Controller Problem (Brand New)

Just got the new controller with the tranforming d pad. I notice a problem that when playing Rage if I moved the thumbstick slighty to the right the aimer would still move right slowly. Its actually really annoying and I have to make sure the stick is perfectly in the middle. This problem accured with Call of Duty and Gears. Anyway I can fix this, or should I just take it back.?

I don't know. Because I played my controller today, and it had the same problem. Then my friend brought his over and it happened to that one as well....and to make matters even more suckier, we borrowed one from my cousin up the street and it did it on his as well....i don't think this is coincidence.

It could be all of the Controllers and X-boxes across America. Conspiring to overtake our interest and then shatter them when the controllers don't end up working.

I will try and take it back for a new one. The weird thing is I have 2 controllers that are older and dont do that.