Call of Duty 3 or Lost Planet?

I have XBL and a HDTV, so which game is best in terms of gameplay, graphics and longevity (not too bothered about sound or story)?

CoD 3 has a far superior MP and better story and dialogue.

Would you recommend getting both, in time?SpartanMonk

CoD 4 or 5

newbie_bob

wtf this guy's bumping old topics like no other..

Call of duty 3 pretty fun a little harder to find ranked matches but its fun. There is a lostplanet demo you should download cause if your looking for graphics lost planets probably better. But I like Cod 3

I've got both, and agree, Lost Planet is a very under rated game. They are very different games. Lost planet if you want to concentrate

on the challenge of killing one gigantic alien at a time. If you like the war genre, and just want to charge forward kill the bad guys, and blow up

all their crap, than COD is for you.

Personally I enjoy playing COD. I get bored killing the bugs, and like the challenge of war games. It's a matter of preference when you have two

good games like these.

I like the acheivement for CoD3 for not firing a round