwasonfire

they arent very tactical they are just both awesome and atmospheric, but yeah its too hard to say. i loved every minute of both of them

tomrocks666

I prefer Half-Life. I like the characters. Bioshock was often a lonely experience.

I prefer Half-Life. I like the characters. Bioshock was often a lonely experience.

Palantas

I prefer Half-Life. I like the characters. Bioshock was often a lonely experience.

Palantas

Bioshock. One of my all time favorites.

Half Life 2 all the way in every way possible. the only thing Bioshock has over it would be the graphics, but otherwise Half Life 2 takes the cakebulletsword

The cake is a Lie.

Bioshock. Simply that.