Do you think GTA IV deserved a 10!!!

its not perfect, so maybe a 9.5 or 9.75H_U_R_D

I agree. Cause no game will ever be perfect.

Nope. I played it for like 4 hours and haven't touched it since.callen3

Haha..my case is similar. I passed the story with both endings and haven't touched it ever since. I was surprised of how fast i put down the game....b4 i got it i was thinkin i would last a long time playin it cuz of the new online and stuff but to my surprise its stayed in its case

I am one of the lots of people that think it was perfection and more than likely will get GOTY.:)

nope it deserved a 12+

how can you lower a game just because you are bored of it ???..you kids are clowns

I'd give it a 9.

To me there is no game I've played that deserves a 10, not because I'm one of those people who think the game needs to be perfect, It's just I always find something that I don't like about a game, even though, it won't make me dislike the game more.

I'd give it a 9.

To me there is no game I've played that deserves a 10, not because I'm one of those people who think the game needs to be perfect, It's just I always find something that I don't like about a game, even though, it won't make me dislike the game more.

TheCaveRat

Well if the description says perfect, I would say that if it gets a 10 it should be perfect.

10? Not quite.

But...

Should 1 review on 1 website be taken as the be all end all of how good a game is? Definitely No.

I personally think the game is a 9 or 9.5 at the most, i could also live with an 8.5

But in the end someones review is just a personal opinion, if its the best game they ever played then thats fine.

Guy who said a 7 lol you deserve a kick in the groin area, I dont care if you dont like it, the game is worthy of a 10 thats why it got one.

Guy who said a 7 lol you deserve a kick in the groin area, I dont care if you dont like it, the game is worthy of a 10 thats why it got one.

pupu_07

no, the reviewers of gamespot after playing it for a day or so felt it deserved a 10, not the entire community that gave it a 10 on this site

Not at all. 9.5 at best.

I never said the entire community gave it a 10, not making alot of sense there sorry noob.pupu_07

hahahahah i got called a noob, how offensive :P

No game deserves a 10, because no game is perfect. Grand Theft Auto is not perfect. It's good. Really well polished down to the last quest. However, you can critique anything about the game. There is always something wrong. For instance the game is neither challenging nor is it easy. Gamers like myself do not like easy and we want something challenging. I found the game easy. After a certain Mission, you get 250,000$, and after that, money ment nothing. You basically get an infinite amount of ammo, and money doesn't really mean anything after that.

How can anyone take gamespot reviews seriously? I rarely agree on most of their reviews. It's just an opinion. MAKE YOUR OWN.

This topic has beeen way to many times....

an the anwser is no not even close.

[QUOTE="H_U_R_D"]its not perfect, so maybe a 9.5 or 9.75Lunchbucket16

thats true no game is perfect..if a game is really good it should get a 9.9 cus there is allways room for improvement

I agree. Cause no game will ever be perfect.

10? Not quite.

But...

Should 1 review on 1 website be taken as the be all end all of how good a game is? Definitely No.

funkyeyk

it got a 10 on ign as well...

`nope it deserves a 6 at least , ecause

1 lack of originality, isnt it obvious , driver paralel lines excelled in crash modeling ,, now rockstar copies that , gta iv looks like driver paralel lines to much ,

2 the physics-rag doll, saints row any one,

3 they took alot of the goods out and the variety of cars . missions and such is no longer as good, no planes, missions to repetitive all i seam to be instructed to do is kill kill kill mostly like saints row, san andreas was alot more better, they did not always have you kill some one,

they had you collect kill steal etc,

and what makes the game worst is its online componant,

people cheat on racing,

and free mode isnt free at all , with people talkin trash booting you for killing them or such and i thought it were free mode, meaning do what you want when you want as long as you want,

rockstar should taKE THE BOOT OPTION OUT OF ITS FREE MODE, its ridiculous, also , just yesterday i was in free mode , i was booted for taking a red infernus off the streets from some ai . cant wait till they get it right, san andreas owns 4 in many ways , hey migh as well take out the online portion when they do 5 ,

the online overrides the singleplayer in my opinion , they cared less for the single player expeirence, ,

and the story was not as good or interisting, they said 100 buildings youd be able to go in, hmm thats funny how i never found all 100 buildings, ive finished the game to ,

no bmx bikes no campers no atvs nothing of those sorts,

also the sound track completely blows, one song is good while all the others are meh

so all in all for me gta iv was a big step backwards, and towards driver quality, if you catch my drift,

over hyped over rated thats it nothing more,

the worst part is your cribs, no garages no free ammo no nothing ,

saints row driver paralel lines, gta 3-san andreas all had some or all the above,

wow they have working tvs, very gay if youi ask me,

i rather watch my whole dvd collection then watch a tv in game through my tv lol , speaking of graphics, did rockstar even try, driver paralel lines, definatelly is better looking ,

and saints row as well ,

oh and no tanks, and a radious cop thing , as for health ars and such they copied saints row , same for cell phones,

My initial reaction was a 10. But after playing it for a couple of weeks I realised it just wasn't as fun as San Andreas. I would give it 8.5 cos they took more out than they put in.

And, No Roman I do not want to go bowling with you, so stop fn ringing me.

`nope it deserves a 6 at least , ecause

1 lack of originality, isnt it obvious , driver paralel lines excelled in crash modeling ,, now rockstar copies that , gta iv looks like driver paralel lines to much ,

2 the physics-rag doll, saints row any one,

3 they took alot of the goods out and the variety of cars . missions and such is no longer as good, no planes, missions to repetitive all i seam to be instructed to do is kill kill kill mostly like saints row, san andreas was alot more better, they did not always have you kill some one,

they had you collect kill steal etc,

and what makes the game worst is its online componant,

people cheat on racing,

and free mode isnt free at all , with people talkin trash booting you for killing them or such and i thought it were free mode, meaning do what you want when you want as long as you want,

rockstar should taKE THE BOOT OPTION OUT OF ITS FREE MODE, its ridiculous, also , just yesterday i was in free mode , i was booted for taking a red infernus off the streets from some ai . cant wait till they get it right, san andreas owns 4 in many ways , hey migh as well take out the online portion when they do 5 ,

the online overrides the singleplayer in my opinion , they cared less for the single player expeirence, ,

and the story was not as good or interisting, they said 100 buildings youd be able to go in, hmm thats funny how i never found all 100 buildings, ive finished the game to ,

no bmx bikes no campers no atvs nothing of those sorts,

also the sound track completely blows, one song is good while all the others are meh

so all in all for me gta iv was a big step backwards, and towards driver quality, if you catch my drift,

over hyped over rated thats it nothing more,

the worst part is your cribs, no garages no free ammo no nothing ,

saints row driver paralel lines, gta 3-san andreas all had some or all the above,

wow they have working tvs, very gay if youi ask me,

i rather watch my whole dvd collection then watch a tv in game through my tv lol , speaking of graphics, did rockstar even try, driver paralel lines, definatelly is better looking ,

and saints row as well ,

oh and no tanks, and a radious cop thing , as for health ars and such they copied saints row , same for cell phones,

mariokart64fan